Estonia: ERR

20260920 03:00 UTC · 00:30:58 · 542 transcript segments · GDELT Visual Explorer · plain-text transcript · Event Map

Film strip

One frame every 4 seconds, 465 in all. Click a frame to jump the transcript to that moment, or click a line of the transcript to see what was on screen while it was said. Served from apprised.news, so it loads behind proxies that block Google Cloud Storage.

00:00:00
00:00:04
00:00:08
00:00:12
00:00:16
00:00:20
00:00:24
00:00:28
00:00:32
00:00:36
00:00:40
00:00:44
00:00:48
00:00:52
00:00:56
00:01:00
00:01:04
00:01:08
00:01:12
00:01:16
00:01:20
00:01:24
00:01:28
00:01:32
00:01:36
00:01:40
00:01:44
00:01:48
00:01:52
00:01:56
00:02:00
00:02:04
00:02:08
00:02:12
00:02:16
00:02:20
00:02:24
00:02:28
00:02:32
00:02:36
00:02:40
00:02:44
00:02:48
00:02:52
00:02:56
00:03:00
00:03:04
00:03:08
00:03:12
00:03:16
00:03:20
00:03:24
00:03:28
00:03:32
00:03:36
00:03:40
00:03:44
00:03:48
00:03:52
00:03:56
00:04:00
00:04:04
00:04:08
00:04:12
00:04:16
00:04:20
00:04:24
00:04:28
00:04:32
00:04:36
00:04:40
00:04:44
00:04:48
00:04:52
00:04:56
00:05:00
00:05:04
00:05:08
00:05:12
00:05:16
00:05:20
00:05:24
00:05:28
00:05:32
00:05:36
00:05:40
00:05:44
00:05:48
00:05:52
00:05:56
00:06:00
00:06:04
00:06:08
00:06:12
00:06:16
00:06:20
00:06:24
00:06:28
00:06:32
00:06:36
00:06:40
00:06:44
00:06:48
00:06:52
00:06:56
00:07:00
00:07:04
00:07:08
00:07:12
00:07:16
00:07:20
00:07:24
00:07:28
00:07:32
00:07:36
00:07:40
00:07:44
00:07:48
00:07:52
00:07:56
00:08:00
00:08:04
00:08:08
00:08:12
00:08:16
00:08:20
00:08:24
00:08:28
00:08:32
00:08:36
00:08:40
00:08:44
00:08:48
00:08:52
00:08:56
00:09:00
00:09:04
00:09:08
00:09:12
00:09:16
00:09:20
00:09:24
00:09:28
00:09:32
00:09:36
00:09:40
00:09:44
00:09:48
00:09:52
00:09:56
00:10:00
00:10:04
00:10:08
00:10:12
00:10:16
00:10:20
00:10:24
00:10:28
00:10:32
00:10:36
00:10:40
00:10:44
00:10:48
00:10:52
00:10:56
00:11:00
00:11:04
00:11:08
00:11:12
00:11:16
00:11:20
00:11:24
00:11:28
00:11:32
00:11:36
00:11:40
00:11:44
00:11:48
00:11:52
00:11:56
00:12:00
00:12:04
00:12:08
00:12:12
00:12:16
00:12:20
00:12:24
00:12:28
00:12:32
00:12:36
00:12:40
00:12:44
00:12:48
00:12:52
00:12:56
00:13:00
00:13:04
00:13:08
00:13:12
00:13:16
00:13:20
00:13:24
00:13:28
00:13:32
00:13:36
00:13:40
00:13:44
00:13:48
00:13:52
00:13:56
00:14:00
00:14:04
00:14:08
00:14:12
00:14:16
00:14:20
00:14:24
00:14:28
00:14:32
00:14:36
00:14:40
00:14:44
00:14:48
00:14:52
00:14:56
00:15:00
00:15:04
00:15:08
00:15:12
00:15:16
00:15:20
00:15:24
00:15:28
00:15:32
00:15:36
00:15:40
00:15:44
00:15:48
00:15:52
00:15:56
00:16:00
00:16:04
00:16:08
00:16:12
00:16:16
00:16:20
00:16:24
00:16:28
00:16:32
00:16:36
00:16:40
00:16:44
00:16:48
00:16:52
00:16:56
00:17:00
00:17:04
00:17:08
00:17:12
00:17:16
00:17:20
00:17:24
00:17:28
00:17:32
00:17:36
00:17:40
00:17:44
00:17:48
00:17:52
00:17:56
00:18:00
00:18:04
00:18:08
00:18:12
00:18:16
00:18:20
00:18:24
00:18:28
00:18:32
00:18:36
00:18:40
00:18:44
00:18:48
00:18:52
00:18:56
00:19:00
00:19:04
00:19:08
00:19:12
00:19:16
