Canada: CBC News Network — The Fifth Estate

20261102 00:00 UTC · 01:01:00 · 752 transcript segments · GDELT Visual Explorer · plain-text transcript · Event Map

Boys are going missing across Canada, lured by gangs into a world of crime and danger. We investigate what happened to a Black teen from Brampton and learn about risks in remote corners of Canada from another boy who first went missing at age 12.

Film strip

One frame every 4 seconds, 915 in all. Click a frame to jump the transcript to that moment, or click a line of the transcript to see what was on screen while it was said. Served from apprised.news, so it loads behind proxies that block Google Cloud Storage.

00:00:00
00:00:04
00:00:08
00:00:12
00:00:16
00:00:20
00:00:24
00:00:28
00:00:32
00:00:36
00:00:40
00:00:44
00:00:48
00:00:52
00:00:56
00:01:00
00:01:04
00:01:08
00:01:12
00:01:16
00:01:20
00:01:24
00:01:28
00:01:32
00:01:36
00:01:40
00:01:44
00:01:48
00:01:52
00:01:56
00:02:00
00:02:04
00:02:08
00:02:12
00:02:16
00:02:20
00:02:24
00:02:28
00:02:32
00:02:36
00:02:40
00:02:44
00:02:48
00:02:52
00:02:56
00:03:00
00:03:04
00:03:08
00:03:12
00:03:16
00:03:20
00:03:24
00:03:28
00:03:32
00:03:36
00:03:40
00:03:44
00:03:48
00:03:52
00:03:56
00:04:00
00:04:04
00:04:08
00:04:12
00:04:16
00:04:20
00:04:24
00:04:28
00:04:32
00:04:36
00:04:40
00:04:44
00:04:48
00:04:52
00:04:56
00:05:00
00:05:04
00:05:08
00:05:12
00:05:16
00:05:20
00:05:24
00:05:28
00:05:32
00:05:36
00:05:40
00:05:44
00:05:48
00:05:52
00:05:56
00:06:00
00:06:04
00:06:08
00:06:12
00:06:16
00:06:20
00:06:24
00:06:28
00:06:32
00:06:36
00:06:40
00:06:44
00:06:48
00:06:52
00:06:56
00:07:00
00:07:04
00:07:08
00:07:12
00:07:16
00:07:20
00:07:24
00:07:28
00:07:32
00:07:36
00:07:40
00:07:44
00:07:48
00:07:52
00:07:56
00:08:00
00:08:04
00:08:08
00:08:12
00:08:16
00:08:20
00:08:24
00:08:28
00:08:32
00:08:36
00:08:40
00:08:44
00:08:48
00:08:52
00:08:56
00:09:00
00:09:04
00:09:08
00:09:12
00:09:16
00:09:20
00:09:24
00:09:28
00:09:32
00:09:36
00:09:40
00:09:44
00:09:48
00:09:52
00:09:56
00:10:00
00:10:04
00:10:08
00:10:12
00:10:16
00:10:20
00:10:24
00:10:28
00:10:32
00:10:36
00:10:40
00:10:44
00:10:48
00:10:52
00:10:56
00:11:00
00:11:04
00:11:08
00:11:12
00:11:16
00:11:20
00:11:24
00:11:28
00:11:32
00:11:36
00:11:40
00:11:44
00:11:48
00:11:52
00:11:56
00:12:00
00:12:04
00:12:08
00:12:12
00:12:16
00:12:20
00:12:24
00:12:28
00:12:32
00:12:36
00:12:40
00:12:44
00:12:48
00:12:52
00:12:56
00:13:00
00:13:04
00:13:08
00:13:12
00:13:16
00:13:20
00:13:24
00:13:28
00:13:32
00:13:36
00:13:40
00:13:44
00:13:48
00:13:52
00:13:56
00:14:00
00:14:04
00:14:08
00:14:12
00:14:16
00:14:20
00:14:24
00:14:28
00:14:32
00:14:36
00:14:40
00:14:44
00:14:48
00:14:52
00:14:56
00:15:00
00:15:04
00:15:08
00:15:12
00:15:16
00:15:20
00:15:24
00:15:28
00:15:32
00:15:36
00:15:40
00:15:44
00:15:48
00:15:52
00:15:56
00:16:00
00:16:04
00:16:08
00:16:12
00:16:16
00:16:20
00:16:24
00:16:28
00:16:32
00:16:36
00:16:40
00:16:44
00:16:48
00:16:52
00:16:56
00:17:00
00:17:04
00:17:08
00:17:12
00:17:16
00:17:20
00:17:24
00:17:28
00:17:32
00:17:36
00:17:40
00:17:44
00:17:48
00:17:52
00:17:56
00:18:00
00:18:04
00:18:08
00:18:12
00:18:16
00:18:20
00:18:24
00:18:28
00:18:32
00:18:36
00:18:40
00:18:44
00:18:48
00:18:52
00:18:56
00:19:00
00:19:04
00:19:08
00:19:12
00:19:16
00:19:20
00:19:24
00:19:28
00:19:32
00:19:36
00:19:40
00:19:44
00:19:48
00:19:52
00:19:56
00:20:00
00:20:04
00:20:08
00:20:12
00:20:16
00:20:20
00:20:24
00:20:28
00:20:32
00:20:36
00:20:40
00:20:44
00:20:48
00:20:52
00:20:56
00:21:00
00:21:04
00:21:08
00:21:12
00:21:16
00:21:20
00:21:24
00:21:28
00:21:32
00:21:36
00:21:40
00:21:44
00:21:48
00:21:52
00:21:56
00:22:00
00:22:04
00:22:08
00:22:12
00:22:16
00:22:20
00:22:24
00:22:28
00:22:32
00:22:36
00:22:40
00:22:44
00:22:48
00:22:52
00:22:56
00:23:00
00:23:04
00:23:08
00:23:12
00:23:16
00:23:20
00:23:24
00:23:28
00:23:32
00:23:36
00:23:40
00:23:44
00:23:48
00:23:52
00:23:56
00:24:00
00:24:04
00:24:08
00:24:12
00:24:16
00:24:20
00:24:24
00:24:28
00:24:32
00:24:36
00:24:40
00:24:44
00:24:48
00:24:52
00:24:56
00:25:00
00:25:04
00:25:08
00:25:12
00:25:16
00:25:20
00:25:24
00:25:28
00:25:32
00:25:36
00:25:40
00:25:44
00:25:48
00:25:52
00:25:56
00:26:00
00:26:04
00:26:08
00:26:12
00:26:16
00:26:20
00:26:24
00:26:28
00:26:32
00:26:36
00:26:40
00:26:44
00:26:48
00:26:52
00:26:56
00:27:00
00:27:04
00:27:08
00:27:12
00:27:16
00:27:20
00:27:24
00:27:28
00:27:32
00:27:36
00:27:40
00:27:44
00:27:48
00:27:52
00:27:56
00:28:00
00:28:04
00:28:08
00:28:12
00:28:16
00:28:20
00:28:24
00:28:28
00:28:32
00:28:36
00:28:40
00:28:44
00:28:48
00:28:52
00:28:56
00:29:00
00:29:04
00:29:08
00:29:12
00:29:16
00:29:20
00:29:24
00:29:28
00:29:32
00:29:36
00:29:40
00:29:44
00:29:48
00:29:52
00:29:56
00:30:00
00:30:04
00:30:08
00:30:12
00:30:16
00:30:20
00:30:24
00:30:28
00:30:32
00:30:36
00:30:40
00:30:44
00:30:48
00:30:52
00:30:56
00:31:00
00:31:04
00:31:08
00:31:12
00:31:16
00:31:20
00:31:24
00:31:28
00:31:32
00:31:36
00:31:40
00:31:44
00:31:48
00:31:52
00:31:56
00:32:00
00:32:04
00:32:08
00:32:12
00:32:16
00:32:20
00:32:24
00:32:28
00:32:32
00:32:36
00:32:40
00:32:44
00:32:48
00:32:52
00:32:56
00:33:00
00:33:04
00:33:08
00:33:12
00:33:16
00:33:20
00:33:24
00:33:28
00:33:32
00:33:36
00:33:40
00:33:44
00:33:48
00:33:52
00:33:56
00:34:00
00:34:04
00:34:08
00:34:12
00:34:16
00:34:20
00:34:24
00:34:28
00:34:32
00:34:36
00:34:40
00:34:44
00:34:48
00:34:52
00:34:56
00:35:00
00:35:04
00:35:08
00:35:12
00:35:16
00:35:20
00:35:24
00:35:28
00:35:32
00:35:36
00:35:40
00:35:44
00:35:48
00:35:52
00:35:56
00:36:00
00:36:04
00:36:08
00:36:12
00:36:16
00:36:20
00:36:24
00:36:28
00:36:32
00:36:36
00:36:40
00:36:44
00:36:48
00:36:52
00:36:56
00:37:00
00:37:04
00:37:08
00:37:12
00:37:16
00:37:20
00:37:24
00:37:28
00:37:32
00:37:36
00:37:40
00:37:44
00:37:48
00:37:52
00:37:56
00:38:00
00:38:04
00:38:08
00:38:12
00:38:16
00:38:20
00:38:24
00:38:28
00:38:32
00:38:36
00:38:40
00:38:44
00:38:48
00:38:52
00:38:56
00:39:00
00:39:04
00:39:08
00:39:12
00:39:16
00:39:20
00:39:24
00:39:28
00:39:32
00:39:36
00:39:40
00:39:44
00:39:48
00:39:52
00:39:56
00:40:00
00:40:04
00:40:08
00:40:12
00:40:16
00:40:20
00:40:24
00:40:28
00:40:32
00:40:36
00:40:40
00:40:44
00:40:48
00:40:52
00:40:56
00:41:00
00:41:04
00:41:08
00:41:12
00:41:16
00:41:20
00:41:24
00:41:28
00:41:32
00:41:36
00:41:40
00:41:44
00:41:48
00:41:52
00:41:56
00:42:00
00:42:04
00:42:08
00:42:12
00:42:16
00:42:20
00:42:24
00:42:28
00:42:32
00:42:36
00:42:40
00:42:44
00:42:48
00:42:52
00:42:56
00:43:00
00:43:04
00:43:08
00:43:12
00:43:16
00:43:20
00:43:24
00:43:28
00:43:32
00:43:36
00:43:40
00:43:44
00:43:48
00:43:52
00:43:56
00:44:00
00:44:04
00:44:08
00:44:12
00:44:16
00:44:20
00:44:24
00:44:28
00:44:32
00:44:36
00:44:40
00:44:44
00:44:48
00:44:52
00:44:56
00:45:00
00:45:04
00:45:08
00:45:12
00:45:16
00:45:20
00:45:24
00:45:28
00:45:32
00:45:36
00:45:40
00:45:44
00:45:48
00:45:52
00:45:56
00:46:00
00:46:04
00:46:08
00:46:12
00:46:16
00:46:20
00:46:24
00:46:28
00:46:32
00:46:36
00:46:40
00:46:44
00:46:48
00:46:52
00:46:56
00:47:00
00:47:04
00:47:08
00:47:12
00:47:16
00:47:20
00:47:24
00:47:28
00:47:32
00:47:36
00:47:40
00:47:44
00:47:48
00:47:52
00:47:56
00:48:00
00:48:04
00:48:08
00:48:12
00:48:16
00:48:20
00:48:24
00:48:28
00:48:32
00:48:36
00:48:40
00:48:44
00:48:48
00:48:52
00:48:56
00:49:00
00:49:04
00:49:08
00:49:12
00:49:16
00:49:20
00:49:24
00:49:28
00:49:32
00:49:36
00:49:40
00:49:44
00:49:48
00:49:52
00:49:56
00:50:00
00:50:04
00:50:08
00:50:12
00:50:16
00:50:20
00:50:24
00:50:28
00:50:32
00:50:36
00:50:40
00:50:44
00:50:48
00:50:52
00:50:56
00:51:00
00:51:04
00:51:08
00:51:12
00:51:16
00:51:20
00:51:24
00:51:28
00:51:32
00:51:36
00:51:40
00:51:44
00:51:48
00:51:52
00:51:56
00:52:00
00:52:04
00:52:08
00:52:12
00:52:16
00:52:20
00:52:24
00:52:28
00:52:32
00:52:36
00:52:40
00:52:44
00:52:48
00:52:52
00:52:56
00:53:00
00:53:04
00:53:08
00:53:12
00:53:16
00:53:20
00:53:24
00:53:28
00:53:32
00:53:36
00:53:40
00:53:44
00:53:48
00:53:52
00:53:56
00:54:00
00:54:04
00:54:08
00:54:12
00:54:16
00:54:20
00:54:24
00:54:28
00:54:32
00:54:36
00:54:40
00:54:44
00:54:48
00:54:52
00:54:56
00:55:00
00:55:04
00:55:08
00:55:12
00:55:16
00:55:20
00:55:24
00:55:28
00:55:32
00:55:36
00:55:40
00:55:44
00:55:48
00:55:52
00:55:56
00:56:00
00:56:04
00:56:08
00:56:12
00:56:16
00:56:20
00:56:24
00:56:28
00:56:32
00:56:36
00:56:40
00:56:44
00:56:48
00:56:52
00:56:56
00:57:00
00:57:04
00:57:08
00:57:12
00:57:16
00:57:20
00:57:24
00:57:28
00:57:32
00:57:36
00:57:40
00:57:44
00:57:48
00:57:52
00:57:56
00:58:00
00:58:04
00:58:08
00:58:12
00:58:16
00:58:20
00:58:24
00:58:28
00:58:32
00:58:36
00:58:40
00:58:44
00:58:48
00:58:52
00:58:56
00:59:00
00:59:04
00:59:08
00:59:12
00:59:16
00:59:20
00:59:24
00:59:28
00:59:32
00:59:36
00:59:40
00:59:44
00:59:48
00:59:52
00:59:56
01:00:00
01:00:04
01:00:08
01:00:12
01:00:16
01:00:20
01:00:24
01:00:28
01:00:32
01:00:36
01:00:40
01:00:44
01:00:48
01:00:52
01:00:56

Transcript

Original Broadcaster Captioning (Enhanced). Treat it as a searchable index of what was broadcast, not a quotation record.

