FRANCE24 — broadcast 20261102 033000 UTC 460 transcript segments Google Cloud Speech-to-Text API (Chirp) + Gemini 2.5 Flash Non-Thinking Data courtesy of The GDELT Project (https://www.gdeltproject.org/), from the Internet Archive TV News Archive. Machine transcription. Treat it as a searchable index of what was broadcast, not a verbatim quotation record. [00:00:00] of large companies which, for once, are doing rather well because they have a [00:00:03] lot of international activity and a fabric of SMEs and ETIs which [00:00:07] suffer in the territories because they are dependent on these order delays, in [00:00:13] with Laurent, that is to say, basically, one fact, and we don't see this polarization well, so there is despair [00:00:15] and and what this translates into is one thing, it's the confidence shock, [00:00:18] today what is happening is a confidence shock which means that basically we [00:00:22] don't invest, we consume little and wait to see if it will [00:00:25] improve, and and besides, the slowdown ends up affecting [00:00:29] employment? unemployment has risen again, it concerns [00:00:32] 8.3% of the active population in the 2nd quarter of [00:00:35] 2026, which is 0.2 points more than in the previous [00:00:39] quarter, Laurent Vronski, is this also something that you perceive, you who in [00:00:43] your sector had trouble hiring for a long time? Absolutely, and besides, [00:00:47] I wanted to come back to the question you asked madam, if it was a surprise to have [00:00:51] the figures for the 3rd quarter, which were bad. We, industrialists, work [00:00:54] with a whole network of subcontractors, and one of the key indicators is [00:00:58] production capacity, meaning that... when you have subcontractors who [00:01:01] extend delivery times, you know that it's going very well for them, and conversely, when they [00:01:05] shorten them, it means that it's going very badly, so we've seen that [00:01:08] since, I'd say, the beginning of the year, and what we see is [00:01:12] that little by little, for almost all the positions for which we recruit, since we are almost in [00:01:15] permanent recruitment, there were positions where there were chronically no [00:01:19] candidates, and now we have candidates again, [00:01:22] so there is really something happening, and we saw that before the figures were published, [00:01:26] hmm hmm, something you also perceived in your sector, [00:01:30] so we also recruit and have trouble [00:01:33] recruiting, [00:01:35] it's really problematic. In reality, what we observe, and we will certainly talk about it later, is that there is [00:01:39] a lack of integration today [00:01:42] and finally, new technology, between... I confirm, we will talk about it later. First, let's talk about the other bad news of the [00:01:45] day, this Friday, it's inflation. In October, consumer [00:01:49] prices rose by 3.4% after [00:01:52] 3.1% in September. Véronique [00:01:55] Richfores, this constant and persistent [00:01:58] price increase, does it [00:02:00] worry [00:02:03] you? Well, listen, [00:02:06] etc., the price of in any case, it's an evolution that considerably [00:02:09] hinders the economic [00:02:11] revolution of situation, especially in France. Why? Because France [00:02:14] is one of the countries, well, the European country, by the way, in which salary [00:02:18] growth has been the weakest in recent years. So when you have [00:02:21] growth, a 2% growth [00:02:25] in salaries and inflation is at 3.8%, [00:02:29] there you go, you know the result, these are losses in purchasing [00:02:32] power that indeed punish the [00:02:35] consumer. It is, and [00:02:39] I think that indeed, France is not an exception, I assure you, [00:02:42] 3.8% or in [00:02:45] France, Italy released an inflation of 5.4% [00:02:49] today, Spain is at 5%, Germany, because we [00:02:52] lowered energy taxation, has come down to [00:02:57] OECD and IMF 2.8, but was at 3.2, I think, last month, so... a [00:03:00] general phenomenon and uh but one that is more severely [00:03:03] felt in France because wage growth is the weakest, [00:03:07] and this situation of loss of purchasing [00:03:10] power is not new, it has been going on for several years. So we had [00:03:14] efforts to make in terms of competitiveness, and I believe these [00:03:17] efforts are beginning [00:03:20] changes, five years of to bear fruit, and we see it in the industrial performance of inhabitants. France. We have seen it, in any case, over the last 18 months, relatively, for example, to [00:03:24] Germany and so on, but at some point, [00:03:28] uh, we must be aware that households are under [00:03:31] constraint, and [00:03:34] that adding to these efforts of purchasing power [00:03:37] or to these constraints of purchasing power, a price shock [00:03:41] quickly becomes unbearable, and I think this is truly what [00:03:45] aggravates the anger today in France, which is not only a [00:03:49] phenomenon among high school students, but a much more general phenomenon, and [00:03:52] which considerably complicates the budget equation, because [00:03:56] if there is this weakness, this fragility of households, then [00:04:00] there is less and less room for maneuver on the budgetary front, in any case, the situation is certainly more delicate, [00:04:04] and we can perhaps say that this inflation is here to stay, in any [00:04:07] case, perhaps the energy part, the crisis in the Gulf of [00:04:11] Hormuz is not [00:04:14] about political instability of resolved, the war in the Middle East is here to stay, [00:04:17] how far can this so, the oil prices must still be above $116 [00:04:20] as we speak, in any case they were earlier, the [00:04:24] tensions, the situation in the Gulf is very uncertain. I could [00:04:28] tell you but tomorrow prices will collapse. [00:04:30] Some said it in April or June, ultimately [00:04:34] we know nothing. What we do know is that today the probability that tensions will persist is high. [00:04:38] The other element is that it's not just petrol, but all raw materials that are [00:04:42] heavily in demand, particularly by AI and by the development needs of AI [00:04:45] infrastructure, which also [00:04:49] diffuse or have diffused inflationary pressures on [00:04:52] prices. How can you absorb this increase? I mean, do you [00:04:56] already feel this increase in costs and this crisis too? [00:05:01] Well, if you want, we use copper, [00:05:04] aluminum, steel, in short, all the raw materials that go well. Copper [00:05:07] is very widely used, especially in everything related to [00:05:10] electrical production. There's an interesting thing, it's not just a phenomenon [00:05:14] of supply and demand, there's also a geopolitical game, meaning that today, you have [00:05:18] concentrations of know-how, for example, we talk a lot about rare [00:05:21] earths which are held by, whose processing capacity is held [00:05:25] by China at over 80%, but it's not just them. For example, a phenomenon that is [00:05:29] completely ignored, tungsten. So people know tungsten because before we made [00:05:33] lamp filaments, but tungsten is used for all cutting tools that [00:05:37] are used to machine parts, metal [00:05:40] parts. Who holds a... monopoly? China. So [00:05:44] obviously it plays on that. So if you want, today raw materials are [00:05:48] also used according to geopolitical [00:05:51] news to be able to obtain results at the level of international [00:05:55] politics. So obviously we are on the front line and it's [00:05:58] always quite a challenge to pass on raw material price increases [00:06:02] to the end customer. [00:06:05] Now I'm a little more optimistic. No one around this [00:06:08] table is a clairvoyant, myself first, but I really think that in terms of hydrocarbons, [00:06:12] it's an epi-phenomenon linked to the conflict in the Middle East. I am convinced, because that's what we [00:06:15] experienced after COVID, that when peace [00:06:19] returns, I mean, I think that things... the question is when, [00:06:22] but I can't say when. I am not Madame Soleil. [00:06:26] To build its budget, the government is still counting on 1% [00:06:29] growth next year. Véronique Richel, is this [00:06:33] hypothesis still credible? [00:06:36] Well, listen, for our part, we had a forecast of - [00:06:40] 0.5 before the publication of this morning's figures. [00:06:42] Uh, precisely, [00:06:46] because the international environment is what it is, because [00:06:49] the prospect of seeing oil prices fall [00:06:53] rapidly and [00:06:55] remain low, because the rise in interest [00:06:58] rates penalizes [00:07:02] business activity in terms of investment, not necessarily in [00:07:06] industry but in many others, and particularly SMEs. [00:07:09] It penalizes real estate, of course, and this morning's [00:07:12] figures were particularly harsh in that regard. [00:07:15] And because the global economy itself, which is [00:07:19] driven by an extraordinary phenomenon, which is this [00:07:24] AI, seems to us to be [00:07:27] exposed to a change of course in this area [00:07:31] from the moment that investors indeed start to be much more [00:07:34] demanding about the debt of companies and what we call the [00:07:38] American hyperscalers in the field. So all