00:19:20
00:19:24
00:19:28
00:19:32
00:19:36
00:19:40
00:19:44
00:19:48
00:19:52
00:19:56
00:20:00
00:20:04
00:20:08
00:20:12
00:20:16
00:20:20
00:20:24
00:20:28
00:20:32
00:20:36
00:20:40
00:20:44
00:20:48
00:20:52
00:20:56
00:21:00
00:21:04
00:21:08
00:21:12
00:21:16
00:21:20
00:21:24
00:21:28
00:21:32
00:21:36
00:21:40
00:21:44
00:21:48
00:21:52
00:21:56
00:22:00
00:22:04
00:22:08
00:22:12
00:22:16
00:22:20
00:22:24
00:22:28
00:22:32
00:22:36
00:22:40
00:22:44
00:22:48
00:22:52
00:22:56
00:23:00
00:23:04
00:23:08
00:23:12
00:23:16
00:23:20
00:23:24
00:23:28
00:23:32
00:23:36
00:23:40
00:23:44
00:23:48
00:23:52
00:23:56
00:24:00
00:24:04
00:24:08
00:24:12
00:24:16
00:24:20
00:24:24
00:24:28
00:24:32
00:24:36
00:24:40
00:24:44
00:24:48
00:24:52
00:24:56
00:25:00
00:25:04
00:25:08
00:25:12
00:25:16
00:25:20
00:25:24
00:25:28
00:25:32
00:25:36
00:25:40
00:25:44
00:25:48
00:25:52
00:25:56
00:26:00
00:26:04
00:26:08
00:26:12
00:26:16
00:26:20
00:26:24
00:26:28
00:26:32
00:26:36
00:26:40
00:26:44
00:26:48
00:26:52
00:26:56
00:27:00
00:27:04
00:27:08
00:27:12
00:27:16
00:27:20
00:27:24
00:27:28
00:27:32
00:27:36
00:27:40
00:27:44
00:27:48
00:27:52
00:27:56
00:28:00
00:28:04
00:28:08
00:28:12
00:28:16
00:28:20
00:28:24
00:28:28
00:28:32
00:28:36
00:28:40
00:28:44
00:28:48
00:28:52
00:28:56
00:29:00
00:29:04
00:29:08
00:29:12
00:29:16
00:29:20
00:29:24
00:29:28
00:29:32
00:29:36
00:29:40
00:29:44
00:29:48
00:29:52
00:29:56
00:30:00
00:30:04
00:30:08
00:30:12
00:30:16
00:30:20
00:30:24
00:30:28
00:30:32
00:30:36
00:30:40
00:30:44
00:30:48
00:30:52
00:30:56

Transcript

Google Cloud Speech-to-Text API (Chirp) + Gemini 2.5 Flash Non-Thinking. Treat it as a searchable index of what was broadcast, not a quotation record.

00:00:43writer seems to have one
00:00:45goal: to make us uncomfortable.
00:00:48To make us want to contradict him at all costs, because
00:00:50Tekitada meis soovi igal juhul talle vastu vaielda, sest et
00:00:54he offers a different perspective on what is happening
00:00:56or has already happened in Estonia.
00:01:00He offers a perspective that has either not been discussed before
00:01:03for one reason or another, or that we
00:01:14books was published in the Estonian
00:01:17forces, I Thought series under the title Labyrinth in the bottom left corner. Editor Katri Liik has
00:01:21said about you that you are fiery,
00:01:25sharp, and you even invite
00:01:28attacks. "Is it your goal
00:01:31to invite attacks or
00:01:35why do you, as a historian, bring out such
00:01:39aspects from the past of Estonians that
00:01:42we prefer to
00:01:43forget? Yes,
00:01:46as an addition, as an addition,
00:01:50I would try to be grammatically correct and
00:01:52precise, to what was just heard,
00:01:55that just now in Kadriorg we had another literary
00:01:59event and then
00:02:02a quite well-known person and publisher, who was
00:02:06conversing with Toomas Kall and Taavid Sevijov,
00:02:08reacted
00:02:11to me, seeing me pass by, "Look, the wasp has arrived."
