France: France 24

20261102 09:00 UTC · 00:30:57 · 523 transcript segments · GDELT Visual Explorer · plain-text transcript · Event Map

Film strip

One frame every 4 seconds, 465 in all. Click a frame to jump the transcript to that moment, or click a line of the transcript to see what was on screen while it was said. Served from apprised.news, so it loads behind proxies that block Google Cloud Storage.

00:00:00
00:00:04
00:00:08
00:00:12
00:00:16
00:00:20
00:00:24
00:00:28
00:00:32
00:00:36
00:00:40
00:00:44
00:00:48
00:00:52
00:00:56
00:01:00
00:01:04
00:01:08
00:01:12
00:01:16
00:01:20
00:01:24
00:01:28
00:01:32
00:01:36
00:01:40
00:01:44
00:01:48
00:01:52
00:01:56
00:02:00
00:02:04
00:02:08
00:02:12
00:02:16
00:02:20
00:02:24
00:02:28
00:02:32
00:02:36
00:02:40
00:02:44
00:02:48
00:02:52
00:02:56
00:03:00
00:03:04
00:03:08
00:03:12
00:03:16
00:03:20
00:03:24
00:03:28
00:03:32
00:03:36
00:03:40
00:03:44
00:03:48
00:03:52
00:03:56
00:04:00
00:04:04
00:04:08
00:04:12
00:04:16
00:04:20
00:04:24
00:04:28
00:04:32
00:04:36
00:04:40
00:04:44
00:04:48
00:04:52
00:04:56
00:05:00
00:05:04
00:05:08
00:05:12
00:05:16
00:05:20
00:05:24
00:05:28
00:05:32
00:05:36
00:05:40
00:05:44
00:05:48
00:05:52
00:05:56
00:06:00
00:06:04
00:06:08
00:06:12
00:06:16
00:06:20
00:06:24
00:06:28
00:06:32
00:06:36
00:06:40
00:06:44
00:06:48
00:06:52
00:06:56
00:07:00
00:07:04
00:07:08
00:07:12
00:07:16
00:07:20
00:07:24
00:07:28
00:07:32
00:07:36
00:07:40
00:07:44
00:07:48
00:07:52
00:07:56
00:08:00
00:08:04
00:08:08
00:08:12
00:08:16
00:08:20
00:08:24
00:08:28
00:08:32
00:08:36
00:08:40
00:08:44
00:08:48
00:08:52
00:08:56
00:09:00
00:09:04
00:09:08
00:09:12
00:09:16
00:09:20
00:09:24
00:09:28
00:09:32
00:09:36
00:09:40
00:09:44
00:09:48
00:09:52
00:09:56
00:10:00
00:10:04
00:10:08
00:10:12
00:10:16
00:10:20
00:10:24
00:10:28
00:10:32
00:10:36
00:10:40
00:10:44
00:10:48
00:10:52
00:10:56
00:11:00
00:11:04
00:11:08
00:11:12
00:11:16
00:11:20
00:11:24
00:11:28
00:11:32
00:11:36
00:11:40
00:11:44
00:11:48
00:11:52
00:11:56
00:12:00
00:12:04
00:12:08
00:12:12
00:12:16
00:12:20
00:12:24
00:12:28
00:12:32
00:12:36
00:12:40
00:12:44
00:12:48
00:12:52
00:12:56
00:13:00
00:13:04
00:13:08
00:13:12
00:13:16
00:13:20
00:13:24
00:13:28
00:13:32
00:13:36
00:13:40
00:13:44
00:13:48
00:13:52
00:13:56
00:14:00
00:14:04
00:14:08
00:14:12
00:14:16
00:14:20
00:14:24
00:14:28
00:14:32
00:14:36
00:14:40
00:14:44
00:14:48
00:14:52
00:14:56
00:15:00
00:15:04
00:15:08
00:15:12
00:15:16
00:15:20
00:15:24
00:15:28
00:15:32
00:15:36
00:15:40
00:15:44
00:15:48
00:15:52
00:15:56
00:16:00
00:16:04
00:16:08
00:16:12
00:16:16
00:16:20
00:16:24
00:16:28
00:16:32
00:16:36
00:16:40
00:16:44
00:16:48
00:16:52
00:16:56
00:17:00
00:17:04
00:17:08
00:17:12
00:17:16
00:17:20
00:17:24
00:17:28
00:17:32
00:17:36
00:17:40
00:17:44
00:17:48
00:17:52
00:17:56
00:18:00
00:18:04
00:18:08
00:18:12
00:18:16
00:18:20
00:18:24
00:18:28
00:18:32
00:18:36
00:18:40
