FRANCE24 — broadcast 20261102 093000 UTC 389 transcript segments Google Cloud Speech-to-Text API (Chirp) + Gemini 2.5 Flash Non-Thinking Data courtesy of The GDELT Project (https://www.gdeltproject.org/), from the Internet Archive TV News Archive. Machine transcription. Treat it as a searchable index of what was broadcast, not a verbatim quotation record. [00:00:00] political debate, truly, [00:00:02] but it's also true that to their discredit, how can [00:00:06] I say it, the media coverage of what's happening, of course it [00:00:10] Jean-Garig, you who work on focuses on events of [00:00:13] demonstration or violence, and we tend to forget [00:00:17] the intellectual debate, the political [00:00:19] debate on the issues, and that's why we [00:00:23] see so little of it, but it's true that it's surprising [00:00:27] nonetheless, it's surprising, inaudible Flor. [00:00:33] Edouard Philippe, who we heard yesterday, who spoke more [00:00:36] about his squabbles with Gabriel Attal about the possibility [00:00:40] of organizing a primary of the center right than about the core [00:00:43] issue. Inaudible also, Bruno Retailleau, but [00:00:47] you just said it, exactly, Edouard Philippe and Raphael Glucksmann, and it's rather, [00:00:51] sorry, Philippe and Gabriel Attal, it's rather, well, they're kind of [00:00:54] fighting each other to see who will represent the [00:00:58] the center-right. We could [00:01:01] today the say at the presidential election, with some [00:01:03] hooks thrown out about a primary that [00:01:07] doesn't seem to interest the [00:01:10] candidates concerned, neither Philippe nor Edouard Philippe, [00:01:13] exactly, nor Bruno Retailleau, nor David Lisnard. So, well, [00:01:17] we're more in these discussions that [00:01:25] was another horizon of expectation which was the that the are indeed a bit inaudible for the French at a time when we see these demonstrations and violence on the other side of the on the left, Raphael Glucksmann, well, he [00:01:29] also has a problem, which is that Raphael Glucksmann, he himself said in an [00:01:32] interview last week that he was harassed by LFI, I quote, [00:01:36] when he went to demonstrations. So, consequently, it's true that he doesn't go, he [00:01:39] doesn't go anymore. He also says, well, he says he's not in his [00:01:43] role, except that in reality, it's especially that he's not welcome. It's true that he has, we [00:01:47] saw, notably during the rally against racism that took [00:01:52] Rally who expect a lot from the place in Paris last week, the farmers seems to have grown. mayor of Paris who was booed with the cry [00:01:56] the left, yes, obviously, well, "everyone hates the PS." So it's very complicated for the left, actually. It feels [00:02:00] like the Insoumis, or at least the Insoumis activists, are targeting, [00:02:04] not necessarily the [00:02:07] said he would go on November National Rally, but the left-wing parties, at least Raphael Glucksmann, the social [00:02:11] democratic left, who is who has, feels like [00:02:15] mobilizes a part of the they are their main adversary, which can be a bit [00:02:18] surprising at a time when the rise of the RN is inexorable, which [00:02:21] will make their lives more complicated in the prospect of a second round, and [00:02:25] even from the first round, because I find that this [00:02:29] way of policing is broadly rejected by public opinion, the [00:02:32] hardening, the well, the [00:02:34] confidentialisation of political life, does not [00:02:37] succeed in improving the image of La France Insoumise, which remains [00:02:40] today, well, the party with the most adverse [00:02:44] opinions. Jean-Luc Mélenchon, its leader, is one of the most [00:02:48] unpopular personalities on the political scene, so this polarization really puts [00:02:52] us in an unprecedented and paradoxical situation. [00:02:54] Today, roughly, the presidential election [00:02:57] looks like a headache for [00:03:00] about half of the French people, not knowing how to be [00:03:03] represented in the second round to have a chance of victory. But for the [00:03:08] that better than me, but first time in history, it's the moderate half of the French people, it's the one that is [00:03:10] rather located towards the center of gravity of political life. Usually, it's the margins that [00:03:14] are excluded and who have difficulty finding outlets in two-round electoral systems. [00:03:18] Here, it's the opposite. So, well, [00:03:22] this is the great tension that reigns in France today, and for the [00:03:25] first time, the moderates are marginalized. [00:03:29] Do you confirm? Oh, but completely, completely, and it's [00:03:32] indeed, well, we will see in it the fruit of [00:03:36] the dissolution of 2024, which led [00:03:40] to this absence of an absolute majority, and then to this [00:03:42] tripartite division, which obviously shrinks [00:03:46] the bloc, the bloc of [00:03:48] moderates. But it goes far beyond that. I mean, it's a [00:03:52] phenomenon that started a long time ago with [00:03:55] the, how can I say it, I was going to say the [00:03:58] direct, a complete overview of shrinking, it's more than a shrinking, it's the impoverishment [00:04:01] of the programs [00:04:03] discourse and the word of or projects led by the major governing parties, on one side the Socialist [00:04:06] Party, on the other side the Republicans. That gave us Emmanuel [00:04:09] Macron, that gave [00:04:11] If there were an entry point to Emmanuel Macron, who [00:04:14] brought both right and left, which we can clearly see was [00:04:19] tearing ourselves apart. And under the control of also a failure, and so necessarily we are moving towards [00:04:22] more radical solutions. The presidential [00:04:25] election lends itself to this radicalism, to this [00:04:28] radicalism. The... [00:04:32] it also contributes because these are events of [00:04:35] polarization, yes, after the history of [00:04:38] presidential campaigns has shown that a shock [00:04:42] in the campaign, as could have been October 17, does not [00:04:45] necessarily make the election. There have been other very [00:04:49] strong moments, I'm thinking of terrorist attacks [00:04:53] notably, which have not necessarily [00:04:55] Pardon in southern changed, that's [00:04:58] to the invasion of why I'm telling you that it's a phenomenon that started a long, long time ago. [00:05:00] It's the culmination, in fact, it's the culmination of a [00:05:03] global failure of those who have [00:05:10] November 5, at the call of bit in the governed the country for the past thirty years. In fact, the Republican promise has not been realized. [00:05:13] And the French are becoming aware of this, and so quite [00:05:16] logically, they turn to what hasn't really been tried, because [00:05:20] the National Rally, it's very clear, it's something they've never been in [00:05:24] power. La France Insoumise is a populist left of a [00:05:27] completely new nature, which is even very different from what the protestataire [00:05:31] left of the Communist Party was a few [00:05:35] years ago. So there is necessarily this choice, this [00:05:39] tearing apart of the moderates towards [00:05:43] more polarized solutions. [00:05:45] Now, it's up to those who embody [00:05:49] this bloc of moderates to provide more [00:05:52] innovative solutions, to try to stick much more to [00:05:56] social realities. I wouldn't want to be in their shoes, [00:06:00] especially since, [00:06:02] well, obviously we're 6 months away from an election, which is both [00:06:06] a lot and very little. Many things can [00:06:10] happen, and we don't even know [00:06:13] final casting. A François [00:06:17] Hollande, why not a Christine [00:06:20] Lagarde, whose resignation from the European Central Bank we learned about [00:06:24] last week. Innovative [00:06:28] solution, says Jean-Garrig just now. Flor [00:06:31] Simon, we can clearly see [00:06:34] equation is still complex for [00:06:38] everyone, and especially for this moderate camp. We mentioned Raphael [00:06:41] Glucksmann, who, after all, positioned himself on an anti-Mélenchon [00:06:44] left. He cannot go, by his own admission, to demonstrations. How can he make [00:06:48] the social demands of a movement his own when he is [00:06:52] excluded from it, or when it is led by someone he [00:06:55] believes is the opposite? That's a very good question, [00:06:59] Pauline, because it's true, it feels like, well, it should be, excuse me, it [00:07:02] should be his, his, his , it's still the social fiber of the left of [00:07:08] so it's true that this morning he was with us for a BFM conf', so he reacted, he said that, [00:07:12] well, for the licenses, there wasn't, it was too late and too little and too [00:07:16] vague. He [00:07:19] 5 to the demonstration at the call of the inter-union, but [00:07:22] well, it's true that we have trouble capturing [00:07:26] Raphael Glucksmann, what he, I mean, has trouble [00:07:30] seeing what he imposes in this movement, [00:07:34] this social effect, [00:07:37] since once again, it's very broad, and so it's true that the left should be [00:07:40] present, has trouble... it's really La France Insoumise that [00:07:44] monopolizes the field. Just a word to come back to [00:07:48] Emmanuel Macron, remember in 2017 he said he would be the bulwark [00:07:51] against the National Rally, that with him, well, the extremes [00:07:55] would lose votes, and well, today I looked at a [00:07:58] Ipsos poll for Le Figaro, I think, which says [00:08:01] that, well, it's not huge, but between 12 and 17% of [00:08:05] voters who voted Macron in 2017 and 2022 will vote [00:08:08] today for Marine Le Pen. So it's true that for the head of state, it's a repudiation. But [00:08:12] we come back to this central bloc that, as you can see, is losing [00:08:16] votes, even Emmanuel Macron's voters, especially those on the right, [00:08:20] would move, or at least a small part, about ten percent, towards