00:02:14So, in that
00:02:17sense, what you are saying now
00:02:20seems to be a broader
00:02:24attitude or observation about me, and it doesn't
00:02:27make me particularly happy, of course.
00:02:30When I was younger, it seemed
00:02:34to me that this might be my
00:02:36function, and at that time, I even
00:02:40occasionally said, very confidently,
00:02:44that I fulfill the role of a mirror, reflecting Estonian
00:02:47custom space with all its
00:02:50shortcomings, with all the defects
00:02:54that are found here. But now that I am older
00:02:58and calmer, I am no longer particularly happy when I am told that a wasp
00:03:02has arrived. But
00:03:05in my time, I did it. I thought that
00:03:08after graduating from the University of Tartu's history department, that
00:03:11it could be one of my functions or
00:03:14purposes,
00:03:16meanings in Estonian society. Well, but it
00:03:20was for a very long time,
00:03:22wasn't it? You did it intentionally, you had that goal,
00:03:25right?
00:03:27No, the goal was not to make anyone angry or irritated.
00:03:31The goal was to create a discussion.
00:03:34But I admit now in hindsight that it didn't particularly
00:03:38succeed, because you don't discuss
00:03:41with a wasp, you repel it, you
00:03:45try to swat it with a rolled-up
00:03:48newspaper. I must remind the listener that,
00:03:51first and foremost, the bloody battles of Sinimäe or the
00:03:55April 2007 riots, but also Andrei
00:03:58Fostov's further
00:04:02delving into Estonian history, these are still topics to which
00:04:05the Estonian public reacted very, very painfully.
00:04:08What
00:04:11purpose do such historical interpretations that
00:04:15are uncomfortable for us to read
00:04:18serve? Is this the purpose of being
00:04:21a mirror?
00:04:24Well, I believe and am still
00:04:27of the opinion that
00:04:30the feeling of annoying
00:04:33oneself, this has not only a deep philosophical meaning, but
00:04:36also a psychotherapeutic one,
00:04:40that if you learn to look
00:04:42at yourself as you really
00:04:45are and not as you would like
00:04:49to be, then this could have not only
00:04:52a healing effect, but also a progressive effect. We
00:04:56learn from mistakes. If we admit that something in our history
00:05:01went wrong and askew, instead of dismissing it or
00:05:04on the contrary, praising it,
00:05:07then there is a danger
00:05:10that mistakes will be repeated, that we will step on the same rake again.
00:05:13Well, this teaching word that
00:05:17was heard during the Singing Revolution, that one must always
00:05:21learn from history and
00:05:23history is what teaches us to be and to live, and then
00:05:27in contrast to that, it is said that the only thing history teaches is that history is not
00:05:31learned from. Now the latter seems to be true, but it's
00:05:35hard to accept. I would still like it to go
00:05:38according to that first saying, that whoever remembers the past
00:05:42has no future. But as a historian, a professional
00:05:46historian, do you believe that every new
00:05:49generation that grows up
00:05:53doesn't remember or doesn't want to remember the mistakes of the previous one, and everything
00:05:56repeats itself?
00:05:59It seems so. Well, let's say on an individual
00:06:02level, this is very clearly
00:06:04observable. When representatives of the older
00:06:07generation try to teach younger people or tell
00:06:11them not to make that mistake, it has usually never yielded
00:06:15results, because making mistakes, making personal mistakes,
00:06:18seems to be part of human rights.
00:06:22No young person has ever been grateful for being
00:06:26prevented from making mistakes. We learn
00:06:28from mistakes, well, and then it probably
00:06:31is so. But as for the perception of history,
00:06:35or well, that's also a well-known
00:06:38saying that every generation writes its own history, and
00:06:42it really changes with generations. The historical concepts change,
00:06:46and the past is re-evaluated once
00:06:48again. And that is, of course, an exciting process, and in my time, I
00:06:52also tried to participate in it. Do you
00:06:55mean that Estonians understand their history one-sidedly,
00:06:58that is, as we want to see ourselves in the mirror
00:07:02or as we want to remember
00:07:04our past? Mm, oh yes, definitely, but this is not
00:07:08at all unique to Estonians, all
00:07:11nations do it. There's a huge beautification and
00:07:14sugar-coating and
00:07:16forgetting of certain
00:07:18uncomfortable episodes and situations. For example, what immediately
00:07:22comes to mind now is that when we had the Republic of Estonia 100, well, we
00:07:26remember that 2018, and before that,
00:07:30slowly moving towards that anniversary, then the
00:07:33100th anniversary of the Estonian War of Independence was also commemorated, and then, well, we even
00:07:37had a cool armored train traveling around Estonia, and then
00:07:40all those important battles and everything
00:07:43were remembered. Do you remember an event that was not celebrated,
00:07:47whose 100th anniversary passed?