00:18:44
00:18:48
00:18:52
00:18:56
00:19:00
00:19:04
00:19:08
00:19:12
00:19:16
00:19:20
00:19:24
00:19:28
00:19:32
00:19:36
00:19:40
00:19:44
00:19:48
00:19:52
00:19:56
00:20:00
00:20:04
00:20:08
00:20:12
00:20:16
00:20:20
00:20:24
00:20:28
00:20:32
00:20:36
00:20:40
00:20:44
00:20:48
00:20:52
00:20:56
00:21:00
00:21:04
00:21:08
00:21:12
00:21:16
00:21:20
00:21:24
00:21:28
00:21:32
00:21:36
00:21:40
00:21:44
00:21:48
00:21:52
00:21:56
00:22:00
00:22:04
00:22:08
00:22:12
00:22:16
00:22:20
00:22:24
00:22:28
00:22:32
00:22:36
00:22:40
00:22:44
00:22:48
00:22:52
00:22:56
00:23:00
00:23:04
00:23:08
00:23:12
00:23:16
00:23:20
00:23:24
00:23:28
00:23:32
00:23:36
00:23:40
00:23:44
00:23:48
00:23:52
00:23:56
00:24:00
00:24:04
00:24:08
00:24:12
00:24:16
00:24:20
00:24:24
00:24:28
00:24:32
00:24:36
00:24:40
00:24:44
00:24:48
00:24:52
00:24:56
00:25:00
00:25:04
00:25:08
00:25:12
00:25:16
00:25:20
00:25:24
00:25:28
00:25:32
00:25:36
00:25:40
00:25:44
00:25:48
00:25:52
00:25:56
00:26:00
00:26:04
00:26:08
00:26:12
00:26:16
00:26:20
00:26:24
00:26:28
00:26:32
00:26:36
00:26:40
00:26:44
00:26:48
00:26:52
00:26:56
00:27:00
00:27:04
00:27:08
00:27:12
00:27:16
00:27:20
00:27:24
00:27:28
00:27:32
00:27:36
00:27:40
00:27:44
00:27:48
00:27:52
00:27:56
00:28:00
00:28:04
00:28:08
00:28:12
00:28:16
00:28:20
00:28:24
00:28:28
00:28:32
00:28:36
00:28:40
00:28:44
00:28:48
00:28:52
00:28:56
00:29:00
00:29:04
00:29:08
00:29:12
00:29:16
00:29:20
00:29:24
00:29:28
00:29:32
00:29:36
00:29:40
00:29:44
00:29:48
00:29:52
00:29:56
00:30:00
00:30:04
00:30:08
00:30:12
00:30:16
00:30:20
00:30:24
00:30:28
00:30:32
00:30:36
00:30:40
00:30:44
00:30:48
00:30:52
00:30:56

Transcript

Google Cloud Speech-to-Text API (Chirp) + Gemini 2.5 Flash Non-Thinking. Treat it as a searchable index of what was broadcast, not a quotation record.

00:00:00November 2nd, International Day to End Impunity for
00:00:04of establishments takes time, Crimes against
00:00:06money, it's complicated, especially when the Journalists.
00:00:08financial state of
00:00:11It's 10 AM here in Paris, hello everyone and welcome to
00:00:14Let's Talk About It, your news broadcast that takes its time. Here are the headlines for
00:00:18this Monday: mutual accusations of cyber-attacks between Kyiv and
00:00:21Moscow. Public warning systems were targeted,
00:00:25Russian and Ukrainian civilians have been receiving erroneous messages since yesterday
00:00:28evening, the time when... the truce ended in Olekhki in southern
00:00:32Ukraine. D-1 before the US
00:00:35midterm elections, a frantic end to the campaign for Donald
00:00:39Trump. Polls are very unfavorable to the Republican
00:00:43the current executive, with the President of camp. The American president showed his muscles again against Iran, we will come back to that in the
00:00:4611 AM news. And then,
00:00:49a back-to-school season under high tension in France after the All Saints' Day holidays.
