Canada: CBC News Network — Live Cross Country Check Up

20260920 20:00 UTC · 01:01:03 · 904 transcript segments · GDELT Visual Explorer · plain-text transcript · Event Map

A lively discussion on an issue of national interest, hosted by Ian Hanomansing.

Film strip

One frame every 4 seconds, 916 in all. Click a frame to jump the transcript to that moment, or click a line of the transcript to see what was on screen while it was said. Served from apprised.news, so it loads behind proxies that block Google Cloud Storage.

00:00:00
00:00:04
00:00:08
00:00:12
00:00:16
00:00:20
00:00:24
00:00:28
00:00:32
00:00:36
00:00:40
00:00:44
00:00:48
00:00:52
00:00:56
00:01:00
00:01:04
00:01:08
00:01:12
00:01:16
00:01:20
00:01:24
00:01:28
00:01:32
00:01:36
00:01:40
00:01:44
00:01:48
00:01:52
00:01:56
00:02:00
00:02:04
00:02:08
00:02:12
00:02:16
00:02:20
00:02:24
00:02:28
00:02:32
00:02:36
00:02:40
00:02:44
00:02:48
00:02:52
00:02:56
00:03:00
00:03:04
00:03:08
00:03:12
00:03:16
00:03:20
00:03:24
00:03:28
00:03:32
00:03:36
00:03:40
00:03:44
00:03:48
00:03:52
00:03:56
00:04:00
00:04:04
00:04:08
00:04:12
00:04:16
00:04:20
00:04:24
00:04:28
00:04:32
00:04:36
00:04:40
00:04:44
00:04:48
00:04:52
00:04:56
00:05:00
00:05:04
00:05:08
00:05:12
00:05:16
00:05:20
00:05:24
00:05:28
00:05:32
00:05:36
00:05:40
00:05:44
00:05:48
00:05:52
00:05:56
00:06:00
00:06:04
00:06:08
00:06:12
00:06:16
00:06:20
00:06:24
00:06:28
00:06:32
00:06:36
00:06:40
00:06:44
00:06:48
00:06:52
00:06:56
00:07:00
00:07:04
00:07:08
00:07:12
00:07:16
00:07:20
00:07:24
00:07:28
00:07:32
00:07:36
00:07:40
00:07:44
00:07:48
00:07:52
00:07:56
00:08:00
00:08:04
00:08:08
00:08:12
00:08:16
00:08:20
00:08:24
00:08:28
00:08:32
00:08:36
00:08:40
00:08:44
00:08:48
00:08:52
00:08:56
00:09:00
00:09:04
00:09:08
00:09:12
00:09:16
00:09:20
00:09:24
00:09:28
00:09:32
00:09:36
00:09:40
00:09:44
00:09:48
00:09:52
00:09:56
00:10:00
00:10:04
00:10:08
00:10:12
00:10:16
00:10:20
00:10:24
00:10:28
00:10:32
00:10:36
00:10:40
00:10:44
00:10:48
00:10:52
00:10:56
00:11:00
00:11:04
00:11:08
00:11:12
00:11:16
00:11:20
00:11:24
00:11:28
00:11:32
00:11:36
00:11:40
00:11:44
00:11:48
00:11:52
00:11:56
00:12:00
00:12:04
00:12:08
00:12:12
00:12:16
00:12:20
00:12:24
00:12:28
00:12:32
00:12:36
00:12:40
00:12:44
00:12:48
00:12:52
00:12:56
00:13:00
00:13:04
00:13:08
00:13:12
00:13:16
00:13:20
00:13:24
00:13:28
00:13:32
00:13:36
00:13:40
00:13:44
00:13:48
00:13:52
00:13:56
00:14:00
00:14:04
00:14:08
00:14:12
00:14:16
00:14:20
00:14:24
00:14:28
00:14:32
00:14:36
00:14:40
00:14:44
00:14:48
00:14:52
00:14:56
00:15:00
00:15:04
00:15:08
00:15:12
00:15:16
00:15:20
00:15:24
00:15:28
00:15:32
00:15:36
00:15:40
00:15:44
00:15:48
00:15:52
00:15:56
00:16:00
00:16:04
00:16:08
00:16:12
00:16:16
00:16:20
00:16:24
00:16:28
00:16:32
00:16:36
00:16:40
00:16:44
00:16:48
00:16:52
00:16:56
00:17:00
00:17:04
00:17:08
00:17:12
00:17:16
00:17:20
00:17:24
00:17:28
00:17:32
00:17:36
00:17:40
00:17:44
00:17:48
00:17:52
00:17:56
00:18:00
00:18:04
00:18:08
00:18:12
00:18:16
00:18:20
00:18:24
00:18:28
00:18:32
00:18:36
00:18:40
00:18:44
00:18:48
00:18:52
00:18:56
00:19:00
00:19:04
00:19:08
00:19:12
00:19:16
00:19:20
00:19:24
00:19:28
00:19:32
00:19:36
00:19:40
00:19:44
00:19:48
00:19:52
00:19:56
00:20:00
00:20:04
00:20:08
00:20:12
00:20:16
00:20:20
00:20:24
00:20:28
00:20:32
00:20:36
00:20:40
00:20:44
00:20:48
00:20:52
00:20:56
00:21:00
00:21:04
00:21:08
00:21:12
00:21:16
00:21:20
00:21:24
00:21:28
00:21:32
00:21:36
00:21:40
00:21:44
00:21:48
00:21:52
00:21:56
00:22:00
00:22:04
00:22:08
00:22:12
00:22:16
00:22:20
00:22:24
00:22:28
00:22:32
00:22:36
00:22:40
00:22:44
00:22:48
00:22:52
00:22:56
00:23:00
00:23:04
00:23:08
00:23:12
00:23:16
00:23:20
00:23:24
00:23:28
00:23:32
00:23:36
00:23:40
00:23:44
00:23:48
00:23:52
00:23:56
00:24:00
00:24:04
00:24:08
00:24:12
00:24:16
00:24:20
00:24:24
00:24:28
00:24:32
00:24:36
00:24:40
00:24:44
00:24:48
00:24:52
00:24:56
00:25:00
00:25:04
00:25:08
00:25:12
00:25:16
00:25:20
00:25:24
00:25:28
00:25:32
00:25:36
00:25:40
00:25:44
00:25:48
00:25:52
00:25:56
00:26:00
00:26:04
00:26:08
00:26:12
00:26:16
00:26:20
00:26:24
00:26:28
00:26:32
00:26:36
00:26:40
00:26:44
00:26:48
00:26:52
00:26:56
00:27:00
00:27:04
00:27:08
00:27:12
00:27:16
00:27:20
00:27:24
00:27:28
00:27:32
00:27:36
00:27:40
00:27:44
00:27:48
00:27:52
00:27:56
00:28:00
00:28:04
00:28:08
00:28:12
00:28:16
00:28:20
00:28:24
00:28:28
00:28:32
00:28:36
00:28:40
00:28:44
00:28:48
00:28:52
00:28:56
00:29:00
00:29:04
00:29:08
00:29:12
00:29:16
00:29:20
00:29:24
00:29:28
00:29:32
00:29:36
00:29:40
00:29:44
00:29:48
00:29:52
00:29:56
00:30:00
00:30:04
00:30:08
00:30:12
00:30:16
00:30:20
00:30:24
00:30:28
00:30:32
00:30:36
00:30:40
00:30:44
00:30:48
00:30:52
00:30:56
00:31:00
00:31:04
00:31:08
00:31:12
00:31:16
00:31:20
00:31:24
00:31:28
00:31:32
00:31:36
00:31:40
00:31:44
00:31:48
00:31:52
00:31:56
00:32:00
00:32:04
00:32:08
00:32:12
00:32:16
00:32:20
00:32:24
00:32:28
00:32:32
00:32:36
00:32:40
00:32:44
00:32:48
00:32:52
00:32:56
00:33:00
00:33:04
00:33:08
00:33:12
00:33:16
00:33:20
00:33:24
00:33:28
00:33:32
00:33:36
00:33:40
00:33:44
00:33:48
00:33:52
00:33:56
00:34:00
00:34:04
00:34:08
00:34:12
00:34:16
00:34:20
00:34:24
00:34:28
00:34:32
00:34:36
00:34:40
00:34:44
00:34:48
00:34:52
00:34:56
00:35:00
00:35:04
00:35:08
00:35:12
00:35:16
00:35:20
00:35:24
00:35:28
00:35:32
00:35:36
00:35:40
00:35:44
00:35:48
00:35:52
00:35:56
00:36:00
00:36:04
00:36:08
00:36:12
00:36:16
00:36:20
00:36:24
00:36:28
00:36:32
00:36:36
00:36:40
00:36:44
00:36:48
00:36:52
00:36:56
00:37:00
00:37:04
00:37:08
00:37:12
00:37:16
00:37:20
00:37:24
00:37:28
00:37:32
00:37:36
00:37:40
00:37:44
00:37:48
00:37:52
00:37:56
00:38:00
00:38:04
00:38:08
00:38:12
00:38:16
00:38:20
00:38:24
00:38:28
00:38:32
00:38:36
00:38:40
00:38:44
00:38:48
00:38:52
00:38:56
00:39:00
00:39:04
00:39:08
00:39:12
00:39:16
00:39:20
00:39:24
00:39:28
00:39:32
00:39:36
00:39:40
00:39:44
00:39:48
00:39:52
00:39:56
00:40:00
00:40:04
00:40:08
00:40:12
00:40:16
00:40:20
00:40:24
00:40:28
00:40:32
00:40:36