00:07:51The Saaremaa uprising, when the men of Saaremaa refused to obey the mainlanders and
00:07:54go to the War of Independence. It was not mentioned at all.
00:07:57Well, that's just one example of how some unpleasant
00:08:01things that happened in the past, well, we try
00:08:04to forget them.
00:08:06And then you are the one who brings out from our history
00:08:10those things that we try to forget.
00:08:12That's what drives you as a historian.
00:08:14Not only as a historian, but also as
00:08:18a writer,
00:08:22because, well, let's admit that if
00:08:25there are taboo subjects, then poking at them is indeed interesting,
00:08:29intellectually interesting, because why repeat
00:08:32and circle around what everyone already knows and what
00:08:36hundreds of mouths and voices repeat? One always wants to go
00:08:39to a somewhat dangerous area. "Where do you
00:08:42find this material? How much do you visit
00:08:45archives? No, you don't even have to visit archives,
00:08:49you just have to remember your own
00:08:52studies at the University of Tartu and
00:08:55what was said, what was hinted at,
00:08:59what was not said at all. Of course, as a student back then, I didn't
00:09:02understand all of it, and I still don't understand
00:09:05everything. Well, in that sense, I don't master all
00:09:08the facts, but I
00:09:11did notice a few things, and that's where I started poking around. I actually started with
00:09:15it already in my second
00:09:17year, in my second-year course paper,
00:09:20where I wrote my
00:09:23essay on the theme of ancient freedom struggles.
00:09:26My supervisor was Sulev Vahtre. I received
00:09:29the highest grade for it, and
00:09:33there I argued against the official
00:09:37interpretation of the ancient freedom struggle. Incidentally,
00:09:40later that course paper became the book "Mõtteline
00:09:43Eesti" (Conceptual Estonia), so this first part, which talks about
00:09:47those ancient times, is based on that student
00:09:50work from back then. And there I
00:09:53took, I took up a study
00:09:57by a German historian, Friedrich Benninghofen, on the
00:10:00Order of the Livonian Brothers of the Sword. As far as I know, it has not
00:10:03been translated into Estonian yet, and it was diametrically
00:10:06opposite to what I was taught
00:10:09in my history courses,
00:10:13both in primary school and later at university. Everything
00:10:17was completely different there, and I emphasize that Vening Hofen
00:10:21is not at all among the Baltic Germans, because well, Baltic
00:10:25Germans, Balts, could be suspected of being spiteful and
00:10:28against us, but Beningghof is a completely imperial German
00:10:32and extremely objective and impartial
00:10:35in my opinion, and that's where I got some of
00:10:39those ideas. This Beninhoffen did not justify
00:10:42the activities of the Teutonic Order
00:10:44in the Baltics.
00:10:47No, certainly not, but his urgent recommendation was to
00:10:50look at things in the context of their time,
00:10:53and the context of the time was such
00:10:57that the crusaders, when they came here, well,
00:11:00we remember from our past studies that we were told that
00:11:04they came here to plunder, to rob, to
00:11:07conquer lands, but in the 13th century context, they
00:11:11came to save us, or the people who were here, to save them. From
00:11:14what? From paganism,
00:11:17from the eastern neighbor, from pagan, no, from pagan perdition, from the fact that, well,
00:11:21pagans are all eventually destined for eternal torment in hell.
00:11:25First of all, and secondly, at that time, when I was dealing with this matter,
00:11:29a very modern motif emerged from it, that
00:11:33we all know the glorious story
00:11:36of the Eastern Vikings, that the people of Saaremaa and Courland, that they were once the rulers
00:11:40of the Baltic Sea, they even burned down Sigtuna,
00:11:43this is spoken of quite proudly.
00:11:47Also in the pre-war republic,
00:11:51one of the favorite motifs was the image of a Viking ship, wasn't it?