00:00:53Despite the government's proposals, high school and
00:00:56university student representatives want to continue the blockades and rallies before the... inter-union
00:01:00dream on Thursday that they want to join. There are
00:01:03blocked establishments this morning,
00:01:05the financial situation of
00:01:06Emmanuel put his finger on the images from Paris and Toulouse
00:01:07live.
00:01:10And it is on this social anger that we will stop this morning with my guests. It has been
00:01:146 weeks since the high school movement began, after several days of
00:01:17more general mobilization against the high cost of living. Questions about the
00:01:21future and especially about the possible end of the crisis in the budgetary
00:01:25context that France is experiencing, 6 months before the presidential election. Who
00:01:29or what can bring calm to the country? A big question for
00:01:3245 minutes with Fleur Simon, Jean-Garregue, and Manuel Rivière. Good morning to all three of you, thank
00:01:36you for being here. Let's talk about it, and let's go.
00:01:50Hello Fleur Simon, hello. You are at home here, journalist in the
00:01:54political department of France 24. Next to you is Jean Garrig, hello Jean
00:01:57Garrig, thank you for being here. You are
00:02:00president of the international commission for the history of assemblies, a book to be
00:02:04published in a few weeks on soon on
00:02:07the presidents of the 5th Republic, it is a bit
00:02:11of circumstance, here is France and its presidentialism, we will come back to it.
00:02:16presidential election. What Emmanuel Rivière, hello to you, hello. You are a political scientist, co-author of "The
00:02:18Civil War Will Not Take Place", Robert Laffont 2026.
00:02:22There again a book, it is also a bit of circumstance, a bit of circumstance.
00:02:27social inequalities, Back to school under high tension therefore in authority of the
00:02:29the planet, it's a movement France, 6 weeks after the... of the high school movement which demands among
00:02:32other things better teaching conditions. Student organizations
00:02:36a form of violence or want to maintain pressure on a government whose response
00:02:39to the crisis they deem insufficient at this stage.
00:02:42As I was just telling you, we see live images, I think it's the Hélène Boucher high school on the left
00:02:46of your screen in Paris and images of Toulouse where there is
00:02:50visibly a bit of smoke around this establishment. We will
00:02:53take stock of this week under high tension with Marc Pop and we will talk about it
00:02:57right after.
00:03:01From Toulouse to Lille, passing through Paris, for this back-to-school
00:03:04season, it's high schools once again blocked that many students
00:03:07discover. Trash cans and barricades evacuated unceremoniously by
00:03:11the police in some places like in front of
00:03:14budget discussions, that the Turgo high school in Paris.