00:00:22NEWS COMING FROM OTTAWA. TRADE TALKS ARE CONTINUING WITH
00:00:26TRADE TALKS ARE CONTINUING WITH CANADA-U.S. AND EUROPEAN CANADA-U.S. AND EUROPEAN PARTNERS. PARTNERS. WITH THE RELEASE OF THE FALL
00:00:29WITH THE RELEASE OF THE FALL 2026 BUDGET ON THE HORIZON. 2026 BUDGET ON THE HORIZON. ON THURSDAY, PRIME MINISTER MAR
00:00:33ON THURSDAY, PRIME MINISTER MAR CARNEY IS GOING TO REVEAL THE CARNEY IS GOING TO REVEAL THE BUDGET.
00:00:36BUDGET. IT'S PREDICTED WE WILL SEE THE
00:00:38IT'S PREDICTED WE WILL SEE THE COUNTRY'S DEBT GROWING AND NEW
00:00:41COUNTRY'S DEBT GROWING AND NEW TAX BREAKS WILL BE INTRODUCED. TAX BREAKS WILL BE INTRODUCED. THE CARNEY GOVERNMENT HAS BEEN
00:00:44THE CARNEY GOVERNMENT HAS BEEN OPERATING IN FULL TRADE
00:00:45OPERATING IN FULL TRADE NEGOTIATION MODE REALLY SINCE
00:00:48NEGOTIATION MODE REALLY SINCE TAKING OFFICE.
00:00:51TAKING OFFICE. THE LIBERALS TRUMPETING WINS THE LIBERALS TRUMPETING WINS FROM EUROPEAN INVESTMENT AND
00:00:54FROM EUROPEAN INVESTMENT AND CANADIAN PROJECTS.
00:00:57CANADIAN PROJECTS. THERE'S THE U.S. SIDE.
00:00:58THERE'S THE U.S. SIDE. CARNEY POSTED THIS ON X TODAY.
00:01:02CARNEY POSTED THIS ON X TODAY. GOOD CONVERSATION WITH PRESIDEN GOOD CONVERSATION WITH PRESIDEN DONALD TRUMP ON THE FUTURE OF DONALD TRUMP ON THE FUTURE OF CANADA-U.S. TRADE.
00:01:06CANADA-U.S. TRADE. HE WRITES THIS BUILDS ON A HE WRITES THIS BUILDS ON A RECENT DISCUSSIONS ON THE
00:01:09RECENT DISCUSSIONS ON THE OUTLINES OF MUTUALLY BENEFICIAL OUTLINES OF MUTUALLY BENEFICIAL TRADE DEAL THAT WILL CREATE JOB
00:01:12TRADE DEAL THAT WILL CREATE JOB FOR OUR WORKERS, BOOST FOR OUR WORKERS, BOOST AFFORDABILITY FOR FAMILIES AND
00:01:16FULLY RESPECT CANADA'S LANGUAGES, CULTURE AND LANGUAGES, CULTURE AND SOVEREIGNTY. SOVEREIGNTY. HE GOES ON TO WRITE.
00:01:19HE GOES ON TO WRITE. OUR TEAMS WILL BE OUR TEAMS WILL BE WORKING IN THE COMING WEEK TO
00:01:22WORKING IN THE COMING WEEK TO DELIVER THAT OUTCOME.
00:01:26DELIVER THAT OUTCOME. HOST OF CBC MORNING LIVE DAVID
00:01:27HOST OF CBC MORNING LIVE DAVID COMMON HAS MORE.
00:01:31COMMON HAS MORE. >> David: THERE'S BEEN >> David: THERE'S BEEN DISCUSSIONS BETWEEN AMERICAN AND DISCUSSIONS BETWEEN AMERICAN AND CANADIAN GOVERNMENT.
00:01:35CANADIAN GOVERNMENT. THE TRADE TALKS HAD BEGUN ANEW THE TRADE TALKS HAD BEGUN ANEW THAT THERE WAS SOME
00:01:39THAT THERE WAS SOME DISCUSSION THE TWO SIDES DISCUSSION THE TWO SIDES CANADIAN SOURCES TELLING CBC CANADIAN SOURCES TELLING CBC NEWS JOURNALISTS WE ARE FAR
00:01:43NEWS JOURNALISTS WE ARE FAR APART. APART. IF THEY ARE REACHING THE LEVEL IF THEY ARE REACHING THE LEVEL OF PRESIDENT TO PRIME MINISTER,
00:01:47OF PRESIDENT TO PRIME MINISTER, IF A PHONE CALL LIKE THAT IS IF A PHONE CALL LIKE THAT IS HAPPENING,
00:01:50HAPPENING, IT IS A POTENTIAL INDICATION OF IT IS A POTENTIAL INDICATION OF SOME PROGRESS COMING. SOME PROGRESS COMING. YOU NOTE MARK CARNEY SAYING IN
00:01:54YOU NOTE MARK CARNEY SAYING IN THE COMING WEEKS. THE COMING WEEKS. AS WE HAVE REPORTED ON CBC NEWS
00:01:57AS WE HAVE REPORTED ON CBC NEWS NO DEAL BEFORE THE MIDTERMS. NO DEAL BEFORE THE MIDTERMS. IS THERE A DEAL IN THE COMING IS THERE A DEAL IN THE COMING WEEKS, QUITE POSSIBLY.
00:02:01WEEKS, QUITE POSSIBLY. NOT NECESSARILY.
00:02:03NOT NECESSARILY. THE N. CLIFF, JANUARY 1st THAT THE N. CLIFF, JANUARY 1st THAT IS
00:02:07IS WHEN THE NEXT TRAUNCH OF WHEN THE NEXT TRAUNCH OF AMERICAN TARIFFS TAKE EFFECT.
00:02:10AMERICAN TARIFFS TAKE EFFECT. THE DESIRE WILL BE TO DEAL WITH THE DESIRE WILL BE TO DEAL WITH THOSE TARIFF TO GET THEM
00:02:13THOSE TARIFF TO GET THEM RESOLVED.
00:02:16I'M NATASHA FATAH. YOU'RE WATCHING CBC NEWS YOU'RE WATCHING CBC NEWS NETWORK. NETWORK. THIS IS THE FINAL WEEKEND OF
00:02:20THIS IS THE FINAL WEEKEND OF CAMPAIGNING AHEAD OF THE U.S. CAMPAIGNING AHEAD OF THE U.S. MIDTERM ELECTIONS WITH CONTROL
00:02:23MIDTERM ELECTIONS WITH CONTROL OF CONGRESS HANGING IN THE OF CONGRESS HANGING IN THE BALANCE. BALANCE. AMERICANS ARE GOING TO CAST
00:02:27AMERICANS ARE GOING TO CAST THEIR BALLOTS COME TUESDAY TO THEIR BALLOTS COME TUESDAY TO ELECT ALL 435 MEMBERS OF THE
00:02:31ELECT ALL 435 MEMBERS OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ALONG HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ALONG WITH 35 SENATORS.
00:02:34WITH 35 SENATORS. THE POLLS ARE DEMOCRATS WELL THE POLLS ARE DEMOCRATS WELL POSITIONED TO TAKE THE HOUSE.
00:02:38POSITIONED TO TAKE THE HOUSE. THE BATTLE FOR THE SENATE IS THE BATTLE FOR THE SENATE IS EXPECTED TO DOME DOWN TO A
00:02:41EXPECTED TO DOME DOWN TO A NUMBER OF KEY RACES IN SOME NUMBER OF KEY RACES IN SOME STATES.
00:02:44STATES. FOR U.S. PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP, FOR U.S. PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP, THE STAKE COULD NOT BE ANY
00:02:47THE STAKE COULD NOT BE ANY HIGHER. HIGHER. LOSING CONTROL OF EITHER ONE OF
00:02:49LOSING CONTROL OF EITHER ONE OF THOSE CHAMBERS WOULD GIVE THOSE CHAMBERS WOULD GIVE DEMOCRATS MUCH MORE POWER IN
00:02:52DEMOCRATS MUCH MORE POWER IN ORDER TO BLOCK HIS AGENDA AND
00:02:54ORDER TO BLOCK HIS AGENDA AND LAUNCH INVESTIGATIONS INTO HIS LAUNCH INVESTIGATIONS INTO HIS ADMINISTRATION.
00:02:58ADMINISTRATION. THAT'S WHY HE'S BACK ON THE THAT'S WHY HE'S BACK ON THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL TODAY.