00:11:54On the two-crown or one-crown coin, there was Toompea somewhere and
00:11:58somewhere there was that Viking ship.
00:12:01Well, young Estonia used the Viking ship motif, well, that's something
00:12:04proud and powerful.
00:12:07If we look from the Scandinavian side, they were the victims of those attacks. That was
00:12:11pure piracy. That was, in modern terms,
00:12:14international terrorism, and it had to be dealt with in exactly the same way as
00:12:18the Americans, when they invaded
00:12:21Iraq, or how they are dealing now with the Yemeni Houthis.
00:12:25Or or with the Iranians,
00:12:27then the justification for such
00:12:31military intervention is the securing of trade
00:12:34routes, international peace, the suppression of international
00:12:37terrorism wherever it arises. So, at the beginning of the 13th century, when
00:12:41this invasion of Western Christians
00:12:44here began, why not look at it as one such military
00:12:48operation to suppress international
00:12:50terrorism? It may seem like a somewhat unexpected
00:12:54idea. "Very unexpected, but those Danish-Swedish territories that fell victim to these
00:12:58Eastern Viking raids, I think
00:13:01they saw it exactly that way and thanked
00:13:05the Lord in church that finally someone had started dealing
00:13:08with this problem. The wheel of war turned, he who
00:13:11was once a plunderer and terrorist, later became
00:13:15a victim and a slave. I
00:13:17now emphasize that everything I just said is
00:13:21very anachronistic, that the word "terrorist" certainly doesn't fit into the realities
00:13:25of the 13th century, but I just used
00:13:29that wording to give
00:13:32today's listener, reader,
00:13:36some points of reference to grasp onto.
00:13:40Valdur Mikita has described that
00:13:43the ecosystem at the border of field and forest
00:13:47is the most species-rich. Species from the forest,
00:13:51plant and animal species,
00:13:54mix there, and vice versa. It is also claimed that
00:13:58for example, when the DNA of people mixes with traces
00:14:01of many nationalities, then it is a person who is
00:14:05intellectually capable and talented in many
00:14:08fields. You are also on the border. How
00:14:11do you currently feel
00:14:13about being on the border?
00:14:15Mm
00:14:18Well, first of all, I know that
00:14:21the border areas between the forest and the open land are the most biodiverse, and
00:14:25I know that even without Valdur Mikita, because when I was studying
00:14:29beekeeping at the time, those areas
00:14:32are indeed the most magnificent, the most
00:14:35suitable for bees.
00:14:37Talking like this now, I took a moment to think.
00:14:41Yes, I'm on the edge, even just by the fact that I come from Ida-Virumaa, which is such
00:14:45a border area. I'm from a mixed
00:14:48family, and here we are dealing with,
00:14:52I emphasize, such a family
00:14:55composition that is very
00:14:58contrasting.
00:15:00If one of my parents were Estonian, the other Latvian, one
00:15:04parent Estonian, the other Finnish, then it wouldn't create such
00:15:07a big contrast as having one parent Estonian,
00:15:10the other Russian. I even once
00:15:13made a table of the contradictions
00:15:16this creates. There were six
00:15:20levels where there is a diametrical contradiction.
00:15:23I don't know, we probably don't need to list them now, but
00:15:27a few examples could be interesting. Well, let's start with
00:15:30the fact that one is a small nation, under
00:15:34a million, which is why we have,
00:15:38for at least a century, at least a century,
00:15:42had this existential fear that at least Estonian intellectual
00:15:45demographers express, that, well, we are in danger
00:15:48of extinction. And Russians, let's say,
00:15:51are 150 million, and although the demographic situation there is also very
00:15:54bad, but as a large nation, they have never
00:15:57felt that existential fear of
00:16:01extinction, so it is not a topic
00:16:05for them at all. Estonia is a small
00:16:08nation-state with a mentality derived from that, and
00:16:11Russia is a large empire, with a mentality
00:16:13derived from that.
00:16:16Estonia has been part of the West for actually
00:16:20all these seven or eight centuries, that is the
00:16:23legacy of the crusaders, they integrated us into the West
00:16:27with very painful methods, and 50 years of Soviet
00:16:30occupation did not change that situation. Incidentally, this is the main
00:16:34motif of "Conceptual Estonia," my first book.