00:03:15on the side of the student Despite the All Saints' Day break and the call launched by the government to resume
00:03:19classes, the determination of the youth remains unwavering. And what
00:03:22high school and university students are saying is that the count is not there and that they are waiting for
00:03:26much clearer announcements. Pushing back the end
00:03:29of the program until 2028 when this government will no longer be
00:03:32there, very clearly, the commitment is not serious, it must be from 2027
00:03:36and above all that the government very clearly commits to saying that it is ending
00:03:40all selection at the entrance of university. The government
00:03:43hoped that the announcements made last Monday would be sufficient to appease the anger of high school
00:03:46students. The executive promised the gradual replacement of the
00:03:50Parcoursup platform, a ceiling of 28 students per second
00:03:53grade class, or even 15,000 additional places in higher
00:03:56education. The Minister of Education is once again calling
00:04:00this morning for an end to the blockades. Everyone is free to protest, but no one can
00:04:03prevent a classmate from going to class, I think that's still important to know. I remind you that normally a
00:04:07blockade is illegal and and and and that the necessity
00:04:11finally the absolute priority what a student needs today is to go to
00:04:15class. The week promises to be particularly tense for the
00:04:17government. High school and university student unions are predicting a black day in
00:04:21establishments on Tuesday, November 3rd, and from this Tuesday we will block our universities and
00:04:25high schools at the call of the high school union and the student union and the
00:04:28inter-union and we will block... Thursday also to then go to
00:04:31demonstration on November 5th. The
00:04:34squabbles with Gabriel Attal about high school mobilization thus calls for a convergence of struggles until the end of the
00:04:37week. The yellow vests who are protesting against the high cost of living announce
00:04:40blockades on November 6th and 7th throughout
00:04:42France. You just saw the map of calls
00:04:46to mobilize this week. Emmanuel
00:04:50Rivière, are we settling into a lasting
00:04:53see who will represent crisis? Yes, it will be difficult to get the movement
00:04:56back to normal for a whole host of reasons. First, because high school
00:05:00students themselves seem largely
00:05:03determined, partly supported by public opinion, which is quite hesitant, we see
00:05:07it well divided, not divided, but people are torn
00:05:10between the idea that this illegitimate movement carries
00:05:14deep and long-term aspirations, but at the same time it might be good to resume
00:05:18classes, that there are government proposals that are going in the
00:05:21right direction but that they are not sufficient. The problem is that all this also creates a kind of
00:05:25system with a state of society that is, for
00:05:29once, very angry with the way it is governed, not
00:05:32just for the past 10 years, with the way we
00:05:36allow people, young people to build their
00:05:39future, with purchasing power issues that have taken on a new dimension.
00:05:42Obviously, a very, very eruptive dimension with the rise in fuel
00:05:46prices, so a kind of general fed up that needs to
00:05:49express itself and which has found a focal
00:05:52point with
00:05:55the Republic who is also much questioned in the
00:05:59demonstrations. But what we see clearly when we look at the composition of the
00:06:02demonstrations and the signs that are flourishing in these demonstrations is that it
00:06:06goes in a whole host of directions, all quite legitimate to tell the truth, and that it is very
00:06:10difficult to respond to. We will certainly get to that.
00:06:13It creates a system, says Emmanuel Rivière, do you agree? Yes, I think
00:06:18core of the problem, that is to say that in reality
00:06:22there are a certain number of demands, some of which
00:06:25are legitimate, others, in my opinion, to be
00:06:29teachers and academics, seem
00:06:31a little utopian or unrealistic. Which ones? For example,
00:06:35the fact of eliminating selection at the entrance of
00:06:38universities. So rather than talking about selection, I would prefer to talk
00:06:41about orientation, but I think that we should perhaps even strengthen
00:06:45the orientation capacities of our system.
00:06:49This is the point of view of a university professor who sees 50% of
00:06:53students failing
00:06:56at the end of their first year and who sees
00:07:00well how much of a problem there has been in their orientation. But to
00:07:04return to the essential point, that is to say that you have a
00:07:07crisis not only of regime but almost a crisis
00:07:11of civilization, with this feeling
00:07:14for not only young people but also
00:07:17for almost all categories of
00:07:20society that we have a totally blocked future, a
00:07:23blocked social elevator, future prospects that are
00:07:27bleak, and it had to burst at some point.
00:07:31We already saw that during the yellow vest movement. Here,
00:07:34the focal point has been the high school students' revolt, but if you
00:07:38like, the responses to the
00:07:42high school student revolt, we can give them,
00:07:45perhaps we can go even further, certainly, and I think at some
00:07:48point the government will have to let go a little more, but
00:07:52fundamentally the problem, which is a problem of a crisis of
00:07:55our society, is not a problem that will be resolved in a few
00:07:59weeks. So it could very well be that these social
00:08:02movements will spread over months and months because in any case
00:08:06they will not be resolved in the
00:08:10long term. But precisely, there is a first figure there... a sign that the movement, at
00:08:13least on the part of high school students, is decreasing at this stage. 41
00:08:17establishments blocked across the country, that's 1% of high schools in
00:08:20France. The fact remains that the proponents of the
00:08:24strongest position from Simon among high school
00:08:27students and university students want to maintain it today, tomorrow, Thursday for
00:08:30the inter-union mobilization, we will come back to that, and why not
00:08:33Friday and Saturday which will be the 6th and the 7th of November, do a six
00:08:37seven as the young people say, that's part of the project
00:08:41uh on the demands of these high school students
00:08:44and university students. There were indeed, and Marc Poupe reminded us in his report at the beginning of
00:08:48last week, proposals made by the
00:08:51government, a reform of Parcoursup for
00:08:542028, more places in higher education,
00:08:58a maximum of 28 students per class in second year,
00:09:01grants indexed to inflation.