this, [00:07:42] with the copy available at the time of the finance [00:07:46] bill, since our forecasts were finalized on October [00:07:49] 7th, led us indeed to consider 0.5%, [00:07:53] and I think there is a real issue there with the [00:07:56] multiplier used by government teams [00:07:59] to draw up their budget. And [00:08:02] there have been errors, not so long ago, ten years ago, [00:08:06] after the recommendations of the IMF, the [00:08:09] officials, telling us, "Excuse us, we made a mistake, [00:08:13] we had a multiplier of 0.5, it was actually much higher than [00:08:16] 1." That's really the mistake that must absolutely be avoided, it seems to me, [00:08:20] today. As a reminder, the deficit is expected to reach 5.4% of national [00:08:23] wealth this year, as for debt, it continues to increase [00:08:27] to reach 120% of national wealth. Laurent Bonscrit, how in these [00:08:31] conditions can we reach the objective of 5% [00:08:34] of GDP in 2027? You [00:08:37] have 3 hours, this is not this is not one, this is not one show that is needed. [00:08:40] Huh, several are needed, [00:08:43] uh, I don't have the magic answer, but I think that [00:08:46] there are safeguards, meaning that we talk about [00:08:50] growth, I think that first of all, we must do everything to [00:08:53] try to stimulate this growth and prevent [00:08:56] the country from collapsing [00:08:59] with negative growth, and precisely how to reduce the [00:09:02] deficit without aggravating, well, without you know, the deficit, the deficit is, well, [00:09:06] if you want, it's like a bathtub, there's a tap running and bringing water, there's a plug, so if the... [00:09:10] is wider than the flow that [00:09:12] comes in, there's a deficit, but if it's the opposite, well, then I'd say we create prosperity, we create [00:09:16] wealth for everyone. Now, if you want, I must tell you, and this will be my little [00:09:20] moment of impertinence, where I'm a bit annoyed is that I have the impression that suddenly [00:09:23] there are a lot of people who are discovering, especially at the government [00:09:27] level, that there is debt, that there are deficits. We've been talking about it for [00:09:30] quite a few years now, it's accelerating, especially since the COVID crisis. [00:09:33] Well, yes, but if you want, it's not a discovery either, because the debt as [00:09:37] we know it today, 1600 billion euros, doesn't contract in the blink of an eye. [00:09:41] So it's unfortunately the culmination of [00:09:44] decades of, in my opinion, mismanagement. [00:09:47] So what is to be feared is that today, as we are in a certain [00:09:50] urgency at the economic and social level, [00:09:53] I don't feel, if you want, a vision for the country, and I think that to manage [00:09:57] to reduce the deficit, we need to do a little more than traditional [00:10:01] surgical strikes, saying, "Oh, we'll do a little measure for this, then we'll do a little [00:10:05] measure for that." And what I see so far is that we are more in the realm of little measures and not [00:10:08] really in structural reforms. So, structural reforms, you're thinking of pensions, [00:10:12] you're thinking, you know, I mean, around [00:10:16] this table, there are already two business leaders, [00:10:18] who have gone through crises, who have gone through... upheavals, and when we [00:10:22] are in difficult situations, there are no taboos to have, and we put everything on the table [00:10:26] to try, I would say, to preserve kinetic [00:10:29] energy. I think that's exactly what needs to be done at the country level, but first, give a [00:10:32] vision. I don't feel much vision right now. Eric de la Noire, no, but I'm, well, I agree [00:10:38] of the problems of the economy today is that it doesn't provide a medium-term vision, and [00:10:42] it doesn't provide hope that would restore confidence. Again, the economy [00:10:45] runs on confidence. As long as we don't provide visibility on what we're doing [00:10:49] structurally, it won't work. Their purchasing power, yes, people who complain [00:10:53] about their purchasing power, in any case, they will have to get used to making efforts, [00:10:57] so complaining about purchasing power all the time does not solve the problems. If we think that it [00:11:00] is always others who will have to make efforts to solve the problems, it will [00:11:04] never work. I remind you that there is a study from INSEE that has just been released, which shows that purchasing [00:11:08] power and the loss of purchasing power are very unequal depending [00:11:12] on the social classes. Popular [00:11:15] classes, particularly