00:40:40
00:40:44
00:40:48
00:40:52
00:40:56
00:41:00
00:41:04
00:41:08
00:41:12
00:41:16
00:41:20
00:41:24
00:41:28
00:41:32
00:41:36
00:41:40
00:41:44
00:41:48
00:41:52
00:41:56
00:42:00
00:42:04
00:42:08
00:42:12
00:42:16
00:42:20
00:42:24
00:42:28
00:42:32
00:42:36
00:42:40
00:42:44
00:42:48
00:42:52
00:42:56
00:43:00
00:43:04
00:43:08
00:43:12
00:43:16
00:43:20
00:43:24
00:43:28
00:43:32
00:43:36
00:43:40
00:43:44
00:43:48
00:43:52
00:43:56
00:44:00
00:44:04
00:44:08
00:44:12
00:44:16
00:44:20
00:44:24
00:44:28
00:44:32
00:44:36
00:44:40
00:44:44
00:44:48
00:44:52
00:44:56
00:45:00
00:45:04
00:45:08
00:45:12
00:45:16
00:45:20
00:45:24
00:45:28
00:45:32
00:45:36
00:45:40
00:45:44
00:45:48
00:45:52
00:45:56
00:46:00
00:46:04
00:46:08
00:46:12
00:46:16
00:46:20
00:46:24
00:46:28
00:46:32
00:46:36
00:46:40
00:46:44
00:46:48
00:46:52
00:46:56
00:47:00
00:47:04
00:47:08
00:47:12
00:47:16
00:47:20
00:47:24
00:47:28
00:47:32
00:47:36
00:47:40
00:47:44
00:47:48
00:47:52
00:47:56
00:48:00
00:48:04
00:48:08
00:48:12
00:48:16
00:48:20
00:48:24
00:48:28
00:48:32
00:48:36
00:48:40
00:48:44
00:48:48
00:48:52
00:48:56
00:49:00
00:49:04
00:49:08
00:49:12
00:49:16
00:49:20
00:49:24
00:49:28
00:49:32
00:49:36
00:49:40
00:49:44
00:49:48
00:49:52
00:49:56
00:50:00
00:50:04
00:50:08
00:50:12
00:50:16
00:50:20
00:50:24
00:50:28
00:50:32
00:50:36
00:50:40
00:50:44
00:50:48
00:50:52
00:50:56
00:51:00
00:51:04
00:51:08
00:51:12
00:51:16
00:51:20
00:51:24
00:51:28
00:51:32
00:51:36
00:51:40
00:51:44
00:51:48
00:51:52
00:51:56
00:52:00
00:52:04
00:52:08
00:52:12
00:52:16
00:52:20
00:52:24
00:52:28
00:52:32
00:52:36
00:52:40
00:52:44
00:52:48
00:52:52
00:52:56
00:53:00
00:53:04
00:53:08
00:53:12
00:53:16
00:53:20
00:53:24
00:53:28
00:53:32
00:53:36
00:53:40
00:53:44
00:53:48
00:53:52
00:53:56
00:54:00
00:54:04
00:54:08
00:54:12
00:54:16
00:54:20
00:54:24
00:54:28
00:54:32
00:54:36
00:54:40
00:54:44
00:54:48
00:54:52
00:54:56
00:55:00
00:55:04
00:55:08
00:55:12
00:55:16
00:55:20
00:55:24
00:55:28
00:55:32
00:55:36
00:55:40
00:55:44
00:55:48
00:55:52
00:55:56
00:56:00
00:56:04
00:56:08
00:56:12
00:56:16
00:56:20
00:56:24
00:56:28
00:56:32
00:56:36
00:56:40
00:56:44
00:56:48
00:56:52
00:56:56
00:57:00
00:57:04
00:57:08
00:57:12
00:57:16
00:57:20
00:57:24
00:57:28
00:57:32
00:57:36
00:57:40
00:57:44
00:57:48
00:57:52
00:57:56
00:58:00
00:58:04
00:58:08
00:58:12
00:58:16
00:58:20
00:58:24
00:58:28
00:58:32
00:58:36
00:58:40
00:58:44
00:58:48
00:58:52
00:58:56
00:59:00
00:59:04
00:59:08
00:59:12
00:59:16
00:59:20
00:59:24
00:59:28
00:59:32
00:59:36
00:59:40
00:59:44
00:59:48
00:59:52
00:59:56
01:00:00
01:00:04
01:00:08
01:00:12
01:00:16
01:00:20
01:00:24
01:00:28
01:00:32
01:00:36
01:00:40
01:00:44
01:00:48
01:00:52
01:00:56
01:01:00

Transcript

Google Speech-to-Text API Automatic Transcription (Chirp). Treat it as a searchable index of what was broadcast, not a quotation record.

00:00:00shows you where it starts, where it ends. were you really willing to
00:00:04risk that job? yes, at thunderbase favorite festival, wake the
00:00:08of diet. taada, there it
00:00:12of is. stream anytime. cbc
00:00:15news.
00:00:22hi, i'm enhannamansing, the host of cross
00:00:24of country of checkup. we're about to start the
00:00:26of show, and we have lot to talk about, but first here are few
00:00:29of stories. to get you ready for that conversation
00:00:33of
00:00:34of of today. of The
00:00:35of European Parliament gave the Canadian Prime Minister, a Rockstar's
00:00:38welcome, with selfies, a Sydney Crosby jersey and warm
00:00:42words. Opening the door to
00:00:44of deepening our alliance is
00:00:47of huge positive step forward. Despite fresh
00:00:50threats from US president Donald Trump,
00:00:56a I think it's laughable. Mark Carney outlined a plan to pull Canada and the EU closer together, what he calls " alliance for the
00:01:00future, this is about sovereignty,
00:01:04saying he wants closer cooperation on energy, defense,
00:01:08AI and research. The speech also featured few veil
00:01:11digs at the
00:01:12a Trump administration. I'm not proposing a third block in
00:01:16order to become a great power rival, only with better
00:01:23a manners. Curney left Europe with a willingness from allies to
00:01:27deepen ties, but no clarity on what that.
00:01:33of "I
00:01:35a would like to work with you on
00:01:38of opening the door for Canada to
00:01:41of being the first associate member
00:01:44of the European Union. That
00:01:46of form of membership doesn't exist and isn't
00:01:49of defined. The precise
00:01:49of nomenclature
00:01:50of is a for Europe is a question for Europe. The terms they
00:01:54use. The Spanish prime
00:01:55of minister seemed to express his support with this picture posted
00:01:59of online. Brothers have
00:02:04of doubts, including that heckler, chanting USA, Sigbarth Rusa,
00:02:08representing the right-wing populist alternative for Germany Party, told
00:02:11CBC News in a statement that was his way of addressing the geopolitical
00:02:15elephant in the room, adding it was an absurd and unrealistic
00:02:19Neejerk reaction from his Vonderlion to propose associate EU
00:02:23membership
00:02:23of for Canada, but any increased economic
00:02:26of cooperation could help Canada and
00:02:28of the EU, says this former ambassador. and it's a big upgrade for us
00:02:32and I'm alated that they seem
00:02:35to act believe that it's an upgrade for them. Still,
00:02:39Canada's conservatives, meeting in British Columbia have lots of
00:02:43questions. We have no
00:02:45of details, we have no uh understanding what that actually
00:02:48of means. I think it is abysmal that Mark Carney is
00:02:52making such incredible
00:02:55of announcements on foreign soil. The prime minister
00:02:59did say... Earlier today, any proposed deal will be debated
00:03:02of and voted on in Canadian parliament when it's finalized. It's expected
00:03:06of to be discussed further at the Canada EU Summit next
00:03:09a month.