00:09:04Sophie Binet, we just heard her say that it wasn't serious because the calendar
00:09:08went beyond the presidential election. But in reality, what
00:09:11can this government, which will only last
00:09:145 more months, propose, and what else
00:09:18can it do, Pauline, at a time when public finances are in the red?
00:09:21That's still the main problem. So it's true that we saw, well,
00:09:2515,000 additional places, 15,000 professors in higher education,
00:09:29students are asking for 25,000, so it's clear that if we look at the numbers, it's
00:09:33far below. Except that in reality, today, we must still remember that at
00:09:36a time when the budget is being debated in the National Assembly
00:09:40and there... largely criticized by the opposition, there is no more money,
00:09:43and that is the whole problem, because
00:09:47not only are there high school students, but as we said, there are also
00:09:50farmers, fuel prices that are only
00:09:54increasing. So it's true that there is a multiplicity
00:09:57of demands for which it would be necessary to invest
00:10:00and for the government to contribute, except that the problem is that today
00:10:04it is no longer possible, and it is no longer possible also, Pauline, because
00:10:08ultimately these are the lenders, in fact all this money
00:10:11is borrowed, so today the government has more and more difficulty borrowing and at
00:10:15extremely high rates. So it's clear that the main point
00:10:19and the main problem that will be extremely complicated for high school students
00:10:23to get what they want. We even hear some unions talk about 10 billion
00:10:27euros, and it will be very difficult for the government to to to
00:10:30meet their demands in addition to all the other ones around, the high
00:10:34cost of living and fuel and farmers, etc. and the increase in the minimum wage
00:10:38which is currently being studied to be implemented before January 1st
00:10:42as well. Yes, well precisely, if we broaden the scope, we understood
00:10:45that high school students had joined a movement that was
00:10:48announced before this crisis started in establishments, particularly in the Parisian
00:10:52suburbs, at the end of September.
00:10:56And as you recalled earlier, Emmanuel Rivière, today in the
00:10:59demonstrations, called the yellow vests, but also in front of the high schools, we
00:11:03see a whole range, no it was you who said it, Jean-Guarry, of
00:11:06rather disparate demands for social
00:11:09justice, equality, freedom of expression following
00:11:13the restrictions on demonstrations
00:11:16that there have been in recent weeks. We see
00:11:19questions emerging about democracy, uh about access to
00:11:23rights, of course about... purchasing power
00:11:26uh given the situations,
00:11:30France, and given the calendar, can we really imagine
00:11:33uh that a government can concretely
00:11:36respond to all this all this, this mille-feuille of
00:11:40anger? Well, rather difficult, by the way, it's interesting to look at the chronology, because
00:11:44we're back at school, there were indeed a certain number of tensions that were linked both to the rise in fuel
00:11:47prices and to the devastating impact of
00:11:51heatwaves and fires, with a whole host of... professions that
00:11:54had demands in a somewhat scattered order, each one saying to themselves,
00:11:58in a reasoning that is actually quite founded, there's so much less money in the
00:12:01coffers, that it's better for us to try to grab what's left
00:12:05still possible uh than to
00:12:09organize the convergence of struggles. The convergence of struggles has become, thanks to the
00:12:13high school students, in a certain way, who indeed mobilized
00:12:16before the appointments that had been made, but they imposed the themes in a
00:12:20certain way, and I think that the fact that it is a... movement of
00:12:23high school students, very much driven at the beginning by high school and
00:12:27university students, gives it a theme, in fact, it's a
00:12:30social movement about the future and about the lack of future, as Jean
00:12:34Garrig said, it's a movement that raises fundamental questions about
00:12:37indeed the future of democracy, because we have added a layer
00:12:41of debate about the very treatment of these movements, both the
00:12:45response in terms of maintaining order and the response to organizational
00:12:49constraints, prohibitions, and so on. But it's a movement about the future of
00:12:54of 2027 appears both
00:13:04short and a little discredited too, that's the question that
00:13:07is dizzying, it's normally an election like
00:13:11the presidential election should be the outlet for these
00:13:15questions, these anxieties, what this
00:13:18movement tells us a little and its success uh both in
00:13:21public opinion and in the street even if it is stronger in the street
00:13:25than in public opinion where it is relatively measured as
00:13:28support, it's that we don't really
00:13:31believe that the presidential campaign can
00:13:35organize the debate and provide answers to these fundamental
00:13:38questions which are indeed long-term questions, whereas the
00:13:42tendency is still very much to focus on the short term and these
00:13:46are more the answers that citizens no doubt expect, but on the question of temporality,
00:13:50is it that we spoke of a convergence of anger and struggles?