the National Rally. So it's true [00:08:24] that the bloc, the all the parties, [00:08:27] the so-called moderate government parties, seem to be [00:08:31] erased, even crushed by these two extremes, the [00:08:34] far left and the far right. This explains the phenomenon Flor Simon describes, which is that there [00:08:38] was a very "out with the old" dimension in the election. He was sort of the armed wing of the [00:08:43] moderate revenge against those who had governed, about whom he himself said [00:08:46] that, well, basically he hadn't succeeded in anything, that he was playing a fictitious game of [00:08:50] left-right positioning that no longer made sense. Well, the problem is that he doesn't give the impression of having [00:08:54] succeeded much more, and so the "out with the old" sentiment will [00:08:58] seek other modalities. So [00:09:02] that's a bit the problem of what [00:09:05] Jean Garrig described, who also provides a particular ingredient to the moment [00:09:09] we're living now. Not only is there no more money to give [00:09:12] satisfaction, but political [00:09:16] the executive are worth almost nothing anymore. They can say, excuse [00:09:19] me for putting it like that, whatever they want in the media, it hardly matters anymore. [00:09:24] money, would this end of the reign [00:09:27] perhaps, maybe my question is stupid, but he has a very, very precise example [00:09:31] here, the high school students say it's difficult to have [00:09:34] classes in high schools and take exams in establishments where it's 39 [00:09:38] degrees. So there's a subject about the school buildings of high schools. [00:09:42] They are truly the outcasts of the world, with high schools [00:09:46] where the toilets are in a deplorable state, where students hold back from going [00:09:50] to the toilet because it's almost unusable, and so on and [00:09:53] so forth. Well, that would imply that we put some money in it, the people who are [00:09:57] supposed to put it, the regions, the regions are exhausted, they have been [00:10:00] deprived of their own resources. That's a major key element of the [00:10:04] policy pursued for 10 years, which is to deprive local authorities of their [00:10:08] own resources. And so now we tell them, well, the state can lend [00:10:12] you money cheaply, and the regions [00:10:15] say we can't, in fact we won't succeed. So we are also a [00:10:19] the culmination indeed of the [00:10:23] shrinking [00:10:25] of the means granted to public action [00:10:28] and public spending in a whole host of areas that are [00:10:32] today perceived as urgent. presidentialism, [00:10:36] unless I'm mistaken, [00:10:39] the vast majority of the septennats and then [00:10:43] quinquennats in France in contemporary [00:10:47] modern history have ended [00:10:50] with a general [00:10:53] criticism. [00:11:03] Hollande's was quite complicated, Nicolas Sarkozy's [00:11:06] too. Well, Jacques Chirac, and even General de [00:11:09] Gaulle, generally, so [00:11:12] some some died along the way. How is [00:11:15] this one more singular than another? Oh, simply [00:11:19] because he no longer has a horizon of expectation. That is to say, [00:11:22] when de Gaulle disappears, well, first he has a designated successor who [00:11:26] is Georges Pompidou. That caused some problems among his Gaullist [00:11:30] rivals, but well, there was Pompidou. When Pompidou [00:11:34] dies, he has Valéry Giscard d'Estaing who brings a horizon [00:11:37] of expectation of societal modernity and so on, and who actually [00:11:41] achieved it. Or then it was, he still had a terrible [00:11:44] end of mandate. But yes, but then when when, but when [00:11:47] Giscard d'Estaing left, well, there [00:11:50] common program of the left, which [00:11:53] led the 11 proposals of François Mitterrand. So each time there was a [00:11:57] horizon of expectation. Today there isn't anymore. I mean, here you [00:12:00] have, well, you have a horizon of expectation, but because there are no [00:12:04] proposals, because the French no longer expect anything, both, both, my general. [00:12:08] I mean, no, but I shouldn't say [00:12:11] he has no reason to expect, since he has a horizon for the voters of the National [00:12:17] presidential election. They expect the return of order, of [00:12:20] security, fewer immigrants, and [00:12:23] probably also the recovery of purchasing power. I think we are under an illusion, but [00:12:27] it's the rule of the presidential election. On the other hand, you have [00:12:31] a real revolutionary societal change, a [00:12:34] revolutionary change proposed by La France Insoumise, and [00:12:37] which, how can I say, [00:12:40] electorate, especially young people who believe in it. And the problem, then, [00:12:44] how is it different from the the the problem [00:12:47] is that what was [00:12:51] carried, the horizon of expectation that was carried in the others. [00:12:55] First of all, because objectively, [00:12:58] the problems