00:03:10of And so
00:03:10of Kate,
00:03:10a the prime minister was also asked about Donald Trump's threat to levy
00:03:14more tariffs if he believes this deal is hostile act.
00:03:19of Mark Carney says any new deal with the EU is about creating opportunity and
00:03:23better future for
00:03:24me Canadians, not a reaction to something else. But he also said Canada is
00:03:27looking for partnerships that are complementary. and reinforce its
00:03:31sovereignty, those are the very concerns, the prime minister cited when he walked
00:03:35away from the deal with the US. All right, thank you, that is Kate McKenna
00:03:39in Ottawa. Is Canada joining the European
00:03:42Union? The
00:03:43a idea of
00:03:44me becoming associate member is being floated, but what exactly is that?
00:03:47Here at the European Parliament, Prime Minister Mark Carney told the EU he wants
00:03:51deeper cooperation. Canada and Europe are
00:03:55each strong. Europe and Canada are stronger
00:03:59together. President
00:04:00of the European Commission
00:04:01a surprised many when she
00:04:03of went a one step further and announced this
00:04:05in a major speech: "I would like to work with you on
00:04:09opening the
00:04:10of door for Canada to being the first
00:04:14of associate member
00:04:15of the European Union. Canada
00:04:19of welcomes this ambition. Polling shows that an overwhelming
00:04:22majority of Canadians support much closer
00:04:26ties with Europe. But it's unclear what
00:04:28a exactly associate..." membership would be, there's no legal
00:04:32a definition, and
00:04:32in it's also unclear what Canada's responsibilities would be if it
00:04:37of joins, will it have to pay taxes to the EU, will
00:04:39of it have to follow the EU's laws? Karney says all the details are being worked
00:04:43out and that Canada's parliament and the
00:04:45of EU
00:04:50of of will have to green light any possible membership. We are looking for of partnerships that are complementary that reinforce our sovereignty, and that's what
00:04:53is on
00:04:54of offer here. So what do we know about what Carney hopes this new alliance will look
00:04:58like? The prime minister has signal. two main things: first, Canada wants more
00:05:02cooperation on trade and key industries, think critical minerals,
00:05:06defense, AI and tech, energy
00:05:08of and
00:05:08in finances, and he's talked about improving what he calls people to people top.
00:05:12is basically making it easier for Canadian and EU citizens to live and
00:05:16work each other's countries. he specifically mentioned European
00:05:20education and research programs, signaling that he'd like to make it easier
00:05:23for students to study abroad. so why would Canada want to join the EU
00:05:27now? a Canada EU alliance would create beacon for
00:05:31other democracies. both have troublesome neighbors. Canada is trying to
00:05:35move away from its relationship with the US, and the EU is facing down
00:05:39Russia, so banding together could help both Canada and the Europe. union
00:05:43to better protect their economies, their laws and their
00:05:46sovereignty. they do not want this police
00:05:49presence, as the world's largest democracy, getting them to the pools
00:05:53is mamoth tas. it's been a
00:05:57year of strikes, train drivers, teachers,
00:06:00lawyers. how difficult has this period been for
00:06:03you? very difficult. i'm sitting in your one
00:06:07stolen vehicle in west africa. you walk into the
00:06:10hospital and what hits you? the chaos, this is our world,
00:06:14this is the
00:06:15national.
00:06:22Canada and Europe should secure our strategic autonomy
00:06:26through deep cooperation, including critical minerals,
00:06:29defense, industrial capacity, AI and compute.
00:06:33Hiam me and hencing in Vancouver, cross country checkup is
00:06:37live. The whole thing with Canada, Canada has been a terrible trade
00:06:41partner and uh... "if they do that, if I think it's at all
00:06:44hostile act, I will put very serious tariffs or stop
00:06:48trading with Europe. our question for the first hour the program, is Canada
00:06:52more like Europe or the United States, what's it stake for you if Canada
00:06:56builds closer ties to the
00:07:08want to work with people who are interested in working with us and that's what
00:07:11Europe is all. "I think it's great to develop trade relationships with
00:07:15other countries and other parts the world. There's nothing wrong with diversifying trade, but I think that
00:07:19there's a bit of naivite among Canadians that we can
00:07:23replace our dependence on the United States. I think
00:07:26loosening our ties with the United States is a gift, because Trump is not to be
00:07:30trusted. As Canada US trade talks remain a
00:07:34stand still, the prime minister is making the case to forge deeper ties with
00:07:38the EU. The EU chief, Ersela Vonderlion floated making..."
00:07:42Canada, associate member this week. While Carney applauded her
00:07:46enthusiasm, he said he's looking for more economic cooperation
00:07:50and exchange programs for Canadian students. But as Canada looks
00:07:54across the Atlantic, how will this affect the already strained
00:07:58Canada US trade negotiations? As we just heard, Trump is
00:08:01already threatening more tarifs. We want to know what impact
00:08:05Canada's geopolitical shift has on you and your
00:08:09perspective on Canada's place in the world. few minutes
00:08:13we'll hear from experts like Paul Waldy the Glob and Mail Economist Mosha
00:08:16Lander and Stephen Marsh the host the Gloves off
00:08:20podcast. Our question is Canada more like Europe or the United
00:08:24States. What's it stake for you if Canada builds closer ties to the
00:08:27EU? Whether you rely on trade with the US or EU?
00:08:31Dream of studying in Europe or have lived abroad would love to hear your
00:08:43Now in our second hour, two former political rivals are
00:08:47joining forces to fight Alberta separation. Former Premiers
00:08:51Rachel Notley and Jason Kenny will be here together to answer your
00:08:55questions during our ask anything that's coming up in hour to.
00:08:59I mean Hannah Mansing in Vancouver, we are live on CBC radio and
00:09:03CBC News Network. This is Cross Country Checkup.
00:09:06Your voice, Canada's
00:09:25a unique perspective. I feel like lot of callers are going to have perspectives that
00:09:28are very particular to themselves. Liz Newcom
00:09:32was born in the United States, she moved from New York to Montreal in
00:09:352000 and two, and that's where she joins us from
00:09:49um, we were asking as you know callers, if Canada feels
00:09:53more like Europe to them or the United States, having grown up in the
00:09:56states, living now in Montreal, how do you feel about
00:10:00that? uh,
00:10:03Canada for me is definitely more like
00:10:07Europe. uh, for few reasons, uh, there's the
00:10:10healthcare system. which Canadians
00:10:14have collectively agreed to put their
00:10:18taxes in to cover people for basic and and
00:10:21catastrophic uh issues health.
00:10:25issues, there's also the social benefits
00:10:28like maternity leave, so I i feel that that's a lot more
00:10:32European, and then of course we've got our parliamentary
00:10:36system of government, which
00:10:39will
00:10:41it keeps things,
00:10:42I feel more in checks and balances
00:10:45especially compared to what we're seeing in the US right now, sometimes
00:10:49it leads to instability like in the
00:10:53UK where there seems to be... uh having a new prime minister
00:10:57all the time, but it also means that we're
00:11:00not uh kind of stuck with a
00:11:04party or or a certain prime minister, if there's disappointment
00:11:08then things can happen to uh change
00:11:11that. big move for you from the United States to
00:11:15Canada, um, was there a moment where you thought to yourself, okay,
00:11:19like I really feel Canadian right
00:12:35we're speaking live with Liz Newcom in Montreal, we're asking, is Canada more like
00:12:38Europe or the United States, what's it stake for you, if Canada builds
00:12:42closer ties to the
00:12:51is someone who was born in the United States, grew up there. How does it?