00:13:53We find in the demonstrations
00:13:55since October 17th, demonstrations that went better the last
00:13:58two weekends than the first, could it have been worse, however,
00:14:02is the temporality of demands the same because
00:14:06the anger against the high cost of
00:14:09living demands a very rapid response, and in that sense, no
00:14:12doubt that alleviating some of the pressure on fuel
00:14:16prices after the release of strategic stocks will perhaps
00:14:20give a little breathing room. But high school students
00:14:22are asking for rapid responses but on long-term
00:14:26things, while the French, the yellow vests, want
00:14:29immediate answers that that, yeah, you are totally right,
00:14:33it's also a problem that arose in a
00:14:37crisis that was the biggest crisis of the 5th
00:14:40Republic, which was that of the revolt of May '68, which started, it must
00:14:44also be remembered, with a revolt of the student world that was a generational
00:14:47revolt against a future that no one
00:14:51wanted anymore. There are similarities
00:14:55with today, but I will also come back to the differences, but we started
00:14:58from there, and a social movement came to be grafted on, which called
00:15:02for short-term solutions that came, moreover, with the Grenelle agreements
00:15:06in May '68. And here there is a phenomenon that is a bit of the same
00:15:09kind, that is to say, we have a generational
00:15:13challenge that arises for young people who were born between the
00:15:1690s and 2010s and who call
00:15:19for solutions that are in reality long- term
00:15:23uh including.
00:15:25This is where I disagree with Sophie Binet,
00:15:29reforming a system similar to that of
00:15:32Parcoursup, in any case a new orientation system, takes
00:15:36time, it's complicated. Restoring a certain number
00:15:45France is deplorable. So there's
00:15:49that, excuse me for interrupting you, Parcoursup, at the time it was conceived, was supposed
00:15:53to erase social inequalities that are unique to French
00:15:56schools in Europe and creates inequalities, which it actually
00:16:00does, because Parcoursup is the least bad of the
00:16:03systems we've known for 30 years. But if you
00:16:07like, the big problem is that this transfer
00:16:11towards social questions about purchasing power, which we've
00:16:14always known throughout almost the entire 5th
00:16:18Republic, it also calls for solutions that
00:16:21are in a different temporality than those posed
00:16:25by young people who are facing a bleak future because
00:16:28of pandemics, because of climate crises, because
00:16:32of AI which is coming and which will undoubtedly disrupt at least 50%
00:16:36of jobs. So these are fundamental answers, it's
00:16:39really a challenge for almost
00:16:43civilization, and then you also have immediate
00:16:46questions about purchasing power for 10 million
00:16:50French people who are below the minimum wage and who cannot make
00:16:53ends meet, and this makes things much
00:16:57more complicated than in May '68, because in May '68 there was 5%
00:17:00growth, there was fat to chew on to answer
00:17:04the questions of young people
00:17:07and the social movement, and including for
00:17:11young people, there was a generation that was coming and that was going to be able to
00:17:14express itself and take power, that is to say this generation which is today challenged
00:17:18by young people. So there are these very different temporalities,
00:17:22plus the fact that, as Flor pointed out, from the governmental
00:17:25side, there aren't many solutions, especially since we are at the end
00:17:28of a reign, and there is a president who is rejected by the French.