workers, very [00:11:18] popular classes, have done very well over these last 10 [00:11:21] years. Middle classes have not done well at all and have been limited by tax [00:11:25] cuts, and upper classes have benefited. So the drop in purchasing [00:11:29] power is not as dramatic as that, contrary to what we hear. What [00:11:33] is needed is to put in place indeed very structural effects. Structural [00:11:36] effects are what? They are investing. So we talk [00:11:39] about investment, it will start with... but yes, [00:11:42] but if we don't invest, we're dead, [00:11:46] in fact. So we are pushing for a "Pact France" with decisions [00:11:50] about getting out of deficits, about the 3%, the famous 3%. [00:11:53] But no, but in the accounting, we should take out investment expenses when [00:11:57] we can measure investment expenses. One of the debacles we've been seeing for [00:12:01] these famous decades is that when we see those who govern us, it's hard [00:12:05] to imagine that they know the difference, that they know the difference between an [00:12:09] investment and an expense. And so we're doing anything, in reality. So investments [00:12:12] are obviously in technological infrastructures, a massive [00:12:15] investment to be made in education. Education today is [00:12:19] the investment of tomorrow. So today, you know, you have the Council of Economic [00:12:22] Analysis, which has produced a rather remarkable paper on what needs [00:12:26] to be done to recover, taking the example of Portugal and England. It costs [00:12:30] 4 billion euros per year, it would be repaid by the decline in demographics. [00:12:34] Let's start by listening to these people who have experience in international [00:12:37] observation. We can have that in any case. It is not indeed either [00:12:40] by surgical strikes nor by the fact that, for example, we reduce [00:12:44] grants to associations which are still the last bulwark of social [00:12:48] cohesion, and they are all experiencing the current situation very [00:12:52] badly. That's how we will get there. So let's resume a, [00:12:55] finally, what are the future prospects? How do we [00:12:58] ensure that we give confidence to the French, and I don't [00:13:02] hear much about that today. You want to add something? Yes, in fact I [00:13:06] link that to the previous subject. Uh, less [00:13:09] growth, even recession, that will be [00:13:12] less tax revenue, it seems to me. Uh, [00:13:16] plus 3.4% inflation compared [00:13:20] to salaries. Madam, you said earlier that salaries had increased less. We should [00:13:23] look at private sector salaries, public sector [00:13:26] salaries, pensions, uh, the [00:13:29] the, how to say, what people receive in various social [00:13:33] benefits and so on. As a business owner [00:13:36] and having worked with several hundred, even several thousand, I don't [00:13:39] have the impression that salaries are growing [00:13:42] slower than inflation, quite the contrary. And also, [00:13:46] one last thing, civil servants are the big losers in reality. Uh, [00:13:49] in any case, private sector employees, I don't have that impression, [00:13:53] and as far as inflation is concerned, I would still like to say that, for [00:13:57] example, the rise in the cost of raw materials, starting [00:14:00] with energy, impacts first and foremost [00:14:03] businesses. The big consumers of energy [00:14:07] today are businesses, and it is businesses [00:14:10] that are taking the hit. So France, to talk about investment, must [00:14:13] also borrow more and more expensively. Debt interest continues [00:14:17] to rise, it is approaching 5%. It is about to become the state's largest [00:14:20] budget item, ahead of education, ahead of [00:14:24] defense. Uh, obviously this has repercussions for French people who also [00:14:28] want to buy a property, for example. Véronique Riche Leres, what does [00:14:31] this increase tell us? We see it there over the last six months of [00:14:34] the year. What is it? Are the markets worried about public accounts, [00:14:39] both, and perhaps [00:14:42] increase go? Uh, probably both, with however [00:14:46] a absolutely necessary clarification, because otherwise [00:14:49] we risk making the wrong diagnosis. The [00:14:53] movement is global, [00:14:55] well, it is global, it is common to all industrialized [00:14:58] countries, that is a very important starting point. [00:15:02] It started in Japan, by the way, and in the United States. [00:15:06] We can find all sorts of explanations. I think it is [00:15:09] strongly linked indeed to the aging process and the fact that the older [00:15:13] we get, the less capital is available, [00:15:17] confronted with the surge in financing needs related to the [00:15:20] technological transition. So on the one hand, you [00:15:23] have the prospect of less available capital, on the other, companies that [00:15:26] will need this capital, and a certain [00:15:30] competition between private needs and public [00:15:33] sector financing. We have seen that recently in [00:15:36] France, as in the United States, by the way, companies have managed to finance themselves at [00:15:39] lower rates than the state, which is historical, [00:15:43] and because this aging is synonymous [00:15:46] with increasing difficulties indeed of the [00:15:50] public sector because there are pensions, there is health because there are [00:15:53] fewer active people who generate less [00:15:57] public revenue, so all this makes [00:16:00] us add to that a president of the American central bank who [00:16:03] has not entirely reassured about his ability to contain [00:16:07] inflation, means that interest rates have started to rise [00:16:11] everywhere. France has risen like the rest of the other [00:16:15] economies until about this summer, and then [00:16:19] since this summer, early summer, mid-summer, I don't know, around mid-summer, August, I [00:16:22] think, French interest rates have started to rise [00:16:26] much faster than others, and particularly than those of [00:16:29] our neighbors, Germany. Why? We are looking [00:16:33] for the answer. At that time, there were no social problems yet, public [00:16:36] accounts had been known since 2024, we knew more or less what [00:16:40] we were facing in terms of public finances. On the other hand, [00:16:44] INSEE revised its growth estimates for the first half of [00:16:48] the year, and with a lot of caution, because we are never certain [00:16:52] to have the right explanations, but still it coincided, and this [00:16:55] revision was [00:16:58] massive, it was very badly received. And above all, what did it tell us? Well, [00:17:02] finally, aeronautics, which was the promise of the future for French [00:17:06] industry, they are struggling to produce, they are struggling to meet [00:17:09] deadlines, etc. Military [00:17:12] spending, [00:17:15] well, it's not bearing fruit, [00:17:20] yes, things are undeniably moving, and they have moved faster [00:17:22] in France than elsewhere, it's indisputable. At the beginning of the summer, we [00:17:26] could even start to be a little optimistic about the propagation of [00:17:30] productivity gains to the French economy, and suddenly all this [00:17:33] disappeared, and if you have less growth but still the same [00:17:38] debt problem, then you will start to have a sovereign problem. I [00:17:41] have the impression that it's that before the political [00:17:45] tensions that effectively existed. Go very quickly. Well, I [00:17:48] disagree, I'm not a victim of naive optimism, but against this extremely [00:17:51] bleak vision with aeronautics not keeping its promises, I mean, [00:17:55] you have to remember that at the end of COVID, there was no [00:17:59] aeronautics. Okay, no, forced, it wasn't, [00:18:02] yes, but you don't restart an industrial tool with a whole network of subcontractors [00:18:05] like aeronautics by pressing [00:18:07] a button. It doesn't happen like that. I also remind you that during COVID we [00:18:11] said after COVID we would travel much less, air [00:18:14] traffic would decrease, it's exactly the opposite that happened. So today [00:18:18] we should rejoice, there are many orders, simply the industrial [00:18:21] tool needs, I would say, to get back in order. On [00:18:25] defense, it's the same story, I remind you that for 30 years we've been told [00:18:28] that it's enough to have the atomic bomb. So there we rediscovered that there were [00:18:32] traditional conflicts and we are restarting, if you will, a [00:18:36] military industrial tool that was almost, I would say, like a shadow of its former [00:18:39] self. So I think there are signs that are very positive, simply [00:18:43] we need to give time to time. I mean, we can't solve everything in 50 characters, necessarily [00:18:47] my point, and we can't solve everything, I would say, no, because France has problems, [00:18:50] and as you said, we are not the only ones, but there are also good things, and [00:18:54] I note that there is still a certain natural propensity to only talk [00:18:58] about negative things. Absolutely. Imagine that the end of the world is for next week, [00:19:02] well, I disagree. Go, uh, yeah, I would also like to [00:19:05] add that debt is