00:16:38And Russia is an Eastern,
00:16:41I don't know, Mongolian-Tatar Eastern type. There are
00:16:44many such contradictions and diametrical contradictions, and
00:16:48in my own family, in everyday life, these
00:16:51manifested, so that while I was between these two
00:16:55drew from one side and drew from the other
00:16:58side, and I kept thinking and thinking and thinking, what is all
00:17:02this that is happening around me? Such a borderline state
00:17:06undoubtedly gives broader
00:17:09opportunities to perceive the world, and on the other hand, perhaps this
00:17:12borderline state also sets its own limits on how
00:17:16to perceive the world. What thoughts does this statement
00:17:20evoke in you?
00:17:25This is such a broad topic,
00:17:27philosophical.
00:17:29When I once
00:17:33corrected, let's put
00:17:35it this way, the "Estonian custom space"
00:17:38invented by President Kersti Kaljulaid, do you remember
00:17:41when it was first mentioned? It was
00:17:44when there was the great migration crisis in Europe
00:17:48and understandably, the Estonian president then expressed
00:17:52an idea or brought up a certain prerequisite,
00:17:55on the basis of which we could then receive
00:17:58at that time, there was talk of alleged or soon-to-be-arriving
00:18:02masses of refugees from somewhere in the Middle East, that we can only accept
00:18:06those people who somehow conform to the Estonian
00:18:09custom space, and she used, in my opinion,
00:18:12in four of her important speeches, I
00:18:16think over two years, this concept
00:18:19of "custom space," never specifying what
00:18:22it is. And then my correction was that, yes,
00:18:26very nice, but please now bring out the
00:18:28criteria that a person must meet in order
00:18:32to fit into the Estonian custom space. Please define
00:18:35this custom space. At that time, I also had
00:18:39some accounts on social media, I had several thousand followers on Facebook, or
00:18:42no, they were called friends on Facebook. Then
00:18:46I received a lot of criticism from there, that
00:18:49a true Estonian doesn't need a definition, a true Estonian already knows what
00:18:53custom space is. But here are some, I don't know, some
00:18:56not quite true Estonians, but those who are
00:19:00foreigners like Fostof, well, they must be
00:19:03explained. So
00:19:07the main content
00:19:09of my
00:19:12argument is that, let's leave aside those refugees from the Middle East or North Africa,
00:19:15someone from America comes to Estonia and says, "Very
00:19:19good, I want to be Estonian, I want to fit into this
00:19:23cultural space." But now tell me, what should
00:19:26I do with my mentality, what criteria should
00:19:30I meet? And what will we then
00:19:32tell him? That, you know, it's
00:19:35undefinable, it's a sort of internal
00:19:38feeling, you just suck it in with your mother's
00:19:41milk and you know, we can't explain it to you,
00:19:45it's so unexplainable.
00:19:48Such an explanation doesn't satisfy me. And
00:19:51this fuss around the custom space really lasted quite a long time, I remember
00:19:54it took two years before a relevant article appeared
00:19:58in the Estonian Wikipedia, the content of which doesn't really
00:20:02satisfy me.
00:20:05But well, let's talk about literature, since
00:20:08I am a literary person, no one would deny that "Truth and Justice" is a very
00:20:12important text for understanding
00:20:16the Estonian mindset.
00:20:18Let's take "Truth and Justice", the first part, and let's take violence
00:20:22against women, it's a very painful topic.
00:20:25Years ago there was a terrible incident when a refugee from Syria, I think a man,
00:20:29poured gasoline over his wife, set
00:20:33her on fire, because in his opinion the woman had behaved incorrectly,
00:20:37violating ancient rules and laws, exactly this
00:20:41woman. But, well, this act is clearly not compatible with the Estonian
00:20:44custom space, it's completely at odds with it. But now
00:20:48let's take "Truth and Justice". Let's take violence
00:20:51against women. Farmer Andres Andres
00:20:53Paas, he generally doesn't beat his wives, well, it's true,
00:20:57he works Krõõt to death, but he beats Mari once, when
00:21:00Mari can't get over Juss's suicide, when Juss starts
00:21:04haunting her, then Andres beats
00:21:07her and also cuts down the tree on which Juss
00:21:11hanged himself. Sauna Madis doesn't
00:21:13beat his sauna aunt, but he threatens her very seriously once when
00:21:17the sauna aunt spreads rumors in the village and talks
00:21:21all sorts of ugly things about the master Andres and his wife.