00:17:32So that means we are in a situation that is
00:17:35quite worrying, to say the
00:17:37least. And then an economy at a standstill, indeed, you were talking about
00:17:405% growth in '68, we are at -0.1 for this 3rd quarter,
00:17:44a French economy at a standstill, these are the words of the Minister
00:17:47of Economy. There are still 6 months left
00:17:50for this government until the
00:17:53can it put on the table, where are we
00:17:55going? That's the question this program is asking this morning. Until a mobilization
00:17:59until? And maybe even after because as
00:18:03Emmanuel Petit said, I think Rivière
00:18:06Rivière, pardon
00:18:10Rivière Emmanuel, you are to politics what Emmanuel was to football. Emmanuel
00:18:14Rivière, no, but it can even last after because it's not because there
00:18:17will be a new president of the Republic, there will
00:18:20priori in May 2027 that all these
00:18:24demands and especially this fundamental problem which is that of the economy
00:18:27will change. So it's true that today the government, in
00:18:30addition to having its finances in the red, does not have,
00:18:34I remind you, an absolute majority in the National Assembly,
00:18:38so that's also extremely complicated. Moreover, we already see
00:18:41it on the budget for next year.
00:18:45We see that the benches of the hemicycle are deserted
00:18:48even though we are in the middle of
00:18:51the government's proposal has already been largely swept aside
00:18:55by the opposition. So that's a real problem, it's
00:18:59not only these finances but also this
00:19:02lack of a majority in the assembly with a
00:19:05president of the Republic who is the target of all the
00:19:09ills, all the problems, in any case that's what we
00:19:12can also see and hear from the opposition,
00:19:16of course, but also in these demonstrations. So it's true that
00:19:19there's the impression that the government is at a dead end, but once again,
00:19:23the next president of the Republic or the next female president of the
00:19:27Republic uh what
00:19:30more can she do? Because public
00:19:34finances won't just improve overnight, unless we erase the debt, but that's
00:19:38another subject uh the
00:19:41position of Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Jean-Luc Mélenchon's position, absolutely.
00:19:45Uh, well, it's true that we can tell ourselves that it can last, and then
00:19:49moreover, to come back to the high school students, we see that today the movement is still
00:19:52quite politicized, very structured, very organized, and they have
00:19:56a capacity for mobilization in the long term because, well, quite
00:19:59simply, they don't lose days of salary when they
00:20:03mobilize or strike. So that can, unlike
00:20:06employees. Uh, you wanted to react, Emmanuel? Yes, on the
00:20:10continuation of the movement, we can still make several hypotheses,
00:20:14and uh well, the mobilization this morning is still less strong than it was before
00:20:17the holidays, that is to say there is a reality that has not disappeared
00:20:20on Parcoursup. The point of view
00:20:24we can have when we work on the perception
00:20:27of young people is a little different from the point of view of university
00:20:31efficiency. We conducted a survey
00:20:33recently for the agricultural grid, well, a survey
00:20:37that was conducted both by the Cluster 17 institute and the Grand
00:20:41Public agency on young people, there were 300 young people interviewed. The first adjective that
00:20:44young people used to describe themselves was stressed, before
00:20:48supportive, committed, stressed.
00:20:54Young people aged 15 to 17 said they were stressed. There is a
00:20:58small subject on this regarding Parcoursup and the way in which
00:21:02school results from the first year give the feeling that one's future is being
00:21:05decided. But the consequence of that is that, well, high school students
00:21:09today are also asking themselves a little about what their absence
00:21:13of grades is becoming, what is happening in the blocked establishments compared to
00:21:16establishments that continue to function with grades, knowing well
00:21:27but that Saturdays remain days of mobilization precisely because
00:21:30Saturdays do not cause a loss of class days, do not cause a loss of salary, a
00:21:34little like the yellow vests and which had gradually
00:21:37faded away as time passed.