a global problem, certainly, but the [00:19:09] question is which states can afford it, and it seems to [00:19:13] me that there is a fundamental difference between us and Japan, which is a country I know well. Japanese [00:19:16] debt is held by the Japanese, and ours is not cash. A few [00:19:19] months ago, perhaps last year, there were debates with [00:19:23] people, perhaps even on this set, who said, "Oh, but debt is not serious, anyway, [00:19:27] who cares, it's not a problem." Today [00:19:31] we are starting to consider, to see that it is [00:19:35] a problem, and I'm sorry, but it is a problem for businesses, [00:19:38] meaning I don't know which businesses finance themselves cheaper than [00:19:42] states, I don't know any, but what I see today are [00:19:45] businesses that cannot finance themselves at all, meaning they [00:19:48] are absolutely at zero. I even know people who have [00:19:52] installed a small application on their phone that measures [00:19:55] in real time the evolution of the spread between France... [00:19:59] There you go, and I can tell you that the thing moves continuously, so it's [00:20:02] impressive. We have very little time left, [00:20:06] perhaps to address the [00:20:11] government's proposed responses to the social crisis, [00:20:14] which suggests, among other things, to advance by one month the revaluation [00:20:18] of the minimum wage, which was planned for January [00:20:21] 1st, 2025, 27, and to add a boost, [00:20:25] it could increase by €22 per month. Very [00:20:29] quickly, do you think this boost is [00:20:33] favorable, necessary, will it change things? It's a boost [00:20:36] that, well, doesn't really do much, in reality, why? Because [00:20:39] first, the revaluation of the minimum wage is automatic. In the [00:20:43] study I mentioned earlier, minimum wage earners are those who [00:20:46] have... [00:20:50] d'abord la revalorisation du smic elle est automatique, faut dans [00:20:53] l'étude de lit que j'ai évoqué tout à l'heure, les smikar sont ceux qui [00:20:57] have been doing best for 10 years, right? Inflation has been 23% for [00:21:00] the last six years, the minimum wage [00:21:04] increased by 22.8%, so the minimum wage follows inflation, it is [00:21:08] because it is indexed, so changing, well, revaluing it a month [00:21:11] earlier, for me, it will do nothing, and we are in this realm of small measures to [00:21:15] try to calm things down, but what should be done? Precisely, I think that for me the [00:21:19] big issue is pensions. At some point, we will have to ask ourselves the question of [00:21:23] pensions, once again, in the budget, they don't want to touch the [00:21:26] revaluation, the revaluation of pensions, one point of pension revaluation [00:21:30] is 3.5 billion euros for the state, one point (is) 3.5 [00:21:34] billion euros, and when we know that every time we have revalued [00:21:37] pensions in the last three years, 75% of this [00:21:41] revaluation went into savings accounts, well, I tell myself that we will [00:21:44] have to be very selective about this revaluation, by ensuring that [00:21:48] below a threshold that is not mine to [00:21:51] determine, but that we can set at the level of the median salary, uh, we [00:21:55] can not revalue for a long time and we freeze it, in reality, that will make [00:21:59] incredible savings, [00:22:01] of course, of course, we see the measures of several, a round table, since he doesn't have [00:22:05] much time, what would be the measure to restore purchasing power to the [00:22:09] French without completely unbalancing the accounts? [00:22:12] And so I think that a much more substantial increase [00:22:15] in the minimum wage could make sense because [00:22:18] the 22 zeros make absolutely no sense, [00:22:22] it would be extremely difficult for our companies to implement over the foreseeable [00:22:26] horizon. On the other hand, we are still a [00:22:29] country that has an exceptional [00:22:32] nuclear windfall. We produce more electricity than [00:22:36] needed, which they sell at a negative price or which they [00:22:39] sold at a negative price, and I find it quite a shame that we [00:22:43] don't use this windfall for our consumers and our businesses, and [00:22:46] that we don't sell EDF, there you go. [00:22:50] At least for some, up to certain ceilings that are to be [00:22:53] determined, which are extremely complex, [00:22:56] electricity, well, electricity at cost price, that would [00:22:59] allow us to absorb the shock and part of the energy shock and [00:23:02] accelerate electrification because [00:23:06] of course, it's not just one measure