00:12:55feel especially in the last few days to see Canadians, many Canadians,
00:12:58celebrating at least the notion of moving closer, connecting more
00:13:02to to Europe and pulling away further from the United
00:13:06States. I'm all for it, I
00:13:10have to say, I still have ties to the US, my family live
00:13:14there, so it's a place that I visit regularly, I
00:13:18have nothing against most Americans
00:13:21or many Americans, they... don't all
00:13:25support what their president is
00:13:27doing, and but I also see
00:13:31that depending a
00:13:35trading partner - who is being that's being
00:13:39led by somebody who's unreliable is not
00:13:43good for Canada, and
00:13:46diversifying our options
00:13:56Liz Newcom, born in the United States, lives in Montreal, and that is where
00:14:00she spoke to us from. Coming up, we're going to speak to Journalist Stephen Marsh
00:14:04about how Canadian identity is changing with shifting global
00:14:08alliances, and of course we'd love to hear from you, our question, is Canada
00:14:12more like Europe or the United States? What's it stake for you if Canada builds
00:14:16closer ties to the
00:14:2524 so the prime minister spoke in front the european parliament
00:14:29on Thursday for more on what his speech told us about what a
00:14:33potentially new relationship with Europe could look like, we've
00:14:36reached Paul Waldy, he's the Europe correspondent for the Global Mail, and
00:14:40we've reached him in Castle Acre, England, about two
00:14:52you from Prime Minister Carney's pitch to the EU? "I think
00:14:56what was interesting was how he very quickly backed off this sort
00:15:00of associate membership that the EU uh
00:15:04president the EU Commission Ersula Vonderline talked about the day
00:15:07before, she sort of invited Canada to be the first associate member the
00:15:11EU. Carney in his speech sort of said, yeah, that's a great ambition, but I think what
00:15:15we're aiming for is closer ties and deeper ties, and I think that's that's
00:15:19part the problem here. I think this whole issue has gotten way out in front of Carney, and I
00:15:23think now he's trying to reel it back in. because of course, how far you go
00:15:27with the EU really involves lot more obligations on the part of
00:15:30Canada, so I think he's going to have to rain this a little bit and focus
00:15:34more on sort of sectoral areas or areas like... minerals,
00:15:38AI, energy, these kinds of things that Canada and EU can work better on
00:15:42rather than some kind of broad, global
00:15:45sweeping kind of associate membership status, so we know we're never going to be
00:15:49member the EU, we don't know what associate
00:15:52member means, I guess we can look at countries like
00:15:56Switzerland or Norway or Iceland to try to figure out is there
00:16:00a model there for us, how are you trying to figure this
00:16:04out? well, I mean that that's the closest thing to associate.
00:16:07status, but I mean that brings benefits and and real costs that I'm not sure all Canadians
00:16:11are quite aware the benefits would be access to the single market, which
00:16:15Norway Switzerland and Iceland have. That's the big market,
00:16:18that's the the free, tarif free access to the one the biggest markets in
00:16:22the world. Uh, the flip side of that is you have to accept every single
00:16:26EU rule and regulation without any say over that, because those countries don't elect members to
00:16:30the European Parliament, they have no bureaucrats in Brussels looking out for their
00:16:34interest, so they are really just have to take whatever rules the EU and they have to
00:16:38contribute to the EU budget, now I don't think that's what Carney or the Canadian
00:16:42officials are really looking at, I think they're looking at something different, that would be
00:16:45along the lines, maybe what they call association arrangements, and these are
00:16:49the kinds of things they have with countries like Turkey, what they had one
00:16:53with Chile, they have one with Ukraine, so they have very broad
00:16:57agreements that can cover lot of different things, it might not be quite as
00:17:00involved as what Norway, Switzerland and Iceland have,
00:17:04so if we're looking for something different, looking for
00:17:08something less than those countries like Norway or
00:17:11Iceland or Switzerland have, is what we're looking for or the prime
00:17:15minister looking for meaningful? it it's hard
00:17:19to say, I
00:17:20mean in some respects we already have that, right? we we signed a
00:17:24trade deal with the European Union back in 2016, it was build
00:17:28at the time,
00:17:28it was the most comprehensive trade deal the world had ever seen it was
00:17:32going to open up tarif free access on goods, it was going to involve services,
00:17:35government procurement, all kinds of... things, it hasn't really done much
00:17:39for trade between both sides and in fact 10 EU member states haven't even
00:17:43ratified it,
00:17:44so they
00:17:44don't even view it as that much
00:17:46of a priority, so I think if you're talking about what we're going to build on from that, it's it's hard
00:17:49to see now, what Carney and I think Vandalar are talking about
00:17:53are more sort of political or more sort of economic arrangements that
00:17:57evolve, things like energy, things like critical minerals, things that kind of go
00:18:01beyond the nuts and bolts of a trade deal, but that's even hard to see how that
00:18:05would work and how you would bolt that onto the... trade deal. What's in all
00:18:09of this for the EU? I think right
00:18:12now, if we look at this realistically, it's all about symbolism. There's very little in
00:18:16it for the EU. Canada is not a major trading partner for the European
00:18:20Union, it's quite a small player in that sense, but I think
00:18:24this allows the EU to project some kind of toughness against Trump,
00:18:28and I think that's also partly Carney's agenda here, he wants to show that he's tough against
00:18:32Trump, so the two them together can talk a big game about forming some kind of
00:18:36closer alliance. think the EU wouldn't mind having access to Canadian
00:18:39critical minerals because they are desperately short of
00:18:42that and they're far too relying on China, so they're looking for new marks for that kind of
00:18:46thing, probably energy as well given the situation with Russia, so there
00:18:49are some pluses here for the EU, but I don't think in the grand schema
00:18:53things, this is top priority for the European Union. As a Canadian
00:18:57journalist who lives in the UK and spends time in Europe, maybe
00:19:01briefly explain to us how, and and it's a diverse group
00:19:05of countries, but how the EU views Mark. Oh,
00:19:09right now, I mean, they they view Mark Carney as a real ally, they view him as somebody who's
00:19:13who's taking the fight to Trump, I think he's, he could go into any, almost
00:19:16any EU country and
00:19:18get very, very warm welcome, warm reception, including here Britain,
00:19:22so yeah, he he's pretty highly
00:19:34earlier this week, CBC spoke to Canadians about how they... feel about
00:19:38building closer ties with the EU, take a listen. I
00:19:42think Canada should still work with United States
00:19:45and we should just realize
00:19:49Trump's not going to be there forever. Great Britain backed out the EU, part of that
00:19:53I think was though that reason that there was too much control. I think
00:19:57it'd be a great way to open gateways to both students over there and
00:20:00students over here to
00:20:01come crossover, learn new things. We were just talking about going on exchange next year and we
00:20:05all like our friends all wanted to go to Europe. will visa free?
00:20:09definitely, i want the warm weather and good food, so i'll be
00:20:12down. few voices from the streets of torondo, few days
00:20:15ago with their reaction to Canada's EU pivot, and of
00:20:19course we'd love to hear your reaction as well, whether you've lived in multiple
00:20:23countries, perhaps you have business that stands to win or lose customers in the
00:20:27US or the EU, give us call. our question, is Canada
00:20:31more like Europe or the United States, what's at stake if Canada builds closer
00:20:35ties to the EU, 8884?
00:20:39416833 or you can text us at 226758
00:20:428924 also lots of online reaction to
00:20:46this program and i want to bring in our producer paris he lees been tracking the online
00:20:50reaction we're
00:21:56let's get to online responses. What do you seeing this hour? Well, we're
00:21:59hearing from folks who are excited about the prospect of closer Canada
00:22:03EU relationship like Lena who left this comment with CBC News
00:22:07on TikTok, I'm a 39-year-old Canadian who moved to Sweden in
00:22:112022. This is monumental. Working for a Swedish
00:22:15company is a dream and the cost of living is crazy cheap compared to
00:22:18Canada. not everyone shares that enthusiasm
00:22:22ian. Sabine Lions in Colona BBC sent us this
00:22:25message via Air Check. She wrote, "My family lives in
00:22:28Europe. Since joining the EU, their lives have been very negatively
00:22:32impacted, from immigration to their green agenda to dictating
00:22:36farming regulations, Europeans are being smothered with ridiculous
00:22:40regulations." Brenda Cavennaught from Calgary also shared her
00:22:44thoughts with us through aircheck. She wrote, "Well, it's great to have strong
00:22:48ties between Canada and the Europe." union, first nations should have
00:22:52rights to be consulted a matter, this important. European heritage
00:22:56is one part of Canadian identity, but we have Canadian citizens who come from all
00:23:00cultures and that is something to be
00:23:09As Canada realigns itself, or at least talks about realigning itself
00:23:13in this new world order, how do we define ourselves to the rest the world?