00:03:01CAMPAIGN TRAIL TODAY. HOLDING RALLIES IN IOWA AND
00:03:03HOLDING RALLIES IN IOWA AND KANSAS WHERE REPUBLICANS ARE KANSAS WHERE REPUBLICANS ARE FIGHTING.
00:03:07FIGHTING. LET'S DIVE INTO ALL OF THIS WITH LET'S DIVE INTO ALL OF THIS WITH JOURNALIST NICK HARPER WHO'S
00:03:10JOURNALIST NICK HARPER WHO'S FOLLOWING THE STORY WITH US FROM FOLLOWING THE STORY WITH US FROM WASHINGTON. WASHINGTON. WHAT'S TAKING PLACE ON THE
00:03:13WHAT'S TAKING PLACE ON THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL TODAY?
00:03:18CAMPAIGN TRAIL TODAY? >> Reporter: NATASHA, HUNDREDS >> Reporter: NATASHA, HUNDREDS OF LAWMAKERS RIGHT ACROSS THE
00:03:21OF LAWMAKERS RIGHT ACROSS THE COUNTRY OUT ON CAMPAIGN TRAIL. COUNTRY OUT ON CAMPAIGN TRAIL. REALLY ALL EYES ARE ON THE REALLY ALL EYES ARE ON THE PRESIDENT.
00:03:25PRESIDENT. AS YOU SAID, IT'S CRUCIAL WHAT AS YOU SAID, IT'S CRUCIAL WHAT HAPPENS IN THESE MIDTERM
00:03:28HAPPENS IN THESE MIDTERM ELECTION TO WHAT HE'S ABLE TO DO ELECTION TO WHAT HE'S ABLE TO DO OVER THE LAST TWO YEARS OF HIS
00:03:32OVER THE LAST TWO YEARS OF HIS PRESIDENCY. PRESIDENCY. HE THIS SUNDAY IS GOING TO TWO
00:03:36HE THIS SUNDAY IS GOING TO TWO RELIABLY RED REPUBLICAN STATE.
00:03:40RELIABLY RED REPUBLICAN STATE. IOWA AND KANSAS. IOWA AND KANSAS. THE SENATE SEATS IN BOTH STATES
00:03:43THE SENATE SEATS IN BOTH STATES SUDDENLY GOT MUCH TIGHTER AND
00:03:45SUDDENLY GOT MUCH TIGHTER AND DEMOCRATS FEEL THAT THEY ARE
00:03:48DEMOCRATS FEEL THAT THEY ARE WITHIN DIFFERENCE TO GRAB THOSE
00:03:51WITHIN DIFFERENCE TO GRAB THOSE SENATE SEATS.
00:03:53SENATE SEATS. THESE ARE TWO-STATES THAT DONALD THESE ARE TWO-STATES THAT DONALD TRUMP CARRIED BY DOUBLE DIGITS
00:03:57TRUMP CARRIED BY DOUBLE DIGITS IN THE LAST PRESIDENTIAL IN THE LAST PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION.
00:04:00ELECTION. IOWA HE TOOK BY 13 POINTS KANSAS IOWA HE TOOK BY 13 POINTS KANSAS BY 16 POINTS. BY 16 POINTS. THESE SHOULD NOT BE IN PLAY.
00:04:04THESE SHOULD NOT BE IN PLAY. THEY ARE. THEY ARE. IT'S VERY TELLING THAT THIS TIME
00:04:07IT'S VERY TELLING THAT THIS TIME AROUND DEMOCRATS FEEL THEY WILL AROUND DEMOCRATS FEEL THEY WILL BE ABLE TO FLIP SEATS THAT HAVE
00:04:10BE ABLE TO FLIP SEATS THAT HAVE BEEN RELIABLY RED FOR MANY BEEN RELIABLY RED FOR MANY YEARS.
00:04:13YEARS. PART OF THAT IS BECAUSE OF THE PART OF THAT IS BECAUSE OF THE DISSATISFACTION OF MANY VOTERS
00:04:17DISSATISFACTION OF MANY VOTERS FEEL WITH DONALD TRUMP'S JOB FEEL WITH DONALD TRUMP'S JOB PERFORMANCE OVER THE LAST COUPLE
00:04:20PERFORMANCE OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS. OF YEARS. >> Natasha: OVER THE COURSE OF >> Natasha: OVER THE COURSE OF OUR COVERAGE, WE'VE BEEN
00:04:24OUR COVERAGE, WE'VE BEEN FOCUSING ON A NUMBER OF KEY FOCUSING ON A NUMBER OF KEY STATES. STATES. LET'S TALK ABOUT MICHIGAN.
00:04:28LET'S TALK ABOUT MICHIGAN. THERE'S SO MUCH GOING ON. THERE'S SO MUCH GOING ON. THERE NOT TO MENTION CLOSE THERE NOT TO MENTION CLOSE ECONOMIC AND CULTURAL
00:04:32ECONOMIC AND CULTURAL CONNECTIONS TO CANADA. CONNECTIONS TO CANADA. IT'S THIS ONE DEMOCRATIC IT'S THIS ONE DEMOCRATIC CANDIDATE THAT'S BEEN GRABBING
00:04:36CANDIDATE THAT'S BEEN GRABBING SO MANY HEADLINES.
00:04:37SO MANY HEADLINES. LET'S TALK ABOUT HIM.
00:04:44LET'S TALK ABOUT HIM. >> Reporter: ABDUL EL-SAYED,
00:04:46>> Reporter: ABDUL EL-SAYED, IF HE WINS HE WELCOME THE FIRST
00:04:49IF HE WINS HE WELCOME THE FIRST MUSLIM IN IN THE SENATE.
00:04:57MUSLIM IN IN THE SENATE. IT'S BECOME CONTENTION. IT'S BECOME CONTENTION. IN THE LAST FEW DAYS.
00:05:01IN THE LAST FEW DAYS. THE PERSON THAT HE BEAT IN THE THE PERSON THAT HE BEAT IN THE PRIMARY, HALEY STEVENS, HAS
00:05:05PRIMARY, HALEY STEVENS, HAS BEGUN CAMPAIGNING WITH HIS BEGUN CAMPAIGNING WITH HIS REPUBLICAN OPPONENT.
00:05:08REPUBLICAN OPPONENT. APPEARING AT A CHURCH SERVICE APPEARING AT A CHURCH SERVICE THIS SUNDAY.
00:05:11THIS SUNDAY. SUGGESTING THERE IS DISUNITY SUGGESTING THERE IS DISUNITY AMONGST THE REPUBLICAN RANKS.
00:05:15AMONGST THE REPUBLICAN RANKS. ALSO IN MICHIGAN, WE HAVE SEEN
00:05:19ALSO IN MICHIGAN, WE HAVE SEEN THIS DIVISION BEING SOWN OF THE
00:05:25THIS DIVISION BEING SOWN OF THE PRESIDENT ACCUSED EL-SAYED BEING
00:05:30PRESIDENT ACCUSED EL-SAYED BEING A JIHADIST.
00:05:31A JIHADIST. THERE ARE DIVISIONS BETWEEN
00:05:36THERE ARE DIVISIONS BETWEEN ARABS AND BLACK VOTERS.
00:05:40ARABS AND BLACK VOTERS. EL-SAYED IS FINDING DIFFICULT TO EL-SAYED IS FINDING DIFFICULT TO WIND OVER BLACK SUPPORT.
00:05:43WIND OVER BLACK SUPPORT. THAT'S WHY MIKE ROGERS HOPING TO THAT'S WHY MIKE ROGERS HOPING TO PICK UP VOTES AND FLIP THIS TO
00:05:47PICK UP VOTES AND FLIP THIS TO REPUBLICANS. REPUBLICANS. IT WILL BE TIGHT ONE AND CLOSELY IT WILL BE TIGHT ONE AND CLOSELY WATCHED.
00:05:53In Pennsylvania's 7th Congressional District,
00:05:57everywhere we went we heard the same concerns. I mean,
00:06:01gas has gone from, you know, to something maybe 3 bucks to
00:06:05almost 5 bucks again and again. The economy prices,
00:06:10that's one of the major things. Affordability is a huge issue
00:06:14right now. And milk has gone up, gas has gone up, you name it,
00:06:19like the prices have gone up. This district, though small,
00:06:23stands out because it's a snapshot of the country's
00:06:27population, under a million but diverse in
00:06:30its makeup, rural and industrial,
00:06:33urban and suburban, some parts working class,
00:06:36other parts wealthier.
00:06:38How Americans vote here, the issues they care about,
00:06:41can predict what happens in the rest of the country. It's also
00:06:45one of at least three seats considered to be toss up races
00:06:49that could flip blue in Pennsylvania,
00:06:51where Republicans hold 10 of 17 seats.
00:06:57If Democrats were able to flip those seats and don't pick up
00:07:00or lose a seat anyplace else in the country,
00:07:03it would be enough for them to to take control of the House.
00:07:08Chris Borick is a professor at Lehigh University. He's been
00:07:12studying the forces that make Pennsylvania the consummate
00:07:16swing state. I think if Republicans lose this district,
00:07:19there is a multitude of factors that are at play. But there'll
00:07:24be 1 enormous overhanging topic and that is cost of living
00:07:27yellow Pennsylvania. I wonder. In recent months,
00:07:31President Trump has made multiple campaign visits to
00:07:34Pennsylvania in an effort to keep its congressional seats
00:07:38red. With a proud Pennsylvania patriots who are the heart
00:07:42and soul of US Steel. It was here he announced his 50%
00:07:45tariffs on steel and aluminum. He's we're going to bring it
00:07:49from 25% to 50%. The tariffs and rallied troops at the Mack
00:07:53Truck Plant, promising to revive American
00:07:56industry while endorsing Republican incumbent Ryan
00:07:59McKenzie. For more than 100 years,
00:08:01this legendary company has been making trucks right here in
00:08:05Eastern Pennsylvania, building the heavy duty
00:08:08machinery that keeps our economy rolling.
00:08:15This was Bethlehem Steel. You can see it's rusting now. But
00:08:18once a powerhouse supplier that helped build this country's
00:08:22cars, bridges and structures, it gives you a sense why
00:08:25Trump's promises of reviving American industry strikes such
00:08:28an emotional chord here. But will those promises be enough
00:08:31to keep this district in Republican hands? Well,
00:08:34compared to two years ago, they're certainly more
00:08:37skeptical of the promises. We've seen this through poll.
00:08:42There are some real divides from the very industries
00:08:45Trump's tariffs claim to help. What are we looking at here,
00:08:48Mike? So there's some shirts that
00:08:50we've had through the years. You know,
00:08:52just ask Mack truck employee Mike Shupp,
00:08:55who's also the president of the local United Auto Workers union.
00:08:58So you don't think that his promises have come to fruition
00:09:02and you're tired of waiting? We don't have any time left to
00:09:05wait.
00:09:07Last year, Mack Trucks was one of a number
00:09:10of companies that issued a warning to the Trump
00:09:13administration over the negative impact of auto tariffs,
00:09:16while the United Auto Workers national chapter backed Trump.
00:09:20Are you getting rid of this? One?