00:21:25Madis threatens to beat her so much that she is beaten. And then there is
00:21:29Oru Pearu, who constantly beats his wife, who unfortunately
00:21:32remains anonymous, she is consistently called a "sheep whore".
00:21:35She constantly gets beaten. Now the big question is, which
00:21:39of these three men represents the Estonian
00:21:41custom space?
00:21:45Very difficult to answer, isn't it? I have never
00:21:48asked myself this question. Well, a person on the borderline does ask such
00:21:51questions, and if we now become
00:21:55very, I don't know, disgusting and cynical, I am now being very
00:21:58ironic, then probably to that Syrian who will
00:22:02one day come to Estonia seeking asylum, if he asks how he should
00:22:06behave, then we will say, based
00:22:09on an incident in Rakvere, where a
00:22:12person whom Ekre once wanted to get as a
00:22:15minister, came under great suspicion
00:22:19because his wife had injuries, the mechanism of which
00:22:22or the mechanism of their formation
00:22:25was unclear, so the Estonian custom space is such that you beat women,
00:22:29you beat them quietly, and if asked, do you beat them? You deny it. Is that
00:22:32the Estonian
00:22:34custom space? Practice shows that it probably
00:22:37is. It happens regrettably often,
00:22:41yes, and if I say that now, well, thank God, Facebook is
00:22:44long gone, but I can imagine the hail of abuse
00:22:48I would receive right now. That no, it's not
00:22:51like that.
00:22:54It still infuriates me sometimes, this sugar-coating
00:22:57of reality or this Estonianness, that we are something different from what we actually
00:23:01are.
00:23:04We may yet talk about some articles that have caused
00:23:08very strong and lasting
00:23:12objections in society, to which you have been able to respond in turn, but
00:23:16I am currently stuck on your article that appeared in July.
00:23:20It was titled, "What is punishment literature?"
00:23:24So my question related to the previous one is, when you
00:23:28show Estonians in the mirror
00:23:31their uncomfortable moments of customs,
00:23:35character, or history, is this
00:23:37punishment literature?
00:23:42Is it something with which you not only
00:23:45express your personal opinion,
00:23:48but also that we, who
00:23:51read, should feel
00:23:54punished? I am now in a situation where
00:23:57we are sitting in the studio right now. Actually, I
00:24:01should be lying on a couch and a psychologist should be
00:24:03talking to me. Now I should start
00:24:07digging deeply into myself.
00:24:11Because from this question, it is clear that is it like this, that I, as this
00:24:14borderline person, who has heard one thing, another, and
00:24:18a third, perhaps I now somehow want to take revenge on the Estonian
00:24:21people or on this custom space
00:24:24where I live? Your answer
00:24:26interests me.
00:24:35Still no.
00:24:37No,
00:24:42I still come back to the thought that if we talk about unpleasant
00:24:45things, then
00:24:49there is hope that we will learn
00:24:52from something, starting to be ashamed of it or, if not
00:24:56ashamed, then thinking that this is not rational behavior, let's rather not.
00:25:00do it in such a way that right now, to extricate ourselves from this difficult situation, this difficult
00:25:03question, I recall what is happening
00:25:07in the Middle East, since I mainly write in Eesti Ekspress
00:25:10about foreign policy events,
00:25:14then ee in this Arab-Israeli
00:25:17conflict, I have
00:25:20registered over the years, and experts have also said,
00:25:23that what distinguishes Israelis, or
00:25:26Jews, from Arabs is that Israelis learn from their
00:25:30mistakes. If they have suffered a defeat in some military
00:25:33campaign, like during the war in
00:25:361973, then they learn from these
00:25:39mistakes. Arabs, who always instill in themselves
00:25:42some kind of ee
00:25:45victory, the same Yom Kippur War, for example, that
00:25:49it surprised me that in Egypt, the anniversary
00:25:52is always celebrated as a great Egyptian victory, although they did not
00:25:55win, they were defeated in that war in the end. So
00:25:59Arabs, who are not able to admit their mistakes at all... to say that
00:26:02they have been defeated somewhere, then they also don't learn from it. And we see this every
00:26:06single time when another conflict flares up there, that
00:26:10Arabs do not learn from their mistakes because the
00:26:13mirror they hold up shows some kind of
00:26:17well, a very wise, very heroic,
00:26:20very, very close to God person
00:26:23apparently, who is then flawless,
00:26:25infallible. If we don't learn from our mistakes, then it
00:26:29can have very disastrous consequences." If you
00:26:33write in Eesti Ekspress about the
00:26:36clashes between Jews and Palestinians,
00:26:39what kind of feedback do you
00:26:41get?