00:23:16Stephen Marsh is a journalist and host the Gloves off pod. cast
00:23:20which explores Canadian sovereignty and foreign policy and
00:23:58do you think about the EU and Canada building more of
00:24:00relationship? I think it's
00:24:04great. thanks for having me on. first of all, um, I'm really
00:24:08excited, I think it's great. um, I'm Dutch Canadian, so
00:24:11I've lived 23 years in Canada, moved back to the
00:24:15Netherlands a few years ago, and
00:24:19um, I'm having lived in both countries
00:24:23and enjoyed Canada's nature, I just hope that there is an opportunity for more
00:24:27exchange between Europeans and Canadians.
00:24:31Um, for Canada, I think it's great, diversifying your business is
00:24:34always makes business sense, so for people not
00:24:38to put your eggs in one
00:24:40basket, um, divide it
00:24:44between Europe and Canada, I think is is a good
00:24:46idea. What is it about?
00:24:50the Netherlands that you think connects to
00:24:53Canada
00:24:56uh, deeply?
00:25:00um, you know, it's really the sacrifice that the Canadians made here
00:25:03during um, during
00:25:05the second world war, and in the rest of Europe, the commemoration
00:25:09the first world war, I don't know if you've ever been to Vimy
00:25:12Ridge, I have, I have, yeah, done the
00:25:16trail from Pashendill in in Belgium down to
00:25:20ridge you come across all the Canadian graveyards and
00:25:24it's amazing to see how the local communities are maintaining them
00:25:28prestinely, the crosses are white, the grass is cut, and this is
00:25:31all done voluntarily. um, you Canadians are being
00:25:35remembered every year, um, even now, the liberation
00:25:39the Netherlands, we commemorate, I hang out my Canadian
00:25:43flag, when they come by, always being
00:25:46welcomed very warmly, um,
00:25:50very generously, that's interesting, you know, yes, I
00:25:54have been there and it is very moving, but I sometimes wonder when I watch coverage
00:25:58from afar on television, if this is something which
00:26:01people... perform the the
00:26:04historical uh connections on certain days let's say
00:26:08and
00:26:09and and you know do they deeply understand it and you're saying they
00:26:12deeply understand it so so that's very interesting what about the challenges if if
00:26:16Canada
00:26:17you know truly wants to move closer to Europe and let's talk specifically about the
00:26:21Netherlands what what's a challenge that Canada and the Netherlands
00:26:25will have to deal with
00:26:29um there's obviously an ocean between us.
00:26:35um um, think i think we have a number of similar
00:26:39challenges um amongst ourselves, so if you look at
00:26:43the how the provinces operate differently and the territory within
00:26:46Canada with different tax systems and different infrastructure, i
00:26:50think we see similar problems in Europe that really kind of confine us
00:26:54to what we can do and how we can expand, so really
00:26:58crossing crossing those bridges
00:27:00and ' "building those bridges is going to be a
00:27:04challenge,
00:27:05um, European Union is very
00:27:09known for being very bureaucratic, it may be difficult in terms of
00:27:13trade relations to improve things, it might take some time,
00:27:17but I think this is just beginning, this is associate membership,
00:27:21so things like student exchange can be very interesting,
00:27:24investing each other's economies and then just take it from there and see how it
00:27:28goes. one last thing, um, as somebody who definitely..."
00:27:32has foot each country and identifies, i
00:27:36feel like as as being a citizen of of both
00:27:39countries. what's a moment, what are the moments beyond the the
00:27:43history of the Canadian armed forces in
00:27:47in uh in the netherlands? beyond that, what are the
00:27:50moments or moment where you feel your Canadian pride
00:27:54stirring? you know
00:27:58when Mark Carney spoke and davos, his speech, that was
00:28:02heart. that was when I was really proud, the most recent time I was really proud to be
00:28:06Canadian and really proud that he's representing Canada
00:28:10in such an eloquent way and showing such great
00:28:13leadership, these are the leaders that we need in in the
00:28:16world, leaders with integrity, people who know what they're doing,
00:28:20people are knowledgeable, but people who also listen to their advisors and the
00:28:24experts, um that made me feel really
00:28:35country checkup. I'm mean Hannah Mansing. We're live in Vancouver and we're
00:28:38looking forward to hearing from you about how you feel about
00:28:42this this move towards at least you know being described as
00:28:46move towards and we'll kind of analyze how much we've actually moved
00:28:50towards Europe uh and maybe away from the United States and
00:28:54what you have at stake as Canada Shifts
00:29:16United States stalled last month, uh, you wrote that this is reshaping
00:29:20our national identity. tell us more about that?
00:29:23well, I think it it was a sort of drastic moment for Canada,
00:29:27because I mean, not only did we refuse American
00:29:31advances, which was... in itself um, but also I
00:29:34think what was kind of most interesting about it is rather than doing what
00:29:38everybody else was doing, we actually said, no, we know
00:29:42better, we're not, we're not going to do a jurisdictional sweep and figure out what what,
00:29:46what everyone in Europe is doing, we know better than everyone else, and we're not going to
00:29:50do this, and that I think is a moment of true independence for the
00:29:53country, and then when you watch the speech that the prime minister gave to the
00:29:57EU? Well, I mean, that speech was very
00:30:01confusing, because it was just... very unclear what it all, what it all means. I
00:30:05mean, the terms of associate membership and so on are are pretty vague, and I
00:30:09really think the devils in the details with this sort of thing, but I mean, I
00:30:12having more connections with Europe obviously gives us more sovereignty by giving
00:30:16us access to the resources that the EU has
00:30:20uh, particularly with financial instruments in tech, which I think are
00:30:23actually probably going to be the defining aspects of this
00:30:27relationship, along with the uh defense uh bank along
00:30:31with the the defense. spending that we're going to do with each other, as reports
00:30:34surfaced about whatever Canada is doing with the EU, the
00:30:38opposition leader Pierre Poliev tweeted, we will never be the 51st
00:30:42US state, and we will never be the 28th EU
00:30:45state. The prime minister of course, says we're not seeking membership, that
00:30:49seems to be pretty clear, though whether we are seeking
00:30:53something different is not so clear. Um, how do we draw the line,
00:30:57Stephen, between building alliances and protecting our sovereignty? -
00:31:01we're not giving up any of our... soverenty to Europe, I mean, that would, I think that would
00:31:05be totally unacceptable to the Canadian people, and and rightly
00:31:08so, um, but I, I think that's kind of obvious, also they
00:31:12wouldn't want us on those terms. lots of ways to
00:31:15do about this, the the finnish prime minister actually, alexander stub, he wrote his
00:31:19dissertation in the 1990s at the London School of Economics on what he called
00:31:23flexible integration with the EU, and we're going to have something like that, we're going to
00:31:27have, access to Erasmus Plus possibly, and few other things
00:31:31like this, but it's really, the deal with cohere is actually a
00:31:35sign I think of where the most exciting possibilities of this lie, which
00:31:38are you know technological um fusions and and and
00:31:42particularly financial instrument fusions, which are you
00:31:45know the really the hardest part for us escape
00:31:49the of us higem is is in tech, and europe can
00:31:53absolutely provide a way for us escape that, that's that's definitely worth
00:31:57pursuing. okay, let's quickly uh uh do a
00:32:00glossery, uh, cohere, guess an AI company, right? company,
00:32:04and erasmus plus, i'm afraid i don't know what that is. erasmus plus is their
00:32:08exchange stud is is there exchange program for universities and the university
00:32:11exchange program? mean i think that would just be wonderful for us. to belong to, but then of
00:32:15course I have kids around that age and it would be, incredibly beneficial for
00:32:19them.