00:09:22Shop takes note that Trump wasn't able to stop Mac from
00:09:26opening a factory in Mexico this year,
00:09:28threatening jobs at his plant. He's ready to give a new
00:09:32candidate, a Democrat, a chance. We have weighed what
00:09:35Ryan McKenzie has done for us versus what we've asked him to
00:09:39do and he's been found lacking. That's where Bob Brooks is
00:09:43making his promises to our agenda and we're going to give
00:09:47him an opportunity. He understands the the jobs need
00:09:50to be protected. We have pushed them on the USMC a he's going
00:09:54to advocate for us. While Shop agrees with some tariffs,
00:09:58he thinks Trump's policies have also hurt important trade
00:10:02relationships like the one with Canada,
00:10:04the states biggest international trading partner.
00:10:07So you consider Canada good customer
00:10:131060 then? Some have also blamed the
00:10:16tariffs for higher prices, part of the larger conversation
00:10:20and dissatisfaction with tariffs,
00:10:22which are part of a larger conversation and
00:10:25dissatisfaction with the cost of living
00:10:29at this bike shop. Owner Lisa Ronka blames tariffs for some
00:10:32of the strain she's feeling in her own business. Take these
00:10:36bikes imported from Canada. Now that's gone up or other
00:10:39accessories she sells in the shop. Definitely went up a lot.
00:10:42I mean, even these bags topic, it's a little frustrating
00:10:46because it, yeah, I mean, it, it's not benefiting us. So to
00:10:49have somebody say they're going to do something that is going
00:10:53to help you, but it just doesn't. The
00:10:55problem is all the retail prices went up. And then again,
00:10:58our profit margin is less
00:11:01true to the district swing sensibilities. Some
00:11:04conservative voters have more patience for Trump's promises.
00:11:07So I don't look at it as anything being backfired. It
00:11:11just takes time. You know, we haven't had an equal plane
00:11:14in a long time, especially with Canada. But,
00:11:17you know, so he's just leveling the
00:11:19playing field. What we've learned from talking to so many
00:11:23voters in this district is just how fiercely independent they
00:11:27can be, refusing any party loyalties.
00:11:29And past election results prove that Republicans and Democrats,
00:11:331M lost here by tight margins. And that's why this time around,
00:11:37for both candidates, grassroots campaigning has been
00:11:41the way to go.
00:11:43Thank you. Go get it
00:11:46at Ryan Mckenzie's campaign headquarters. That means
00:11:49launching people to door knock on a Sunday
00:11:53and at this mixer. For Democrats,
00:11:55it's about convincing undecideds in marginal
00:11:58communities, like the districts growing
00:12:01Asian population to support blue. And many of our voters
00:12:05are independent, so they're not Democrat or
00:12:07Republican. So they're really ripe to be convinced which
00:12:11party is going to be looking after their interest.
00:12:15Republican support has typically come from some of the
00:12:18more rural parts of the state. Another slim Republican win
00:12:22could depend on whether they're energized enough to vote.
00:12:26And those fractures and fissures within the Republican
00:12:30coalition, while not gigantic, could be impactful. If you
00:12:34don't have those folks turn out over the last few months,
00:12:38the Trump flags have have gone away. People that have had
00:12:42Trump flags up for years and years have taken them down.
00:12:47Some agenda looms large, even if his name is not on the
00:12:51ballot.
00:12:54It's the biggest test of Donald Trump's presidency. Do me a
00:12:57favor, just pretend I'm on the ballot
00:12:59as Americans make their choice. Choose CBC News for the
00:13:02Canadian point of view. America votes the midterms everywhere
00:13:06you get CBC News.
00:13:09LET'S STICK WITH FEDERAL POLITICS.
00:13:11POLITICS. VOTERS ARE GOING TO THE POLLS
00:13:14VOTERS ARE GOING TO THE POLLS NEXT MONTH IN SIX FEDERAL NEXT MONTH IN SIX FEDERAL BYELECTIONS. BYELECTIONS. PRIME MINISTER MARK CARNEY
00:13:18PRIME MINISTER MARK CARNEY CALLED THEM TODAY FOR CALLED THEM TODAY FOR DECEMBER 7th. DECEMBER 7th. THREE OF THE BYELECTIONS ARE
00:13:22THREE OF THE BYELECTIONS ARE GOING TO BE IN QUEBEC, TWO OF GOING TO BE IN QUEBEC, TWO OF THEM IN THE MONTREAL AREA, ONE
00:13:25THEM IN THE MONTREAL AREA, ONE OF THE RIDINGS SAULT STE. MARIE
00:13:28OF THE RIDINGS SAULT STE. MARIE BECAME VACANT AFTER STEPHEN BECAME VACANT AFTER STEPHEN GUILBEAULT LEFT POLITICS.
00:13:32GUILBEAULT LEFT POLITICS. THE THIRD BYELECTION IN QUEBEC THE THIRD BYELECTION IN QUEBEC IS MOSTLY RURAL RIDING.
00:13:35IS MOSTLY RURAL RIDING. LET'S TALK ABOUT TWO MORE
00:13:37LET'S TALK ABOUT TWO MORE BYELECTIONS TAKING PLACE IN
00:13:40BYELECTIONS TAKING PLACE IN ONTARIO, ONE THIS TORONTO AND
00:13:43ONTARIO, ONE THIS TORONTO AND OTHER IN SOUTHWESTERN TORONTO
00:13:48OTHER IN SOUTHWESTERN TORONTO AND BRAMPTON.
00:13:50AND BRAMPTON. BLOC QUEBECOIS LEADER INTRODUCED
00:13:54BLOC QUEBECOIS LEADER INTRODUCED THE THREE CANDIDATES.
00:13:57THE THREE CANDIDATES. >> THOSE PEOPLE AROUND HERE ARE
00:14:01>> THOSE PEOPLE AROUND HERE ARE CLAIMING THEIR DIFFERENCE.
00:14:04CLAIMING THEIR DIFFERENCE. RESPECTFUL OF EVERYBODY IN
00:14:07RESPECTFUL OF EVERYBODY IN QUEBEC. QUEBEC. RESPECTFUL OF CANADA.
00:14:11RESPECTFUL OF CANADA. THE VALUES WE CARRY ARE USEFUL THE VALUES WE CARRY ARE USEFUL FOR
00:14:16AS WELL. >> Natasha: AGAIN, IN FEDERAL >> Natasha: AGAIN, IN FEDERAL POLITICS THE BUDGET SET TO BE
00:14:20POLITICS THE BUDGET SET TO BE RELEASED ON THURSDAY. RELEASED ON THURSDAY. THIS WILL BE THE PRIME
00:14:23THIS WILL BE THE PRIME MINISTER'S SECOND AFTER TAKING MINISTER'S SECOND AFTER TAKING OFFICE LAST YEAR.
00:14:26OFFICE LAST YEAR. IN THE LAST BUDGET, CARNEY IN THE LAST BUDGET, CARNEY COMMITTED TO DECLINING DEFICIT
00:14:30COMMITTED TO DECLINING DEFICIT TO G.D.P. RATIO. TO G.D.P. RATIO. THIS YEAR THE PARLIAMENTARY
00:14:33THIS YEAR THE PARLIAMENTARY BUDGET OFFICE IS PREDICTING THE BUDGET OFFICE IS PREDICTING THE DEBT RATIO GOING TO RISE.
00:14:36DEBT RATIO GOING TO RISE. SPEAKING EARLIER TODAY, SPEAKING EARLIER TODAY, CONSERVATIVE PARTY LEADER PIERRE
00:14:39CONSERVATIVE PARTY LEADER PIERRE POILIEVRE LAID OUT WHAT HE WANTS POILIEVRE LAID OUT WHAT HE WANTS TO SEE IN THE BUDGET.
00:14:42TO SEE IN THE BUDGET. >> HE DOUBLED THE DEFICIT.
00:14:44>> HE DOUBLED THE DEFICIT. OUTSIDE OF COVID, CARNEY EASTERS
00:14:46OUTSIDE OF COVID, CARNEY EASTERS IS THE -- CARNEY'S DEFICIT IS
00:14:51IS THE -- CARNEY'S DEFICIT IS THE BIGGEST IN CANADIAN HISTORY.
00:14:54THE BIGGEST IN CANADIAN HISTORY. HE PROMISED TO SPEND LESS YET
00:14:57HE PROMISED TO SPEND LESS YET EVERY SINGLE LINE ITEM IS EVERY SINGLE LINE ITEM IS SPENDING MORE.
00:15:00SPENDING MORE. THE COST GET PASSED ON TO THE COST GET PASSED ON TO CANADIANS.
00:15:03CANADIANS. GOVERNMENT SPENDING BIDS UP
00:15:06GOVERNMENT SPENDING BIDS UP PRICES OF GOODS. PRICES OF GOODS. FAMILIES PAY MORE AND THE MONEY
00:15:09FAMILIES PAY MORE AND THE MONEY THEY BORROW. THEY BORROW. THAT IS WHY CONSERVATIVES ARE
00:15:11THAT IS WHY CONSERVATIVES ARE DEMANDING THAT HE CUT AWAY DEMANDING THAT HE CUT AWAY WASTEFUL SPENDING TO BRING DOWN
00:15:15WASTEFUL SPENDING TO BRING DOWN INFLATION AND TAXES SO CANADIANS
00:15:17INFLATION AND TAXES SO CANADIANS CAN AFFORD A GOOD LIFE.
00:15:20CAN AFFORD A GOOD LIFE. >> Natasha: NOW TAKE A LOOK AT >> Natasha: NOW TAKE A LOOK AT WHERE POLIEVRE IS STANDING IN
00:15:23WHERE POLIEVRE IS STANDING IN FRONT THAT TRUCK IN OTTAWA.
00:15:26FRONT THAT TRUCK IN OTTAWA. DISPLAYING THE NATIONAL DEBT
00:15:29DISPLAYING THE NATIONAL DEBT CLOCK.
00:15:31CLOCK. THEY DISPLAYS THE COUNTRY
00:15:34THEY DISPLAYS THE COUNTRY NATIONAL. NATIONAL. POLIEVRE'S AND FOR THE BUDGET
00:15:37POLIEVRE'S AND FOR THE BUDGET FOCUS ON OUT ASKING SPENDING IN FOCUS ON OUT ASKING SPENDING IN A LETTER TO THE PRIME MINISTER,
00:15:40A LETTER TO THE PRIME MINISTER, HE'S ALSO DEMANDING THAT ALL HE'S ALSO DEMANDING THAT ALL FEDERAL TAXES ON DIESEL BE
00:17:58We're learning more about the four people who died and two
00:18:00others injured after a single vehicle collision in Puslinch,
00:18:04Ontario. Officials from OP's Wellington County Detachment
00:18:07say around 1:30 AM on October 31st,
00:18:09a vehicle was traveling along Watson Road South,
00:18:12just north of Wellington Road 34. The vehicle left the
00:18:16roadway, struck a guardrail, and went into a ravine. OPP
00:18:19Puslinch Fire and Guelph Wellington paramedic Services
00:18:22responded to the collision. Four people were pronounced
00:18:26dead at the scene including a 19 year old man and 17 year old girl from
00:18:30Mississauga, a 19 year old man from Brampton
00:18:32and a 15 year old girl from Milton. Two others survived.
00:18:35Their surviving occupants include a 17 year old female
00:18:38who remains in hospital with life altering injuries and a 16
00:18:42year old female who sustained non life threatening injuries.