00:26:44Well, I would even phrase it this way, that
00:26:46many younger generation intellectuals, who were once
00:26:50on friendly terms with me, are no longer so, because
00:26:54there is still a predominantly pro-Palestinian
00:26:56stance. I would even say that
00:27:00there's a small parallel now with the Ukrainian war, which
00:27:02notoriously, when it started in 2022,
00:27:06then in Russian society, well,
00:27:10they got very, very much at odds with each other.
00:27:13There were typical cases where in one family the children
00:27:17had one opinion and the parents had a completely different opinion, and it could even
00:27:21end with them ceasing to communicate with each other. The Ukrainian
00:27:25war made Russians fall out with each other. I
00:27:28say that what happened with Gaza, made the Estonian
00:27:31intellectual community fall out with each other. I wouldn't say that the entire Estonian nation is
00:27:35now divided, but the Estonian intellectual community certainly is, and I perceive that
00:27:38very clearly. So, the fact that I started
00:27:42writing about this and took a very firm stance, I simply created
00:27:45more adversaries
00:27:49for myself, maybe even enemies. But I
00:27:52say that this is not the first time, I have had many such
00:27:56moments in life, starting from the conceptual Estonia, after its
00:27:59publication, the national wing,
00:28:02the conservative wing suddenly discovered that maybe I am a Moscow
00:28:06henchman, maybe I am this or that, because I want to rob the Estonian
00:28:09people of their Estonian history and show everything
00:28:13somehow in a light favorable to the Russian Empire,
00:28:17well, roughly such
00:28:20suspicions existed. And now, with the
00:28:24aftershocks of the Gaza conflict, mentally, now
00:28:27it suddenly turns out, how should I
00:28:30say this? Well, in this left-wing modern
00:28:34discourse, the prevailing definition, I
00:28:37am a white, half-dead man, who
00:28:40patronizes and does something else like that, in short, I unexpectedly found myself
00:28:44in the same company where once in the early 90s I
00:28:47thought those were
00:28:50the conservative nationalists who despised my view
00:28:53of history. I thought I was completely different from them, but now a
00:28:57new generation came and today it's completely different, I'm exactly in the same
00:29:00company. Mm
00:29:02paradox, your most
00:29:06recognized work, Sillamäe Passion, has
00:29:10received the Cultural Endowment of Estonia annual prize, the Virumaa prize, many other
00:29:13prizes, it has also been translated into Russian.
00:29:16Yes, and one of my university classmates,
00:29:20who is now quite a well-known ethnologist, Aimar
00:29:23Ventsel, he did an experiment. He would occasionally
00:29:27give the Russian-language version in Ida-Virumaa to Russian-speaking
00:29:30people to read. And he confirmed, well,
00:29:34let's say, through such an experiment, he confirmed what I already
00:29:38knew, that our Russians hate this book,
00:29:41for the reason, but for the same reason why Estonians hate
00:29:45my text, I write some things there that
00:29:48Russians don't like, which
00:29:51undermines their self-image, puts it in doubt.
00:29:55You are a stranger to
00:29:58strangers and a stranger to your
00:30:01own, right? "I don't even know to whom I really
00:30:04belong, to my closest ones, to my
00:30:07closest, to my family, to them I am probably
00:30:10my own. Let's move in time to April
00:30:142013, when your article "My
00:30:17Life with Leena" was published. It was a frank
00:30:21article about your home beauty, focused on your
00:30:25wife's bedridden mother, who needed
00:30:27round-the-clock care, a place in a nursing home was not
00:30:31possible.
00:30:33This article received a lot of feedback,
00:30:37a lot of thoughtful consideration, a lot of
00:30:39condemnation. It was again such an
00:30:42inflammatory abscess that you
00:30:45pressed. How do you look at all of that, which was 3 years
00:30:49ago, how do you look at it
00:30:52today?
00:30:56It was a deep trauma that we had..."
Data courtesy of The GDELT Project (gdeltproject.org), from the Internet Archive TV News Archive. Film strip and transcript are GDELT's, rehosted here under their terms of use, which permit it with this citation.