00:32:32the liberals, capital L liberals want Canada to be more
00:32:35European, conservatives, capital C, want us to remain American in
00:32:39spirit, and if that is the case, uh, is
00:32:43that danger to... Canada trying to forge a
00:32:46unified identity, amid that political divide. Well,
00:32:50actually, I mean, what I what I wrote in the piece in the globe was that that's what it used to
00:32:54be, right? Like that, what used to be is the kind of this debate between
00:32:58liberals who wanted a more European state and wanted us to not necessarily to
00:33:02look towards Europe, but wanted us to be more like a European state, and conservatives who
00:33:06wanted us to integrate more with the United States and wanted us to be more American,
00:33:10but the truth the matter is that the America that we could integrate
00:33:13with is gone. Right, I mean, when you hear Stephen Harper talk about this,
00:33:17he's he's very clear about this, not just Harper, like many, many
00:33:20conservatives, um, and so that's that's a that's a real
00:33:24identity crisis for the Conservative Party for sure, um,
00:33:28but I think also for us, I think it represents a bit of a transition,
00:33:31because I think we, I used to think of us anyway as
00:33:35somewhere, you know, just in between Europe and America, and that
00:33:39was kind or maybe even just between the UK and
00:33:43and and America, but "now that's that's all over and
00:33:47I think we - our destiny, it seems to me is to
00:33:51both be more sovereign to ourselves, like more, like sovereignty
00:33:54obviously matters more now than it ever has to all Canadians, but
00:33:58also the dream of a cosmopolitan Canadian, the dream of
00:34:02a of a Canadian as a citizen the world, which is part
00:34:06of our multicultural reality, which is what we live, I think
00:34:09that's the identity we're moving towards and I,
00:34:12I, I think it's unique, I don't think
00:34:13it is something" that you can compare to other countries, i i think it's
00:34:17something that we alone possess and find it
00:34:21very new and find it very
00:34:32stephen marsh, journalist and host the gloves off podcast. he's in
00:34:36Toronto. in our next hour we have very special ask anything with Rachel
00:34:40Knotle and Jason Kenny together, the Alberta referendum
00:34:44coming up next month. two former Alberta premiers, one NDP, the
00:34:47other Conservative, will join us to answer your questions, so that is
00:34:51in our two. I hope you stay tuned for that. Right now, we're focusing
00:34:55on Canada's place in the world. Is Canada more like Europe or the United
00:34:59States? What's a stake for you? If Canada builds closer ties to the
00:35:03EU, 888-416-8333 or you can
00:35:07text us
00:35:0722675-8-89-24.
00:35:11So for lot of people it is just very personal and it has to... do with their family
00:35:15history, for some people it has to do with business. Romana
00:35:19Chibagu and her family own claba hair and
00:35:23beauty supplies, which is based in London Ontario, though we've reached her today
00:35:27in Rigina. How are you? hi, how are you today?
00:35:31good, good,
00:35:36States, strain though it is, is so important to your
00:35:39business? sure, so we've been in business business for
00:35:43almost 30 years, we started in 1997 and
00:35:46uh throughout that time we've we've grown as a brick and mortar business
00:35:50of uh black hair and beauty supply products so wigs,
00:35:54extensions uh hair preparations of all types and skin
00:35:57preparations. um at one point we had six stores across southwestern
00:36:01Ontario um and as e-commerce emerged uh we went in
00:36:05that direction and we still have some sp brick and mortar stores in London
00:36:07Ontario. you buy most of your inventory from the United States
00:36:11and uh Canada's counter tariffs have have hit
00:36:15bottom line, how much are these added costs affecting your
00:36:19business? absolutely, so it's a real operational risk
00:36:23for us,
00:36:25so um, if you
00:36:26know anything about black hair, that the macca black hair care is in america in
00:36:30cities like Atlanta, cities like Chicago um and New
00:36:33York, and so the supply pipeline pretty much goes right through America
00:36:37in so far as our suppliers, manufacturers and distributors
00:36:40and so a 50% increase is
00:36:44major concern for us because we have a small market in terms the
00:36:48black population, we don't just serve the black population, we serve many others, we we are
00:36:52essentially our goal is to ensure that folks can uh
00:36:55be the be the best version themselves. um
00:36:58but we we def niche market is our the black population in Canada
00:37:02and uh the 50% increase um it impacts
00:37:06our our ability to be able to pay our staff um it
00:37:09impacts we we do large shipments imagine out
00:37:12$10000 shipment that's now $150,00 this is very
00:37:16concerning for us um in terms of our sustainability and we're a
00:37:19multi-generational business so we're actually looking at the next
00:37:23generation which is me um and and my sister uh
00:37:26taking over so we wanted
00:37:28we want to be able to to continue another 30 years and
00:37:31so you probably heard Donald Trump reacting to Canada and
00:37:35the EU uh
00:37:37their talks right
00:37:38and and he kind of dismissed it as laughable and even said that he might
00:37:42punish Europe at least uh if if he felt that
00:37:45Canada and and the European Union were trying to hurt the
00:37:49United States um I assume all of that must have made you a little bit
00:37:53nervous um I'm I am concerned about
00:37:57the... of this policy
00:37:58we absolutely see that there could be opportunities not necessarily to partner within
00:38:02Europe, I think within our industry, we're looking at Asia and Africa, particularly
00:38:06where we see R&D innovation in places in Africa for example, there's a lot of
00:38:10like sustainable fibers that are used for lot the
00:38:14products that that we um that we distribute
00:38:16and and that's really interesting to us, but ultimately when we're talking about
00:38:20legacy quality brands that have been around for generations, we're talking about the
00:38:24American market um and so we definitely... do not want to
00:38:28entrench or exasperate um the situation, make
00:38:38we're certainly hoping that this can be handled delicately by our
00:38:40government. Romano, thank you very much for speaking with
00:38:43us. no problem, thank you, Ian. Romana Chibagu and her
00:38:47family run Kaylaba hair and beauty supplies. the
00:38:51business is in London, Ontario, though she spoke to us this afternoon from
00:38:55regina. our question, is Canada more like Europe or the United States, what's
00:38:59it stake for you if Canada bills closer ties with the
00:39:16ourselves from the United States might be the wrong move.
00:39:19why? well, Canada and the United States share a
00:39:23massive border trade from an environmental perspective makes more...
00:39:27sense within North America uh Trump's going to be gone in two
00:39:31years right, so the the entire
00:39:33everything changes then, so we have more of
00:39:37relationship with the United States than Europe, identify
00:39:40more with Americans and have lot of friends down there, done a lot of
00:39:44extensive traveling down there, and as an
00:39:48English speaking Canadian, even though I have a French
00:39:52name, the the you know Canada
00:39:55and and the United States. shares so much media and film and
00:39:59television and and there's much more of influence
00:40:03in our you know society from the United States than there is
00:40:07from Europe. So as you saw, whether it was
00:40:11clip on the news or on your phone or however, you got the information, our
00:40:15prime minister at the EU, being greeted so warmly and
00:40:19being met with a standing ovation, how did you
00:40:21feel? Absolutely prideful to be a Canadian
00:40:25to to know that, we're... we're so respected in the global
00:40:29community
00:40:30like that, but you know, we we haven't lost that respect
00:40:34from the United States, we've only lost it from a fringe minority group
00:40:38that managed to get a president in the white house for few
00:40:40years and that dynamic changes in two
00:40:44years. how about the idea of
00:40:48of making these moves towards Europe, just to kind of thumb our
00:40:52nose at the United States? if that is, I mean, it
00:40:55feels like tip for tat from from the perspective of just a
00:40:59regular carpenter canadian on the ground right? yeah, and so how do you
00:41:03feel about that? well, it it costs more money for my uh clients
00:41:07to build houses and uh buy stuff uh you know at
00:41:11uh at the project stores to you know finish their builds.
00:41:15yeah okay Andreay thank you very much for calling i
00:41:21watching the online reaction. let's bring her in again. hey Paris hey we
00:41:25were talking about your time in Ireland you were... student and I just
00:41:28wonder what nine months, I guess you were there in 2022,
00:41:32um, how did it shape your perspective as a student?
00:41:36yeah, I think it really um, anyone who has the privilege or ability to...
00:41:40do a semester or year abroad, i think they should take that opportunity. it
00:41:43really broadens your perspective.
00:41:47certainly lot the issues that i maybe had
00:41:51trouble with reconciling in Canada, i realized they had the same issues in
00:41:54Europe, um, maybe for different reasons, but it it
00:41:58really uh, yeah, it really broaden my perspective lot.