00:18:45Families have been forever changed and an entire community
00:18:48is searching for answers. Our responsibility is to ensure
00:18:51those answers are based on evidence,
00:18:53facts and a thorough investigation.
00:18:56The speed limit on this stretch of Rd. is 50 kilometres per
00:19:00hour. There is a warning sign to reduce speed just before a
00:19:03bend in the road. Investigators are still trying to determine
00:19:07the cause of the crash and if speed,
00:19:09substances or seat belts played a role.
00:19:12I don't believe that this vehicle had enough seatbelts
00:19:15for the amount of occupants that were in the vehicle at
00:19:18that time. But currently it's under investigation to
00:19:20determine whether or not speed or the seat belts were the
00:19:23causal factors. It's also unclear where the vehicle was
00:19:26coming from or headed towards. The OPP say this stretch of
00:19:29Watson Road will remain closed until the guardrail is repaired.
00:19:32Dalmanutha. CBC News Puslinch.
00:19:37I want you to look at something pretty disturbing. It's the
00:19:40aftermath of a train crash in Spain. You can see how bad it
00:19:44was, At least 69 dead, more than that injured. And
00:19:47people are furious. Overnight protests in Spain demonstrators
00:19:51demanding accountability
00:19:56they're not angry simply because the crash happened,
00:20:00they're angry because the crash happened again. Spain was once
00:20:04considered to have one of the largest and safest high speed
00:20:08rail networks in the world, but they've also now just had a
00:20:12series of devastating and deadly crashes. 3 Just this
00:20:16year, at least 39 people have died in
00:20:18a high speed train crash in Spain. A new investigation is
00:20:22underway in Spain after a second deadly
00:20:25rail accident in just days. But back to this crash. Normally,
00:20:28as with the other crashes, investigators would be combing
00:20:32through the area looking for flaws in the track or barriers
00:20:35to visibility or something that might tell them what the trains
00:20:39drivers were thinking. But this investigation will likely
00:20:43unfold very differently because officials seem to have
00:20:46pinpointed a big part of what went wrong long before the two
00:20:49trains even got close to each other. Let me show you what I
00:20:53mean.
00:20:58The crash itself is fairly easy to explain. 2 high speed trains
00:21:03are heading in the same direction, but one is stopped,
00:21:07the other is on the move coming from behind. That train doesn't
00:21:11realize the train ahead of it is in the way until it's too
00:21:15late. The impact is devastating and looks like this,
00:21:19but let's add detail. These are high speed trains capable of
00:21:23traveling up to around 300 kilometers an hour. We are in
00:21:27central Spain,
00:21:29between Madrid and Seville, and both trains are traveling
00:21:32South early in the morning. The train in front is run by a
00:21:36private company called Erio. The train about 25 kilometers
00:21:40back is run by Renfe, Spain's National Rail company.
00:21:43Between the two trains there are hundreds of passengers on
00:21:47board, most on the Renfe train. But
00:21:49when the Erio train hits approximately this point in the
00:21:53track near the town of Urda in Toledo province,
00:21:56something goes wrong, bringing both trains
00:21:59to a stop. You see, in Spain, you have what's called the LZB.
00:22:03It's a piece of safety technology that's continually
00:22:07checking train position, train speed,
00:22:10and then relaying that information to each trains
00:22:13engineer. When it works, it's also ensuring that two
00:22:17trains are never too close to each other. But when the system
00:22:21fails, as it did here, some kind of computer bug. If
00:22:25they don't know why yet, that system too has a backup
00:22:29which is to
00:22:30automatically stop all affected trains. So why did only one of
00:22:34them start running again? This is a two-part event.
00:22:38Clearly, if the if the if the if the
00:22:41primary system wouldn't have failed,
00:22:44nothing, you know, nothing would have happened. In
00:22:47the second part. There was clearly a human element
00:22:50involved.
00:22:56So now we're at 8:30 in the morning,
00:22:58about half an hour into a 2 hour trip,
00:23:01the two trains about 25 kilometers apart. That distance
00:23:04is important because about 6 minutes after all trains have
00:23:08come to a stop, the state owned company that
00:23:11manages the railways and manages signalling decides to
00:23:15take manual control of the situation. Here's a short clip
00:23:19between those signalers and the driver of the Renfe
00:23:23strain, which, remember, is behind the Erio train,
00:23:26the Martha.
00:23:28SO
00:23:32silly
00:23:35normal. So it's in Spanish, but a couple of other things
00:23:39that aren't immediately obvious when the dispatcher is
00:23:43authorizing the train to start moving using the BSL. He's
00:23:47talking about the Line Side Signaling Block system,
00:23:50which is a manual backup to the LCB. This system also keeps
00:23:55trains from hitting each other by dividing the track into
00:23:59fixed geographical blocks where you only want one train in any
00:24:03block at any given time.
00:24:05So if a train is here, it trips a signal light for
00:24:08trains behind to show red, meaning stop. Depending on the
00:24:11exact system a block behind that a driver might see a
00:24:15yellow light, but a train operator is
00:24:17basically looking for a green light which signals it's safe
00:24:21to travel at normal speed. That last part about normal speed is
00:24:25what the audio clip you just heard is referring to. I'll
00:24:28play it again.
00:24:31You know, the
00:24:33really,
00:24:35really
00:24:38call Martha normal. But here's the problem. These manual
00:24:42signaling blocks can themselves be about 25 kilometers long. So
00:24:46a signaling system with a sensitivity of 25 kilometers
00:24:50trying to direct 2 trains that are 25 kilometers apart isn't
00:24:54leaving a whole lot of room for error. And according to Spain's
00:24:59transport minister, the train the renfaire back
00:25:02should never have been told to start moving again since there
00:25:07was still a stop signal active on that line. And if it had,
00:25:11at least it should have been told to go at reduced speed.
00:25:15That's why the judgment call telling the train to proceed at
00:25:19normal speed, which is approaching 200
00:25:21kilometers an hour, is so confounding because what
00:25:24the transport minister says might have been safer given how
00:25:28close the trains were, would have been to order the
00:25:32Renfrey to proceed under driving on site rules. Meaning
00:25:36like driving a car, you don't go any faster than
00:25:39the breaking distance. You need to stop if you see something in
00:25:43the way. If the every system safety system goes down,
00:25:46you cannot just stop the whole railway system, right?
00:25:49In that situation, it makes sense for the train to
00:25:52go at 40 kilometers an hour. It's very slow speed. It gives
00:25:56you enough time to look at whoever is there. You can break
00:25:59the train completely fine. So this raises another question,
00:26:03why tell the Renfe to proceed at normal speed?
00:26:11I'll be fully transparent here. The investigation is ongoing.
00:26:15So we're very much getting into this. This is our understanding
00:26:19based on what's out there territory. But what seems to
00:26:22have happened here is that the company trying to direct the
00:26:26trains may have expected both trains to start moving together
00:26:30at more or less the same time. According to the same Spanish
00:26:33daily that obtained audio recordings in the moments
00:26:37before the crash,
00:26:38the ERIO driver had received the same order to resume normal
00:26:42speed, but 7 minutes later she called
00:26:44the control centre to say she was still stopped because she
00:26:48could not restart the train.
00:26:51Princeton, MN.
00:26:54Hmm,
00:26:57that dispatch from the stalled Erio,
00:27:00now in the way of a high speed train barreling down on it,
00:27:04reportedly took place minutes before impact,
00:27:07which doesn't sound like a lot, but had that information been
00:27:11relayed in a timely way to the Renfe train,
00:27:14maybe it would have slowed down. But right now there's no
00:27:17indication it received any notice to slow down at all.
00:27:21That train should not be an approach the other train by
00:27:25three kilometers if the basic system
00:27:27safety systems were in place. The only explanation is that
00:27:31these multiple layers of multiple systems that were for
00:27:35safety, they were either not activated,
00:27:38not working, over jumped or something got
00:27:41ignored. Right now my my personal feeling based on my
00:27:45professional experience is that the dispatchers were not well
00:27:50enough trains in terms of what to do with the primary system
00:27:54failed. As I said at the start, this is the third deadly
00:27:58train crash just this year in Spain. The others involved a
00:28:02very different set of factors, whether track wear and tear.
00:28:06But the common thread is this overarching question about the
00:28:10country's approach to safety and whether these crashes were
00:28:14preventable. And there's one other wrinkle,
00:28:16which is that this isn't just a safety issue but also a
00:28:20political one. I mentioned how protesters are angry. There
00:28:24also happens to be a national election coming up in less than
00:28:28a month from now,
00:28:29and voters may take this crash with them to the polls.
00:33:21OK, this wildlife centre in
00:33:22Abbotsford is dealing with phone call after phone call and
00:33:26it started with one type of bird. It's been dead and dying
00:33:31birds and it's the cackling geese,
00:33:33which it's avian flu and they start off with the cackling and
00:33:38then the IT seems to branch out more. She says they are
00:33:42averaging about 60 calls a day. This is the worst year we've
00:33:46had, absolutely the worst.
00:33:49They're just littered all over the place. Mellick says they
00:33:52aren't resourced enough to attend the calls. The province
00:33:56says viral infection can spread from wild birds,
00:33:58especially during fall migration. Highly pathogenic
00:34:01strains can cause severe illness and death in birds like
00:34:04Canadian geese and chickens. The BC Poultry Emergency
00:34:07Operations Centre says so far it isn't aware of any
00:34:10infections on farms, but it is keeping a close eye.
00:34:13We're remaining diligent. We're at the highest alert level that
00:34:16we have called the red Bio security level. The province is
00:34:19implemented an indoor order
00:34:21so that commercial poultry needs to be inside to minimize
00:34:25contact with wild birds. The province says the Fraser Valley
00:34:28is especially a high risk area because migrating birds remain
00:34:32there. But it's also noticing that wild birds are arriving
00:34:36later this year and unlike the wildlife centre,
00:34:38they aren't noticing as many sick birds compared to past
00:34:42years. There is a hypothesis that maybe this is due to the
00:34:45El Nino event. It's it's quite warm and it's that cold weather
00:34:49up north that triggers the birds to
00:34:51to migrate. S We're seeing fewer birds out on the
00:34:55landscape and fewer sick and dead birds submitted to the
00:34:58program than we did at this time last year. Whether that
00:35:02signals that there's going to be a lower case load or just a
00:35:06delay in the cases, only time will tell. The BC
00:35:09Poultry Emergency Operation Centre says strict measures are
00:35:13in place to protect poultry from farm gates being closed,
00:35:17only essential vehicles entering and going,
00:35:20proper PPE and better air filtration systems.
00:35:23Since 2021, avian flu has impacted more
00:35:26than 10 million birds in BC, according to the Canadian Food
00:35:29Inspection Agency, and that's the highest number
00:35:32across Canada. The province is urging anyone who finds a sick
00:35:35or injured bird to not touch them and call the conservation
00:35:38officer service hotline beneath breach. CBC News, Abbotsford.
00:35:44A super El Nino is building in the Pacific Ocean and it could
00:35:47have a big influence on our winter here in Ontario. El Nino
00:35:50is a natural climate pattern driven by unusually warm
00:35:53Pacific Ocean waters. This year it is tracking as the strongest
00:35:57ever. It is expected to peak in November or December,
00:36:00with its biggest impacts on Canadian winter weather
00:36:03arriving not long after. So what does that mean for Ontario?