facing our society today are [00:13:02] much more serious, in my opinion, and numerous than those that [00:13:05] arose in those times. And [00:13:08] secondly, because those who propose these new [00:13:11] horizons of expectation are in solutions that appear [00:13:15] very radical for a whole other part of [00:13:19] society, whether it's the far left or the far right. When [00:13:22] François Mitterrand was elected, wasn't it the same thing? [00:13:26] Yes, no, but no, but it's, but you will look at the [00:13:29] surveys, and Emmanuel knows [00:13:33] the, how can I say, the solutions of [00:13:36] François Mitterrand were first approved by a very large part of the [00:13:40] French, and above all, they were not rejected as the solutions or [00:13:44] the people of Marine Le Pen or Jean-Luc Mélenchon [00:13:47] are. Added to that, I [00:13:50] think, when we take a step back, when we zoom [00:13:54] out, as Jean said, we see that Western societies are [00:13:57] confronted with issues that are very [00:14:00] similar. There's the climate [00:14:04] challenge, things that we could, well, that many see [00:14:08] as the disorders of the liberal capitalist, [00:14:12] free-trade system that penalizes much of Europe because of its [00:14:15] positioning, its deindustrialization, and its [00:14:18] loss of competitiveness, which had been pointed out by the Draghi [00:14:22] report. And all of this is grafted onto the challenge, the [00:14:25] climate challenge. Well, after that, in France, there are two specificities: [00:14:29] that we can no longer [00:14:31] build a kind of consensus around a dominant model, like the one [00:14:35] inherited from the Second World War, with, well, [00:14:39] with the welfare state, to which we are very attached, but around which we are [00:14:44] the historian and the journalist, I think we are [00:14:47] not far from a crisis of regime in the sense that the presidential function [00:14:51] can no longer be exercised as in the time of the General, as in the time [00:14:55] we are engaged in a European context, we have decided, and [00:14:59] moreover, with the acquiescence of a part of the population on [00:15:03] certain points, even of the majority, that certain policies only made sense [00:15:07] at the supranational level. So, [00:15:10] the president who can cure all ills, who will fix everything [00:15:14] in his day and with me you will see what you will see and you will have [00:15:17] results where all others have failed, that's a little bit over, and so this [00:15:21] illusion of the presidential election, I think it also needs to be somewhat [00:15:25] dispelled. Yes, well, listen, we will probably talk about it [00:15:28] again in the next 6 months. In the meantime, there is a call to [00:15:32] demonstrate next Thursday, [00:15:35] the inter-union. We will see what happens. Thank you very much to all three [00:15:39] of you for coming this morning to this set, Emmanuel Rivière. There [00:15:43] will be no civil war at Robert Laffont in [00:15:47] 2026. And Jean Garrig, we will read in January about this presidential [00:15:50] regime which, as Emmanuel Rivière said, [00:15:54] uh, deserves to be [00:15:57] singularly rethought, well, rethought at least. Thank you very much, Flor. We will find [00:16:01] you on France 24, an emission to rewatch on replay, to listen to again in podcast. We will meet [00:16:05] again just after the break. [00:16:19] Timmy Thomas is a pig farmer and [00:16:22] Republican. [00:16:24] My family has been farming this land since they immigrated here [00:16:28] 150 years ago. He voted twice for Donald [00:16:31] Trump. Pender Sharp, on the other hand, is a farmer and [00:16:35] Democrat. We have been here since [00:16:38] 1905, and six generations of our family have followed [00:16:42] one another on this land. Like [00:16:45] Timmy, he heads a family farm in North [00:16:48] Carolina. The two men have everything in common, except [00:16:52] politics. [00:16:56] Timmy Thomas runs one of the last independent pig [00:16:59] farms in North Carolina. In other words, his [00:17:03] farm does not depend on large agro-industrial companies. He owns [00:17:07] the... [00:17:12] All these babies are 2 weeks old. They have one more [00:17:15] week to spend with their mothers. [00:17:19] A profitable economic model provided that operating costs [00:17:22] are stable. However, the rise in the price of diesel affects all these [00:17:26] expenses. [00:17:29] The price of diesel has almost doubled in a year. In years like this, we don't even [00:17:33] ask ourselves how much profit we're going to make. We just ask ourselves if [00:17:36] we're going to break even to stay in business and, [00:17:40] hopefully, make a profit next [00:17:42] year. [00:17:44] Today, in this context, it's above all a question of [00:17:47] survival. [00:17:49] One gallon, 3.8 liters, now costs more than $6 [00:17:53] compared to about $3.50 last year. A surge in [00:17:56] prices that adds to the burden on