00:42:02all right, let's get to the uh online reaction and maybe start with something
00:42:05on our tiktok account. yeah, cbc news got this uh,
00:42:10comment on TikTok, the viewer wrote, join the EU, we haven't
00:42:13removed internal trade barriers, we haven't reconciled labor mobility
00:42:17rules between provinces, CETA remains
00:42:20unratified. It's time for Carney to focus on fixing Canada's
00:42:24problems rather than hoping and relying on other nations to do so for
00:42:28him. Stacyson in Hag
00:42:31Sascatuan sent us this message on CBC.ca/aircheck, she
00:42:35wrote: in Sascatuwan, I think we have seen too much influence from our
00:42:39Albertan. who are themselves far too americanized in their
00:42:42thinking. At this point in time, people in Alberta and Sascatuwan are more
00:42:46similar to Americans than Europeans, but I think it would
00:42:49be far better if the latter were true. I support Prime Minister Carney's efforts to
00:42:53bring us closer to Europe and move us away from the US. Dennis
00:42:57Freesen from Calgary shared his thoughts online. Also, he wrote, "For me
00:43:00personally, I see only gains for Canada in closer relationship with the
00:43:04EU. I have lived and worked in Canada, Europe, and the US.
00:43:08The US is at the bottom of..." the list by a big
00:43:17listening or watching Cross Country Checkup on CBC
00:43:20News Network and CBC Radio. This program is live, and so let me
00:43:24share with you some news which is breaking right now from British
00:43:28Columbia. The leader the provincial opposition party, the
00:43:31Conservatives, Carrie Lyn Finley has
00:43:34resigned, as you've probably heard over the last couple of weeks, actually
00:43:38more than a couple of weeks. many of her MLA's have left the party, the
00:43:42most recent to leave the party, announced that today, there was a lot of
00:43:46question about her status within her own party, carry
00:43:50linley status within her own party a caucus meeting last
00:43:53week, uh CBC News had learned that she had been asked
00:43:57to step down, and so she has done that, breaking news, the
00:44:01opposition leader in BC stepping down, and one the potential impacts of
00:44:05that is what the provincial NDP government will do in terms of
00:44:09calling an election. "there been a lot of rumors swirling around in this province that
00:44:13that might be imminent, though usually parties don't
00:44:16call an election while the opposition is without a leader.
00:44:20all right, let's get back to our topic of this hour, which is about
00:44:24Canada's move towards Europe and away from the United States,
00:44:28and how you feel about that, and what's it stake for you if Canada were
00:44:31indeed to build closer ties to the EU.
00:44:35Gregory Fitzgerald is calling us from Siri, British Columbia, just outside
00:44:38Vancouver, hi Gregory."
00:44:43very well. how do you feel about Canada uh and
00:44:47and our relationship to the United States and Europe? I think it's
00:44:51wonderful, absolutely wonderful, and the more ties, the
00:44:54better. And you by wonderful, you mean moving away from the states
00:44:58and moving towards Europe? No, we, the states is going
00:45:02through. A hard time within
00:45:06itself, so we can still trade with other countries.
00:45:10around the world, this is why I'm so proud of our prime minister for
00:45:14stepping back from the discussions on the trades
00:45:18with the
00:45:18US,
00:45:23we this country is so unique in in
00:45:26itself from being
00:45:30multicultural excuse my voice, I have serious
00:45:33disability, no problem, we
00:45:36we we
00:45:37we were not we're not like Europe, we're not like any other. country in the world, we're
00:45:41unique in our own way, and that's what makes
00:45:45Canada so great around the world, everybody wants
00:45:49to be here, it's because like you just said,
00:45:52carry linley just stepped down, the people have a
00:45:56voice and things get done, this is the
00:46:00greatness about our country, and the more trade we
00:46:04have in Europe and as well other
00:46:07places if it works out, Saudi Arabia. if it works out,
00:46:11china if it works out a good
00:46:13way, like mark carne
00:46:17said, nobody tells us, who to trade with
00:46:20or who to do business with,
00:46:23so i i think you know we're like ourselves, we we
00:46:27Canada is just too unique, it's like we can't be compared to any other
00:46:31country in the world, gregory,
00:46:40Canada trades heavily already with the European Union, by the way, last year
00:46:44we bought $92 billion
00:46:46dollars in goods from the EU and sold 39 billion, that's
00:46:50according to Statistics Canada. with US tariffs looming
00:46:54pivoting to Europe may sound tempting, but is it realistic? whenever it comes
00:46:58economic issues like this, we turn to people like
00:47:02Mosha Lander, senior lecturer in the department of economics at Concordia
00:47:05University in Montreal, and he is in Montreal this afternoon. Hi
00:47:13are losing access to the United States market because the
00:47:17punishing tariffs, do you think expanding access to the
00:47:20EU can help or? fact in a substantial way
00:47:24offset those losses? it never hurts to have lot of
00:47:28trading partners, so even if everything we're going swimmingly with the
00:47:32US, we should still be pursuing other opportunities for other trade partners,
00:47:36whether in Europe, and Asia or anywhere else. uh, the more that you
00:47:39have, that's the diversity, that's the shock absorber that's needed, so that
00:47:43if something happens with any one partner, we have alternatives, i
00:47:47have zero interest in uh or zero problem with
00:47:51Canada trying to make this pit. but where my problem lies is that the prime
00:47:55minister in his recent speeches is kind of presenting it as an either or where
00:47:59he says that the world order is broken that we're going to have to move away from
00:48:02the the relationship with the US, that's not the solution, the solution is
00:48:06figure out solution on how to continue free trade with US
00:48:10while pursuing free trade with Europe uh and that's the first best
00:48:13solution. 10 EU countries still haven't ratified
00:48:17Canada's existing trade deal largely to protect their
00:48:20farmers from our... cultural exports, do you expect the
00:48:24EU will demand changes on how we protect farmers, and of
00:48:28course I'm thinking about supply management? yeah, and that's why it
00:48:32hasn't passed those 10 parliaments yet. uh, don't forget that CETA was
00:48:36negotiated uh 10 years ago, so
00:48:39they had a problem back then, uh, and for all the talk in Canada about
00:48:43how Trump makes issue with Canada supply management problem, it's
00:48:46important to recognize that both presidents Obama and Biden expressed their
00:48:50own concerns with the policy, every federal leader in the election last year said
00:48:54that this was no-go area, they were not going to talk about it, they weren't going to
00:48:58compromise it uh, and I think the fact that we're willing to say that this is
00:49:02some line in the sand that we won't cross, is going to be the thing that continues to impeed our
00:49:05ability to make deals with countries uh, we we've talked in the
00:49:09past about how Canada sometimes uh gives up leverage in these
00:49:13negotiations by hurting itself. This is one of those areas where I I think that we
00:49:17do need to have a conversation about what exactly is it that Canada is getting from
00:49:21this policy
00:49:21of supply management.