00:36:07Well, there is no comparison for an
00:36:09El Nino of this magnitude since we haven't had one before. But
00:36:12based on what we know
00:36:14from previous similar events, it could mean that we're in for
00:36:17a warmer than normal winter with fewer prolonged stretches
00:36:20of bitter cold. But don't put away the skis or snow shovels
00:36:24just yet. A milder winter doesn't mean we won't see cold
00:36:27periods, significant snowfall or winter
00:36:29storms. El Nino can also shift the jet stream and storm tracks
00:36:32across North America. For Ontario,
00:36:34that could mean real ups and downs in temperature,
00:36:37with periods of milder weather interrupted by blasts of Arctic
00:36:41air. And in southern Ontario, that could translate into more
00:36:44freeze saw cycles and the potential for freezing rain. Farther West
00:36:48in Canada, El Nino typically brings warmer,
00:36:51drier conditions, raising concerns about drought
00:36:54and a worsening of next year's wildfire season. It's important
00:36:57to understand while El Nino's influence on winter weather in
00:37:01Western Canada is better established,
00:37:03its effects here in Ontario are less consistent and predictable.
00:37:07So what does that mean for Ontario? Well,
00:37:10the winter may be milder overall,
00:37:12but it doesn't mean winter weather is going away.
00:37:22>> HALF THE CONTINENT IS MOVING AND HALF IS NOT.
00:37:24AND HALF IS NOT. >> I LIKE TO HAVE MORE DAYTIME
00:37:27>> I LIKE TO HAVE MORE DAYTIME IN THE EVENING.
00:37:30IN THE EVENING. WHEN I CAN ACTUALLY HAVE FUN. WHEN I CAN ACTUALLY HAVE FUN. >> I HAVE TO ADMIT, I DON'T KNOW
00:37:33>> I HAVE TO ADMIT, I DON'T KNOW IF WE SHOULD GET -- WHICH SIDE IF WE SHOULD GET -- WHICH SIDE TO GO.
00:37:36TO GO. I DON'T KNOW. I DON'T KNOW. >> Natasha: NOBODY KNOWS. >> Natasha: NOBODY KNOWS. WE DON'T KNOW.
00:37:40WE DON'T KNOW. SOME SCIENTISTS KNOW. SOME SCIENTISTS KNOW. YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT TIME IT IS.
00:37:42YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT TIME IT IS. MANY CANADIANS HAVE WOKEN UP MANY CANADIANS HAVE WOKEN UP TODAY WONDERING WHAT'S GOING ON.
00:37:46TODAY WONDERING WHAT'S GOING ON. WHERE AM I. WHERE AM I. HALF THE COUNTRY HAS FALLEN BACK
00:37:49HALF THE COUNTRY HAS FALLEN BACK BY TURN THEIR CLOCKS ONE HOUR BY TURN THEIR CLOCKS ONE HOUR EARLIER.
00:37:52EARLIER. OKAY, SEVERAL PROVINCES AND OKAY, SEVERAL PROVINCES AND TERRITORIES OPTED TO DITCH THE
00:37:56TERRITORIES OPTED TO DITCH THE SHIFT AND STAY ON PERMANENT
00:37:59SHIFT AND STAY ON PERMANENT DAYLIGHT TIME. DAYLIGHT TIME. LINDA, WHAT IS HAPPENING? LINDA, WHAT IS HAPPENING? WHO AM I?
00:38:02WHO AM I? WHY ARE WE HERE?
00:38:05WHY ARE WE HERE? >> Reporter: EVERY TIME THIS >> Reporter: EVERY TIME THIS HAPPENS WE FEEL LITTLE
00:38:09HAPPENS WE FEEL LITTLE DISCOMBOBULATED. DISCOMBOBULATED. THIS YEAR MAYBE LITTLE MORE THAN THIS YEAR MAYBE LITTLE MORE THAN USUAL.
00:38:13USUAL. SOME ARE MOVING BACK AND SOME SOME ARE MOVING BACK AND SOME ARE NOT. ARE NOT. LET'S LOOK AT WHERE THE CHANGES
00:38:17LET'S LOOK AT WHERE THE CHANGES ARE HAPPENING AND WHERE THEY ARE
00:38:19ARE HAPPENING AND WHERE THEY ARE NOT IN MANITOBA.
00:38:21NOT IN MANITOBA. ALBERTA, NORTHWEST TERRITORIES.
00:38:24ALBERTA, NORTHWEST TERRITORIES. MOST OF BRITISH COLUMBIA THEY
00:38:26MOST OF BRITISH COLUMBIA THEY DID NOT DO THE TIME CHANGE.
00:38:29DID NOT DO THE TIME CHANGE. THEY MOVED TO PERMANENT DAYLIGHT
00:38:32THEY MOVED TO PERMANENT DAYLIGHT TIME. TIME. YUKON AND SASKATCHEWAN MADE THE YUKON AND SASKATCHEWAN MADE THE CHANGE.
00:38:36CHANGE. ALL THE PROVINCES, QUEBEC, MOST ALL THE PROVINCES, QUEBEC, MOST OF ONTARIO, SOME COMMUNITIES
00:38:39OF ONTARIO, SOME COMMUNITIES NEAR THE MANITOBA BORDER MOVING NEAR THE MANITOBA BORDER MOVING TO THE PERMANENT DAYLIGHT TIME
00:38:42TO THE PERMANENT DAYLIGHT TIME TO ALIGN WITH MANITOBA. TO ALIGN WITH MANITOBA. THAT HAS NOT MADE THE CHANGE.
00:38:45THAT HAS NOT MADE THE CHANGE. IN NUNAVUT AS WELL, THE CLOCKS IN NUNAVUT AS WELL, THE CLOCKS WENT BACK.
00:38:48WENT BACK. NOW IT IS THE SAME TIME IN
00:38:51NOW IT IS THE SAME TIME IN MANITOBA, ONTARIO, QUEBEC, PARTS
00:38:53MANITOBA, ONTARIO, QUEBEC, PARTS OF NUNAVUT AND THE SAME TIME IN
00:38:56OF NUNAVUT AND THE SAME TIME IN SASKATCHEWAN, ALBERTA AND THE SASKATCHEWAN, ALBERTA AND THE OTHER PARTS OF NUNAVUT.
00:38:58OTHER PARTS OF NUNAVUT. STAY WITH ME. STAY WITH ME. B.C. AND THE YUKON, THEY ARE NOW
00:39:02B.C. AND THE YUKON, THEY ARE NOW THE TWO HOURS BEHIND ONTARIO.
00:39:04THE TWO HOURS BEHIND ONTARIO. THAT PUTS THEM NOW ONE HOUR
00:39:07THAT PUTS THEM NOW ONE HOUR AHEAD OF WASHINGTON STATE, TWO
00:39:10AHEAD OF WASHINGTON STATE, TWO HOURS AHEAD OF ALASKA. HOURS AHEAD OF ALASKA. ALL THESE TIME CHANGES MEAN
00:39:14ALL THESE TIME CHANGES MEAN THERE'S GOING TO BE CHANGES THAT THERE'S GOING TO BE CHANGES THAT WILL BE HAPPENING IN OTHER PARTS WILL BE HAPPENING IN OTHER PARTS OF OUR LIVES.
00:39:18OF OUR LIVES. THINK ABOUT ALL THE THOUSANDS OF THINK ABOUT ALL THE THOUSANDS OF BORDER WORKERS WHO SCHEDULES
00:39:21BORDER WORKERS WHO SCHEDULES HAVE HAD TO CHANGE BECAUSE THEY HAVE HAD TO CHANGE BECAUSE THEY ARE NOW ALIGNING THEIR SCHEDULES
00:39:25ARE NOW ALIGNING THEIR SCHEDULES WITH THE NEIGHBOURING BORDER WITH THE NEIGHBOURING BORDER STATES.
00:39:28STATES. CALL CENTRE WORKERS, CHANGING CALL CENTRE WORKERS, CHANGING SHIFT TIME TO STAY IN LINE WITH
00:39:31SHIFT TIME TO STAY IN LINE WITH EASTERN TIME. EASTERN TIME. VANCOUVER AIRPORT SAYING THEY
00:39:34VANCOUVER AIRPORT SAYING THEY HAD TO MOVE SOME OF THEIR TIME HAD TO MOVE SOME OF THEIR TIME OF THEIR FLIGHTS BY AN HOUR IN
00:39:37OF THEIR FLIGHTS BY AN HOUR IN ORDER TO KEEP EVERYBODY MOVING
00:39:41ORDER TO KEEP EVERYBODY MOVING THE RIGHT TIME ZONE.
00:39:44THE RIGHT TIME ZONE. TECH EXPERTS WARNING EXISTING
00:39:46TECH EXPERTS WARNING EXISTING CALENDAR NOTIFICATIONS.
00:39:49CALENDAR NOTIFICATIONS. THOSE DOCTORS APPOINTMENTS THEY
00:39:54THOSE DOCTORS APPOINTMENTS THEY MOIT NOT BE THE -- THEY MIGHT
00:39:57MOIT NOT BE THE -- THEY MIGHT NOT BE RIGHT TIME.
00:40:01NOT BE RIGHT TIME. WE ARE ADJUSTING TO DARKER WE ARE ADJUSTING TO DARKER MORNINGS AS WELL.
00:40:04MORNINGS AS WELL. THERE'S SOME SAFETY CONCERNS
00:40:08AROUND PEDESTRIAN COLLISIONS INVOLVE IN THAT. INVOLVE IN THAT. THIS PSYCHOLOGY PROFESSOR SAYS
00:40:11THIS PSYCHOLOGY PROFESSOR SAYS OVERALL, THIS IS GOING TO HAVE A
00:40:13OVERALL, THIS IS GOING TO HAVE A WIDE RANGE OF HEALTH IMPACTS.
00:40:16WIDE RANGE OF HEALTH IMPACTS. >> WE WORK AND WE FUNCTION ON
00:40:19>> WE WORK AND WE FUNCTION ON THE BASIS OF LIGHT.
00:40:22THE BASIS OF LIGHT. WE NEED DARKNESS TO SLEEP AND
00:40:25WE NEED DARKNESS TO SLEEP AND RECOVER FROM ALL THE ACTIVITY
00:40:27RECOVER FROM ALL THE ACTIVITY AND ALL OF FUNCTIONS, DIGESTION,
00:40:32AND ALL OF FUNCTIONS, DIGESTION, EVERYTHING IMMUNE SYSTEM.
00:40:34EVERYTHING IMMUNE SYSTEM. THAT DEPENDS ON SLEEP.
00:40:38THAT DEPENDS ON SLEEP. ANYTHING THAT CHANGES THAT ANYTHING THAT CHANGES THAT RELATIONSHIP ONE WAY OR ANOTHER
00:42:55>> Marianne: THE PRIME MINISTER OF THE THE UNITED MINISTER OF THE THE UNITED KINGDOM SAYS HE'S OPEN TO CALLS
00:42:58KINGDOM SAYS HE'S OPEN TO CALLS FOR AN APOLOGY FOR BRITAIN'S
00:43:00FOR AN APOLOGY FOR BRITAIN'S ROLE IN THE TRANSATLANTIC SLAVE ROLE IN THE TRANSATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE.