farmers, already [00:18:00] penalized by [00:18:01] customs duties. [00:18:04] We import certain inputs from Canada. When customs duties [00:18:08] soared and the price of diesel also increased, the same [00:18:12] product ended up costing three times as much as it did 6 [00:18:14] months ago. So it was difficult to cope with all these [00:18:18] increases at the same time. [00:18:22] The war with Iran and the customs duties imposed on foreign [00:18:25] countries are directly responsible for the financial burden [00:18:28] on the agricultural world. Not enough [00:18:31] to shake Timmy's political [00:18:34] loyalty. [00:18:37] Trump responsible for the war in Iran, I would vote for him [00:18:41] again, I think he did everything he could to put our [00:18:44] country back on the right [00:18:45] track. [00:18:51] An opinion that Pender Sharp, the farmer, absolutely [00:18:54] does not share. Last year, he lost $1 million [00:18:58] in profit on his tobacco sales due to the trade [00:19:01] war initiated by Donald Trump. In mid-summer [00:19:04] 2025, Trump imposed tariffs on China. [00:19:40] This year, soybean harvests have suffered from a severe drought, [00:19:44] to which has been added the rise in diesel prices. [00:19:48] We are in the middle of harvest season and everything is expensive. We consume [00:19:51] fuel every day to harvest our crops in the fields [00:19:54] and [00:19:56] we are losing money on every hectare we cultivate. [00:20:07] American product, Mexico too, and we are caught in a bind. [00:20:11] It feels like a handful of people are making decisions as if it were a [00:20:15] game, while thousands of us are suffering the consequences. Our [00:20:19] families' incomes depend on the outcome of all [00:20:20] of this. [00:20:26] To try to lower the price of diesel, Donald Trump authorized [00:20:29] the resumption of imports of Russian fuel, banned [00:20:33] since 2022 due [00:20:35] Ukraine. A measure justified, according to [00:20:38] Timmy. [00:20:41] There are so many problems everywhere in the world that we need to explore all possible [00:20:44] avenues to import more diesel to the [00:20:47] United States. [00:20:50] losing money, he continues to stand firm behind the Republican [00:20:53] Party and advocates [00:20:55] resilience. [00:21:04] Many decisions made by Trump and conservatives have had negative [00:21:07] consequences for [00:21:08] me, [00:21:12] but they had to be made. What [00:21:15] penalizes me today may benefit my grandchildren, so I will [00:21:19] bear it and accept to pay the price [00:21:21] now so that they have a [00:21:25] better life. [00:21:30] Pender, on the contrary, believes that the Trump administration is [00:21:33] sabotaging the future of his grandson who has been working full-time with him for [00:21:36] a year and a half. [00:21:40] You have to be a little crazy to want to do this, but I love this [00:21:43] job, there's nothing cooler in the [00:21:45] world. [00:21:52] To offset the losses of American farmers, Donald Trump [00:21:56] announced 2 weeks ago the release of an $8 billion [00:21:59] fund, eyewash according to Pender and his [00:22:02] grandson. If we distribute this aid across the entire [00:22:06] United States, it represents about $15 per acre, or about $40 per [00:22:10] hectare, and it doesn't even concern certain crops, [00:22:13] like tobacco. We don't ask to be subsidized by the state, [00:22:17] we simply want to be able to make a living from our profession. To get out [00:22:20] alone, it's terrifying to think that our [00:22:23] generation could be the one that puts an end to 150 years of family [00:22:27] history, [00:22:29] when I have nothing to do with it. If we get to that point, it will be solely [00:22:33] because of the decisions of one man. The frustration of [00:22:38] If Pender and Timmy vote according to their [00:22:41] partisan affiliation on November 3, others might [00:22:45] well change sides or not vote at [00:22:47] all. [00:22:54] Your program with Parmigiano Reggiano. [00:30:14] Let's Talk About It, here are the headlines for this Monday, back to school under high tension in [00:30:18] France after the All Saints' Day holidays, despite government proposals, [00:30:22] high school and university student representatives want to continue blockades and gatherings [00:30:25] before the inter-union strike planned for Thursday, there [00:30:28] are still blocked establishments this morning, we are in front of the Turgo high school. [00:30:32] with Pauline Godard [00:30:34] D-1 before the midterm elections in the United States, a hectic end to the campaign [00:30:38] for Donald Trump who is flexing his muscles again against Iran, you [00:30:42] will hear it and then reciprocal accusations of cyberattack [00:30:45] between Kyiv and Moscow, the public alert system has been targeted, Russian [00:30:49] and Ukrainian civilians have been receiving erroneous messages since yesterday evening, [00:30:53] at which time the truce ended. [00:30:57] Ukraine.