00:49:22and what does it cost in Canada
00:49:24and in particular the Canadian consumer,
00:49:26how much better off would we be, how much less would our cost of living and
00:49:29affordability issues be, if we were to have the conversation about maybe moving beyond
00:49:33this. as Mark Carney was in Europe to speak to
00:49:37the the European parliament, Donald Trump said that if he
00:49:41considers this Canada EU deal or whatever is
00:49:45going on there as hostile act, he would slap tariffs
00:49:49on the EU or maybe even stop trading with Europe, all
00:49:52together, what's the actual economic risk
00:49:55here? their risk to the
00:49:59US is if Canada finds that there are producers in Europe that can
00:50:03supply us with products uh more productively, less
00:50:06expensively, then of course we're going to move towards Europe, but that doesn't mean that
00:50:10we're going to move the entirety of our supply chain to Europe, it doesn't mean that all of
00:50:14sudden we're going to be importing from Europe
00:50:17$365 billion a year like we are currently from the US
00:50:21uh so if he stand up for those businesses that stand to lose
00:50:25uh, why exactly are we buying from the US and not from Europe? if it's
00:50:28because there are tariffs on Europe that make them uh less
00:50:32efficient, but in the absence of those tariffs they would be uh the
00:50:36efficient producer, that's actually a good thing for Canada,
00:50:39and I can understand why Trump would want to try and stick up for his US producers, but I don't think
00:50:43that's the motivation here, I think it's just purely that if Canada is trying to stand up to
00:50:47Trump by saying we're going to look to find uh trade partners that maybe do want
00:50:51to do business with us, aren't going to try and use it as a weapon uh, I
00:50:55think that's where his problem lies, and when Mark Carney has spoken about that
00:50:59trade is not a zero sum game, and that we have
00:51:01to be a little more respectful the
00:51:02of way that we deal with countries in the world, uh, in that part he's dead on
00:51:06correct, and Trump really is missing the mark here again, where he just
00:51:10doesn't understand how trade works. Let me finish by asking a version of
00:51:14our show question to you and you can answer it as economist or
00:51:18outside of your work as economist is Canada more like Europe or
00:51:22the... United States, you know, I seem to recall that
00:51:25there was a poll and I,
00:51:26I might be wrong with my facts, but I i think
00:51:28it was like the globan mail at the turn the century, ask Canadians, what makes Canadians
00:51:32Canadians uh, and I seem to recall among that top 10 list were things like Tim
00:51:36Hortons and Hockey and our weather and all the stuff that you would expect, but
00:51:39the number one answer was, what makes Canadians Canadians is we're not
00:51:43Americans, so I think part of our identity is in
00:51:47just saying that while we look a like talk like share common culture,
00:51:50history, values and things like that, 'don't you confuse us with Americans and
00:51:54whether that's a point of pride or whether that's big brother, little brother uh envy sort
00:51:58of thing. I lot of Canadians will say that when they travel, they travel with that Canadian
00:52:02flag uh, because otherwise we might be'. used for something that we don't want to be
00:52:06associated with, and that's at the best of times, so uh,
00:52:09you know, I i think that we like to think of ourselves as more
00:52:12European than American, but it's often funny that when we see Europeans try and
00:52:16analyze Canada, they say, you're a lot more like the US than you might care to
00:52:20admit uh, and that's where we get a little bit bent out of shape that, what do you mean, but it
00:52:24it's hard not to be uh a little more American than would like to admit
00:52:27given uh the amount of television and music and culture and arts that we're
00:52:31exposed to uh at some point that filters over into our language.
00:52:35uh and the way that we behave, and of course for all the Canadians that are proud the
00:52:39you that appears in uh some of our words like
00:52:42labor, uh,
00:52:44you know, there's another generation that's coming along that says, I don't have time for this
00:52:47silliness, uh, if the easiest way to do
00:52:49it is to spell it without the you like the Americans do, or to spell words that
00:52:53should end in I, se as I z e, or even
00:52:57pronounce the z is z. you, I think with each passing
00:53:00generation uh, that idea of don't you confuse us with Americans is weakening
00:53:04a little bit.
00:53:20you very much for speaking with us, and mosha lander, senior lecturer in the
00:53:24department of economics at Concordia University in Montreal. Coming up,
00:53:28we'll speak to an expert on Canada, US trade about how closer
00:53:31ties with the US could affect our Kuzma negotiations.
00:53:35Our number here on Cross Country Checkup
00:53:37888-416-8333 or you can text us
00:53:40226758-8924.
00:53:45Pete Mazy is in Chetwin British Columbia. Hi
00:53:47Pete. Hello. You lived in the
00:53:51UK? Do you think Canada is closer to the United States or
00:53:54Europe? Well, I'm British by birth and I was in the
00:53:57British Army, but I'm also Canadian, right? So
00:54:00I got half of my family. I've lived all over Europe and
00:54:04worked. been to Germany, Austria, all those places, we've got way more in common
00:54:08with the states, like we got hockey, baseball,
00:54:11football, uh, my great grandparents came up from
00:54:15Utah, my girlfriend's great grandparents came up from North
00:54:18Dakota, uh, the first Asians people don't recognize
00:54:22the medicine line, hope you remember that, the black,
00:54:26black foot for confederacy doesn't recognize the border, the
00:54:30Mohawks don't recognize the border, we've out in the west we've
00:54:34got rod. those and just got so much in common, my
00:54:38sisters used to live in
00:54:40uh uh
00:54:42the the lower mainland and we used to go across the border all the time, they never even used to
00:54:46ask us for passports, so it's interesting, so you were in
00:54:49the you were in the British army, you said yeah, so I mean there
00:54:53is lot of alignment obviously between the Canadian armed forces
00:54:57and go ahead, well we have our historical
00:55:00ties to England right, obviously who's a queen and all that stuff.
00:55:05like my neighbors are from Newfindland and you can hear it in their
00:55:08accents, like you can hear the Irish and the and the
00:55:11west country English in their accents and and some the you know some the
00:55:15stuff they eat and that so we do have lot of ties to England,
00:55:19but I don't know we don't have much in common with
00:55:22Spain, the main point of mine is we do have lot
00:55:26more in common with the United States and in the
00:55:29west at least I can say because that's my only experience
00:55:32is the furthest. i've been is a
00:55:36manitoba so we've got to you do have
00:55:40lot more in common with them, you can go back and forth across the border, you don't
00:55:44really notice a lot of differences, but one of
00:55:48my worries is getting closer to the EU is the EU
00:55:51isn't doing very well, Germany has bailed out so many
00:55:55countries in the EU over the years that even Germans, German
00:55:59Germany's economy isn't doing very well and even the country itself, like I
00:56:02was in Germany when I was in the military. "and they wasn't even
00:56:06cigarette butt or a piece of gum on the sidewalk, it was spotless and now
00:56:10I've heard from friends that it's changed lot, it's
00:56:14and you know countries like Sweden join the EU, they've got
00:56:18their crime rates gone through the roof, there's a I don't mind having a
00:56:22trade uh deal with the EU, but I don't any kind of
00:56:26close closer
00:56:50there. The debate we're having in the first hour, and actually we're
00:56:52going to spill over a little bit into the second hour the program, is about Canada's
00:56:56move towards Europe, away from the United States and what's at stake for
00:57:00you as a Canadian, as the prime minister
00:57:04contemplates, what? whatever it is that he's contemplating because there's lot that we
00:57:08don't yet
00:57:18again and Paris, what do you have for us online?
00:57:22well, it's remarkable to me how many people have written with their perspectives having lived in both
00:57:26Canada and Europe. Nicholas Hoffman and Dorville Quebec
00:57:30sentence this message through our aircheck form. He wrote, having lived half my life in
00:57:34Europe, and the other half in Canada, I believe Canada has similar values
00:57:38to Europe, such as helping each other out. Politically, our liberal and open-minded
00:57:42views are not that different from those the Europeans. The fact that the world
00:57:46order has changed is a good. reminder not to put all Canadian eggs in one
00:57:49basket. Jeff from Calgary also left us this message on
00:57:53aircheck. He says after traveling through both the US and
00:57:57Europe, I can say with full confidence that western Canada, especially the
00:58:00prairies is more similar in terms of
00:58:02core values, culture and economy to parts the United States then it is to
00:58:06Europe. It really is apples to oranges. And Matthew Barber and
00:58:10Edmonton shared his thoughts online. To he wrote, while there is room for
00:58:14closer relationship with Europe, there is no way that we could achieve this. of open
00:58:17access with Europe that European countries enjoy with each other, we can't even
00:58:21achieve that level of cooperation between the provinces within Canada
00:59:23okay, back to the online stuff, we'll talk to you next hour, and as we
00:59:27get ready to sign off from CBC News Network, I want to promote what's
00:59:31going to happen in about 15 minutes on this program. we are going to continue our
00:59:35conversation about Canada, Europe and the United States until about
00:59:39quarter after the next hour, and then we have two
00:59:42former Alberta Premiers who were once fierce partisan
00:59:46rivals. Rachel Notley who represented the NDP and then
00:59:50succeeded by Jason Kenny, a long-time conservative,
00:59:54uh, former premiers now, and they're going to be here to answer your
00:59:57questions about Alberta separatism, so
01:00:01great to have both them on the program, great for you to have an opportunity to
01:00:05talk to them, same number
01:00:15is Cross Country Checkup, I mean Hannah Mansingh in Vancouver, is Canada more
01:00:18like Europe or the United States, what's at stake if Canada builds
01:00:22closer ties to the
01:01:01going on right now with the prime minister, speaking?
Data courtesy of The GDELT Project (gdeltproject.org), from the Internet Archive TV News Archive. Film strip and transcript are GDELT's, rehosted here under their terms of use, which permit it with this citation.