00:43:03TRADE. HE'S IN THE CARIBBEAN FOR A HE'S IN THE CARIBBEAN FOR A MEETING OF COMMONWEALTH LEADERS
00:43:06MEETING OF COMMONWEALTH LEADERS AND WILL JOIN KING CHARLES WHO'S
00:43:07AND WILL JOIN KING CHARLES WHO'S IN THE REGION ON A TOUR.
00:43:11IN THE REGION ON A TOUR. CBC'S JULIA CHAPMAN IS FOLLOWING CBC'S JULIA CHAPMAN IS FOLLOWING THIS STORY FROM LONDON.
00:43:14THIS STORY FROM LONDON. WHAT IS HE SAYING ABOUT THIS.
00:43:22WHAT IS HE SAYING ABOUT THIS. >> Reporter: HE SAYS THAT >> Reporter: HE SAYS THAT ENSLAVED PEOPLE WERE DENIED
00:43:26ENSLAVED PEOPLE WERE DENIED HUMANITY AND THEIR RIGHTS WERE
00:43:27HUMANITY AND THEIR RIGHTS WERE BRUTALLY AND VIOLATED.
00:43:31BRUTALLY AND VIOLATED. HE RECOGNISES THAT THE PAIN AND HE RECOGNISES THAT THE PAIN AND SUFFERING THAT WAS CAUSED DURING
00:43:34SUFFERING THAT WAS CAUSED DURING THAT PERIOD STILL SHAPES THE THAT PERIOD STILL SHAPES THE WORLD TODAY.
00:43:37WORLD TODAY. BUT THE HEADLINE IS THAT THE BUT THE HEADLINE IS THAT THE PRIME MINISTER IS OPEN TO
00:43:40PRIME MINISTER IS OPEN TO HEARING CALLS FOR THE BRITISH HEARING CALLS FOR THE BRITISH STATE TO NORMALLY APOLOGISE FOR
00:43:44STATE TO NORMALLY APOLOGISE FOR ITS ROLE IN THE TRANSATLANTIC
00:43:53ITS ROLE IN THE TRANSATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE.
00:43:59SLAVE TRADE. HE DOESN'T BELIEVE FINANCIAL
00:44:02HE DOESN'T BELIEVE FINANCIAL REPARATIONS WILL BE FAIR.
00:44:03REPARATIONS WILL BE FAIR. HE DOES PROPOSE NEW EFFORTS TO
00:44:06HE DOES PROPOSE NEW EFFORTS TO RESTRUCTURE THE DEBTS OF POOR RESTRUCTURE THE DEBTS OF POOR COMMONWEALTH COUNTRIES.
00:44:09COMMONWEALTH COUNTRIES. INTERESTINGLY, THE LEADER OF THE INTERESTINGLY, THE LEADER OF THE CONSERVATIVE OPPOSITION PARTY
00:44:12CONSERVATIVE OPPOSITION PARTY SAYS TODAY THAT SHE DOESN'T SAYS TODAY THAT SHE DOESN'T BELIEVE THE U.K. SHOULD MAKE AN
00:44:15BELIEVE THE U.K. SHOULD MAKE AN APOLOGY OVER SLAVERY.
00:44:17APOLOGY OVER SLAVERY. BUT SOME CARIBBEAN LEADERS HAVE
00:44:21BUT SOME CARIBBEAN LEADERS HAVE WELCOMED HIS COMMENTS.
00:44:24WELCOMED HIS COMMENTS. INCLUDE THIS IS EXPECTED TO BE A INCLUDE THIS IS EXPECTED TO BE A DOING ON THE AGENDA AT THE
00:44:27DOING ON THE AGENDA AT THE COMMONWEALTH HEADS OF GOVERNMENT COMMONWEALTH HEADS OF GOVERNMENT MEETING THIS WEEK.
00:44:30MEETING THIS WEEK. >> Marianne: WHAT DOES THIS
00:44:32>> Marianne: WHAT DOES THIS DEVELOPMENT WITH BERNHAM AND HIS
00:44:39DEVELOPMENT WITH BERNHAM AND HIS COMMENTS MEAN? COMMENTS MEAN? >> Reporter: THE KING HAVE TO
00:44:43>> Reporter: THE KING HAVE TO WALK A DIPLOMATIC TIGHT ROPE.
00:44:45WALK A DIPLOMATIC TIGHT ROPE. HE'S IN THE CARIBBEAN RIGHT NOW
00:44:48HE'S IN THE CARIBBEAN RIGHT NOW TO PROMOTE BRITISH PARTNERSHIPS.
00:44:50TO PROMOTE BRITISH PARTNERSHIPS. IT CAN BE SEEN BY SOME AS
00:44:54IT CAN BE SEEN BY SOME AS DISTASTEFUL IF HE DOESN'T DISTASTEFUL IF HE DOESN'T MENTION AT ALL THE MORE MENTION AT ALL THE MORE DIFFICULT SUBJECTS ON THE MINDS
00:44:58DIFFICULT SUBJECTS ON THE MINDS OF MANY PEOPLE IN THESE OF MANY PEOPLE IN THESE COUNTRIES. COUNTRIES. HE HAS ONLY GIVEN ONE SPEECH SO
00:45:01HE HAS ONLY GIVEN ONE SPEECH SO FAR ON THIS TOUR.
00:45:03FAR ON THIS TOUR. HE DID ALLUDE TO THE LEGACY OF
00:45:07HE DID ALLUDE TO THE LEGACY OF SLAVERY IN THE BAHAMAS.
00:45:08SLAVERY IN THE BAHAMAS. TAKE A LISTEN.
00:45:13TAKE A LISTEN. >> WE ACKNOWLEDGE THE GREAT
00:45:14>> WE ACKNOWLEDGE THE GREAT SUFFERING AND INJUSTICES OF THE
00:45:18SUFFERING AND INJUSTICES OF THE PASS IN THESE ISLANDINGS EVEN AS
00:45:20PASS IN THESE ISLANDINGS EVEN AS WE ENJOY THE SUCCESSES OF THE WE ENJOY THE SUCCESSES OF THE PRESENT AND BUILD NEW
00:45:24PRESENT AND BUILD NEW OPPORTUNITY FOR THE FUTURE. OPPORTUNITY FOR THE FUTURE. >> Reporter: MOST OF THE
00:45:27>> Reporter: MOST OF THE KING'S VISIT TO THE CARIBBEAN KING'S VISIT TO THE CARIBBEAN HAS FOCUSED ON DEVELOPING
00:45:30HAS FOCUSED ON DEVELOPING COMMERCIAL LINKS WITH THESE
00:45:33COMMERCIAL LINKS WITH THESE COUNTRIES AND CHAMPIONING COUNTRIES AND CHAMPIONING ENVIRONMENTAL CAUSES AS HE DOES.
00:45:36ENVIRONMENTAL CAUSES AS HE DOES. THERE HAD BEEN A LOT OF LIGHTER
00:45:39THERE HAD BEEN A LOT OF LIGHTER MOMENTS.
00:45:41MOMENTS. HE WAS SEEN DANCING IN A PARADE
00:45:44HE WAS SEEN DANCING IN A PARADE IN BAHAMAS AND DRINKING RUM.
00:45:48IN BAHAMAS AND DRINKING RUM. THE KING ANOTHER SPEECH ON
00:45:51THE KING ANOTHER SPEECH ON TUESDAY.
00:45:58SPEAK WITH SORROW AND RESPECT. >> Marianne: JULIA CHAPMAN IN >> Marianne: JULIA CHAPMAN IN LONDON. LONDON. THANKS.
00:46:01THANKS. FOR A CLOSER LOOK AT BRITAIN'S FOR A CLOSER LOOK AT BRITAIN'S HISTORY WITH THE SLAVE TRADE,
00:46:04HISTORY WITH THE SLAVE TRADE, WE'RE JOINED BY MICHAEL CHARLES WE'RE JOINED BY MICHAEL CHARLES BANNER.
00:46:08BANNER. HE'S THE DEAN OF TRINITY COLLEGE HE'S THE DEAN OF TRINITY COLLEGE IN CAMBRIDGE AS WELL AS THE
00:46:11IN CAMBRIDGE AS WELL AS THE AUTHOR OF BRITAIN'S SLAVERY AUTHOR OF BRITAIN'S SLAVERY DEBT. DEBT. REPARATIONS NOW.
00:46:14REPARATIONS NOW. HE SAYS IT'S TIME FOR THE U.K. HE SAYS IT'S TIME FOR THE U.K. TO ACKNOWLEDGE ITS HISTORY WITH
00:46:18TO ACKNOWLEDGE ITS HISTORY WITH THE SLAVE TRADE. THE SLAVE TRADE. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US
00:46:20THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US THIS MORNING, MICHAEL. THIS MORNING, MICHAEL. AS WE HEARD JULIA JUST MENTION,
00:46:24AS WE HEARD JULIA JUST MENTION, BUCKINGHAM PALACE SAYS KING BUCKINGHAM PALACE SAYS KING CHARLES WILL CONFRONT WHAT IT
00:46:27CHARLES WILL CONFRONT WHAT IT CALLS THE SHAMEFUL ASPECTS OF CALLS THE SHAMEFUL ASPECTS OF BRITISH'S HISTORY WITH HONESTY
00:46:31BRITISH'S HISTORY WITH HONESTY WHEN HE ADDRESSES THE WHEN HE ADDRESSES THE COMMONWEALTH LEADERS.
00:46:34COMMONWEALTH LEADERS. WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THAT WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THAT DEVELOPMENT?
00:46:38DEVELOPMENT? >> IT'S A GREAT FIRST STEP.
00:46:39>> IT'S A GREAT FIRST STEP. YOU WILL KNOW, BRITISH PRIME
00:46:44YOU WILL KNOW, BRITISH PRIME MINISTERS HAVE BEEN PLAYING --
00:46:47MINISTERS HAVE BEEN PLAYING -- THEY'VE BEEN STANDING EW WE'RE T
00:46:51THEY'VE BEEN STANDING EW WE'RE T GOING TO TALK ABOUT THIS AND GOING TO TALK ABOUT THIS AND WE'RE NOT GOING TO PAY
00:46:54WE'RE NOT GOING TO PAY REPARATIONS. REPARATIONS. VERY DEFENSIVE. VERY DEFENSIVE. THIS IS BIG FIRST STEP.
00:46:57THIS IS BIG FIRST STEP. BRITAIN NEEDS TO ADMIT, FORMAL
00:47:04BRITAIN NEEDS TO ADMIT, FORMAL APOLOGY TO THE NATIONS AFFECTED. APOLOGY TO THE NATIONS AFFECTED. I THINK IT IS A FIRST STEP.
00:47:08I THINK IT IS A FIRST STEP. BECAUSE REPARATIONS FOLLOW BECAUSE REPARATIONS FOLLOW NATURALLY FROM THAT ADMISSION.
00:47:11NATURALLY FROM THAT ADMISSION. THAT'S WHERE WE WILL GO NEXT.
00:47:17THAT'S WHERE WE WILL GO NEXT. THE PRIME MINISTER OPEN TO THE PRIME MINISTER OPEN TO DISCUSSION. DISCUSSION. LET'S SEE WHERE GOES.