but several that work together to [00:23:09] move forward. Another measure, another [00:23:12] proposal, because the question is how to increase purchasing power. So for all the people who have [00:23:16] a payslip, well, there's a gross line and then there's a net line. [00:23:20] And between the two, well, there's money that goes into social charges. [00:23:23] And so I think that the first measure is to be able to [00:23:26] reduce these social charges, and the corollary to reduce these social charges is [00:23:30] precisely to make structural reforms on the efficiency of public [00:23:33] spending. That's the only way we'll get by. Yes, because this gap is [00:23:37] intended to finance public spending, in any case, social security, [00:23:41] sickness. The debt is intended to finance public spending [00:23:44] related to the debt. As we said, it has become the first item, it will become [00:23:48] the first budgetary item. It serves, it serves to finance this [00:23:52] differential. We have to go straight to the gross amount then. We have very, [00:23:55] very little time left, but I would still like to point out the fact that this social unrest started with [00:23:59] high school and university students. Despite the government's announcements, youth [00:24:02] organizations are calling for the mobilization to continue. [00:24:05] The executive is notably promising the replacement of Parcoursup in [00:24:08] 2028, a cap on second-year classes at 28 [00:24:12] students, and the creation of 1500 places in higher education. It also announced loans to [00:24:16] renovate establishments. I specify [00:24:19] that Parcoursup is the platform that allows [00:24:22] one to apply to pursue higher education studies. Very, [00:24:26] very quickly, Eric Delannoy, do these responses from the government seem [00:24:30] appropriate to you? Do they seem well calibrated to you? These are promises they won't have to [00:24:33] keep, so naturally, well, suppressing Parcoursup, I would [00:24:36] rather replace it, meaning perhaps less opaque [00:24:39] no, the selection is very [00:24:43] difficult, it's very different to say we're going to replace it rather than we're going to [00:24:46] improve it. I mean, everyone is for improving Parcoursup, except that it's something [00:24:50] that is inaudible today. Today, Parcoursup has allowed the failure [00:24:54] rate in the first year of university to drop. We went from 60% [00:24:57] failure to 50%, which is already an absolute scandal, actually, because why? Because, [00:25:01] deep down, there's a better match between offers and demands for [00:25:04] the majority of students, and so the lottery [00:25:08] that took place before was certainly not better, which means [00:25:12] that removing Parcoursup is not the solution. [00:25:16] It's making it more transparent, especially giving the reasons for [00:25:18] refusals. There's Parcoursup, but there's also guidance. The guidance of [00:25:22] students today is very poorly done, very poorly done due to lack of resources, [00:25:26] and very poorly done due to the fact that today, parents, who are the first to guide [00:25:29] their children, are not aware of the possible paths, and [00:25:33] so we're going to have to do mentoring, we're going to have to support, and we're going to have [00:25:37] to make sure that we revalue trades, [00:25:41] especially trades in vocational high schools, which are today, for many, [00:25:44] dead-end paths, which is a real scandal, and unfortunately, we'll have to do or [00:25:48] fortunately, do another show. [00:29:13] It's difficult to imagine the extent of the devastation of this city of 200,000 [00:29:19] This people suffers from climatic [00:29:23] drought. [00:30:20] Hello everyone, welcome if you're joining us for the rest [00:30:24] and end of the night edition. Here's the latest news from this [00:30:27] Monday. On the front page: blocked high schools, calls [00:30:31] for strikes. We'll be interested in this high-tension social week [00:30:35] beginning in France, after 6 weeks of mobilization and 2 [00:30:39] weeks of school holidays. Several meetings on Tuesday and [00:30:42] Thursday are announced by the trade unions. [00:30:45] D-1 before the election verdict in [00:30:48] the United States. Will the midterm elections reshuffle the cards in [00:30:51] Congress? Until the last minute, Donald Trump [00:30:55] is holding rallies, while in the Democratic camp, we will see, [00:30:58] dissensions have erupted into the open. This is the case in Michigan where [00:31:02] Ayanna Pressley Stevens has switched sides. [00:31:06] And then Formula 1 has a new legend at only...