00:47:20LET'S SEE WHERE GOES. NO ONE SAID THAT YET. NO ONE SAID THAT YET. >> Marianne: SPECIFICALLY,
00:47:24>> Marianne: SPECIFICALLY, WHAT WILL YOU BE LISTENING FOR WHAT WILL YOU BE LISTENING FOR ON TUESDAY WHEN KING CHARLES
00:47:28ON TUESDAY WHEN KING CHARLES ADDRESS THE COMMONWEALTH ADDRESS THE COMMONWEALTH LEADERS?
00:47:30LEADERS? >> WE WILL OPEN UP THE TOPIC OF >> WE WILL OPEN UP THE TOPIC OF APOLOGY.
00:47:34APOLOGY. THE PRIME MINISTER SAID WE NEED THE PRIME MINISTER SAID WE NEED TO HAVE A CONVERSATION WITH THE
00:47:37TO HAVE A CONVERSATION WITH THE CARIBBEAN NATIONS ABOUT WHAT AN CARIBBEAN NATIONS ABOUT WHAT AN APOLOGY LOOK LIKE, WHAT DO THEY
00:47:40APOLOGY LOOK LIKE, WHAT DO THEY EXPECT FROM BRITAIN. EXPECT FROM BRITAIN. THAT'S A GOOD FIRST STEP. THAT'S A GOOD FIRST STEP. HE WILL SAY THAT.
00:47:44HE WILL SAY THAT. HE WON'T SAY ANYMORE.
00:47:46HE WON'T SAY ANYMORE. PRIME MINISTER -- BRITAIN
00:47:54PRIME MINISTER -- BRITAIN EXTRACTED VAST AMOUNTS OF VALUE
00:47:57EXTRACTED VAST AMOUNTS OF VALUE FROM SLAVE LABOUR IN THE FROM SLAVE LABOUR IN THE CARIBBEAN.
00:48:00CARIBBEAN. WE STILL BENEFIT FROM THAT. WE STILL BENEFIT FROM THAT. THE CARIBBEAN SILL SUFFER
00:48:04THE CARIBBEAN SILL SUFFER POVERTY AS A RESULT. POVERTY AS A RESULT. THAT'S AN ONGOING TRUTH.
00:48:08THAT'S AN ONGOING TRUTH. UNTIL WE ADDRESS IT, WE'RE UNTIL WE ADDRESS IT, WE'RE PASSING THE BUCK.
00:48:11PASSING THE BUCK. >> Marianne: WHAT DO YOU THINK >> Marianne: WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT THE PRIME MINISTER SAYING,
00:48:14ABOUT THE PRIME MINISTER SAYING, YES, THERE COULD BE AN APOLOGY
00:48:16YES, THERE COULD BE AN APOLOGY BUT NO TO REPARATIONS FOR NOW.
00:48:20BUT NO TO REPARATIONS FOR NOW. ARE YOU SURPRISED? ARE YOU SURPRISED? >> NO, IT'S DIFFICULT TERRITORY.
00:48:23>> NO, IT'S DIFFICULT TERRITORY. THE PRIME MINISTER WANTS TO SAY, THE PRIME MINISTER WANTS TO SAY, WE HAVE TO FACE UP TO THIS.
00:48:26WE HAVE TO FACE UP TO THIS. IT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE AS A IT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE AS A LOGICAL POSITION.
00:48:30LOGICAL POSITION. THE ARGUMENT HE'S BEEN USING
00:48:32THE ARGUMENT HE'S BEEN USING WELL, BRITAIN CAN'T BE HELD WELL, BRITAIN CAN'T BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR THE CRIMES OF RESPONSIBLE FOR THE CRIMES OF THE PAST.
00:48:36THE PAST. IT IS TRUE.
00:48:38IT IS TRUE. ENSLAVED PEOPLE, WERE RAPED ON
00:48:42ENSLAVED PEOPLE, WERE RAPED ON REGULAR BASIS ON THE PLANTATION.
00:48:48REGULAR BASIS ON THE PLANTATION. THAT'S NOT THE ISSUE.
00:48:49THAT'S NOT THE ISSUE. THE ISSUE IS THAT BRITAIN NOW
00:48:52THE ISSUE IS THAT BRITAIN NOW POSSESS AND IS WEALTHY BECAUSE POSSESS AND IS WEALTHY BECAUSE OF THE VALUE IT EXTRACTED FROM
00:48:56OF THE VALUE IT EXTRACTED FROM THE CARIBBEAN. THE CARIBBEAN. THE CARIBBEAN IS POOR BECAUSE OF
00:49:00THE CARIBBEAN IS POOR BECAUSE OF THE VALUE THAT WAS TAKEN.
00:49:01THE VALUE THAT WAS TAKEN. THAT'S WITH WE NEED TO ADDRESS.
00:49:05THAT'S WITH WE NEED TO ADDRESS. THE ANALOGY IS NOT MY THE ANALOGY IS NOT MY GRANDFATHER MIGHT HAVE BEEN A
00:49:09GRANDFATHER MIGHT HAVE BEEN A BIG NAZI, NO ONE SAYING I SHOULD BIG NAZI, NO ONE SAYING I SHOULD BE HELD RESPONSIBLE.
00:49:12BE HELD RESPONSIBLE. IF I HAVE THE PICTURES OF THAT
00:49:14IF I HAVE THE PICTURES OF THAT NAZI GENERAL TOOK OFF JEWISH NAZI GENERAL TOOK OFF JEWISH REFUGEES, I NOW HAVE THOSE
00:49:18REFUGEES, I NOW HAVE THOSE PICTURES I SHOULD RETURN THEM.
00:49:19PICTURES I SHOULD RETURN THEM. NO ONE SAYING SHOULD SAYING TAKE
00:49:23NO ONE SAYING SHOULD SAYING TAKE RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE CRIME. RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE CRIME. WE ARE IN POSSESSION OF GOOD AND
00:49:27WE ARE IN POSSESSION OF GOOD AND FINANCIAL BENEFITS THAT BELONG FINANCIAL BENEFITS THAT BELONG TO THE CARIBBEAN.
00:49:29TO THE CARIBBEAN. >> Marianne: WHAT DO YOU THINK >> Marianne: WHAT DO YOU THINK IS THE RIGHT RESOLUTION HERE?
00:49:32IS THE RIGHT RESOLUTION HERE? THERE ARE PEOPLE THERE IN GUYANA THERE ARE PEOPLE THERE IN GUYANA WELCOMING THE KING SAYING THEY
00:49:35WELCOMING THE KING SAYING THEY DON'T WANT AN APOLOGY. DON'T WANT AN APOLOGY. THEY WANT THOSE REPARATIONS.
00:49:39THEY WANT THOSE REPARATIONS. HOW IMPORTANT IS THAT?
00:49:40HOW IMPORTANT IS THAT? >> LET'S HAVE THAT CONVERSATION.
00:49:43>> LET'S HAVE THAT CONVERSATION. WE NEED TO BEHAVE LIKE GROWNUPS.
00:49:46WE NEED TO BEHAVE LIKE GROWNUPS. THEY HAVEN'T BEHAVED FOR A LONG
00:49:50THEY HAVEN'T BEHAVED FOR A LONG HIGHLY. HIGHLY. LET'S TALK ABOUT APOLOGY AND LET'S TALK ABOUT APOLOGY AND LET'S TALK ABOUT WHAT A
00:49:53LET'S TALK ABOUT WHAT A REPARATION LOOK LIKE. REPARATION LOOK LIKE. >> Marianne: IT IS SUCH A DEEP >> Marianne: IT IS SUCH A DEEP ISSUE.
00:49:57ISSUE. WE CAN TALK ABOUT THIS FOR SO WE CAN TALK ABOUT THIS FOR SO MUCH LONGER.
00:49:59MUCH LONGER. BECAUSE OF THE HISTORY AND THE
00:50:02PAIN AND THE GENERATIONAL PAIN THAT FAMILIES HAVE BEEN DEALING THAT FAMILIES HAVE BEEN DEALING WITH AND LOOKING AT THEIR OWN
00:50:05WITH AND LOOKING AT THEIR OWN HISTORY AND LOOKING AT THE HISTORY AND LOOKING AT THE SITUATION NOW AS YOU SAY BETWEEN
00:50:08SITUATION NOW AS YOU SAY BETWEEN THE COMMONWEALTH COUNTRIES AND THE COMMONWEALTH COUNTRIES AND THE SITUATION FINANCIALLY AND SO
00:50:11THE SITUATION FINANCIALLY AND SO MANY CARIBBEAN NATIONS. MANY CARIBBEAN NATIONS. WHAT DO YOU THINK WILL BE
00:50:14WHAT DO YOU THINK WILL BE SATISFACTORY FOR THOSE WATCHING
00:50:16SATISFACTORY FOR THOSE WATCHING THE KINGSBURY'S SP -- KING'S SPH
00:50:20THE KINGSBURY'S SP -- KING'S SPH ON TUESDAY?
00:50:21ON TUESDAY? >> I DOUBT HE'LL GO FAR ENOUGH.
00:50:24>> I DOUBT HE'LL GO FAR ENOUGH. KINGS DO WHAT THEY ARE TOLD IN KINGS DO WHAT THEY ARE TOLD IN BRITAIN.
00:50:27BRITAIN. HE WON'T BE ABLE TO GO FURTHER.
00:50:30HE WON'T BE ABLE TO GO FURTHER. HE'S REFLECTIVE MAN.
00:50:35HE'S REFLECTIVE MAN. HE'S A THOUGHTFUL MAN. HE'S A THOUGHTFUL MAN. I THINK HE WILL REALISE THAT THE
00:50:39I THINK HE WILL REALISE THAT THE PRESENT POSITION IS NOT A STABLE PRESENT POSITION IS NOT A STABLE PLACE TO BE.
00:50:43PLACE TO BE. ONCE WE ADMITTED THIS WAS ONCE WE ADMITTED THIS WAS TERRIBLE CRIME, A CRIME WHICH
00:50:46TERRIBLE CRIME, A CRIME WHICH EXTRACTED VALUE FROM THE EXTRACTED VALUE FROM THE CARIBBEAN WHICH ENDED UP IN
00:50:50CARIBBEAN WHICH ENDED UP IN BRITAIN. BRITAIN. THEN THE LOGIC, OVERWHELMING
00:50:53THEN THE LOGIC, OVERWHELMING LOGIC IS WE'VE GOT TO FIND A WAY
00:50:55LOGIC IS WE'VE GOT TO FIND A WAY OF MAKING A GOOD FINANCIALLY.
00:51:01OF MAKING A GOOD FINANCIALLY. >> Marianne: MICHAEL CHARLES >> Marianne: MICHAEL CHARLES BANNER,
01:00:23[Mark] On this edition of The Fifth Estate,
01:00:25two boys lured into danger.
01:00:28[Jacqueline] It's like, where the heck is he?
01:00:30You can't just vanish off the face of the earth like that.
01:00:34[Christene] A parent cannot sleep, they cannot function,
01:00:36and they're trying to hide that fear of,
01:00:39is my child dead or alive?
01:00:40Be prepared to stop, security checkpoint.
01:00:44We're in Pelican Narrows in North Saskatchewan,
01:00:47following the trail of a boy from Brampton, Ontario,
01:00:50who was brought some 3,000 kilometres and then disappeared.
01:00:54I told him, "Get away from here. These are not good people."
Data courtesy of The GDELT Project (gdeltproject.org), from the Internet Archive TV News Archive. Film strip and transcript are GDELT's, rehosted here under their terms of use, which permit it with this citation.