00:21:41So I think the most probable scenario is still that
00:21:45after the holidays there won't be much left of these Saturday
00:21:48mobilizations, but that's not to say that nothing will remain at all, quite the
00:21:51contrary to all the anxieties that are being expressed. Yes, yes, Jean
00:21:55Guerri, yes, what in reality, what
00:21:58interests me if we zoom out a little bit, so I Parcoursup there also
00:22:01I understand the perception that exists today, but
00:22:05the previous systems were much more stressful in reality, and
00:22:09for years, high school and student organizations had been
00:22:12specifically asking for a system like Parcoursup. So it was
00:22:16badly handled, badly
00:22:19handled, etc., and that's what generates stress, we
00:22:23agree, but to get back to the essential,
00:22:26what's sad, I mean, is that what high school
00:22:30students and students are raising today
00:22:33is this concern about the future. It
00:22:36should precisely give the opportunity, since there's a
00:22:39presidential election, for a big debate, particularly on
00:22:43our education system that doesn't work,
00:22:46on this social elevator that's blocked, etc.
00:22:50And what we see, the very structure of these
00:22:54demonstrations, the polarization on issues of
00:22:57law enforcement, violence, and
00:23:00the essentialization of opponents, the polarization of
00:23:03debates, etcetera, etcetera, means that
00:23:06we are missing out on a major debate. So what you're saying
00:23:09is that this high school movement could have imposed the theme of the
00:23:13presidential election,
00:23:17access to education. And in
00:23:20reality, having slipped in some places into
00:23:26chaos, as some even say,
00:23:28what it could have generated as a public debate
00:23:32is not happening. Yes, and not only that, but
00:23:36also the fact of trying to
00:23:39reduce the movement to a few
00:23:42demands that are legitimate,
00:23:45by the way, I think that it would deserve much more. In any
00:23:48case, it would deserve to be taken up by the presidential
00:23:52candidates, and the fact is that for
00:23:55now, only France Insoumise is really
00:23:58present in the discussions about this
00:24:02problem. But does France Insoumise really have something, and here I
00:24:05turn to you, Flore, does it emerge as
00:24:09a winner from this sequence in terms of voting
00:24:13intentions? In any case, if we look at the polls,
00:24:16it's the first political party/movement that
00:24:20attracts 18-24 year olds, around 40%. High school students don't have the right to vote,
00:24:23should we remind them? Yes, but well, 18-24 year olds, after all, there are also students,
00:24:27etc., so for young people, yes. But then again, these young people also have to turn out, because these
00:24:31are voting intentions, but it's not a segment of the population that
00:24:35votes a lot. Jean-Luc Mélenchon
00:24:39and France Insoumise in general, it's true that we saw them from the start
00:24:42on the blockades, then we see them in all the
00:24:45demonstrations, they are indeed, they want to be
00:24:49uh, not only the embodiment of this high school
00:24:52movement, but also the political outcome. So, once again,
00:24:56with the fact that some don't vote yet, and
00:24:59that it's not a segment of the population that turns out much, but nevertheless, they want to bring
00:25:03young people with them. Uh, just a quick word, what
00:25:07we also see in these mobilizations is that there's
00:25:10also, I think,
00:25:12a reality, which is that the National Rally is currently
00:25:16leading in voting intentions in the first round, and...
00:25:20Marine Le Pen is winning in all voting intentions for the second
00:25:23round, and we see that these are young people mobilizing, but
00:25:27not only them, and we also see on the placards and in the
00:25:31demands a kind of awareness that they don't want
00:25:34these people who are demonstrating to refuse the National
00:25:37Rally at the Élysée. So on that too, France
00:25:41Insoumise, which is with the National Rally, also
00:25:44has its card to play, if you will, in this
00:25:48mobilization where we see that the National Rally could
00:25:52access the Élysée. Does Jean-Luc Mélenchon see
00:25:55in this social anger
00:25:58a way to inflate the votes, let's say?
00:26:03To increase voting intentions in his favor for a potential
00:26:07second round in the presidential election? Very clearly, I think France Insoumise must
00:26:10see the confirmation of part of its winning
00:26:14scenario. In their minds, there is an electorate to conquer, which is an
00:26:18abstentionist electorate that they have called the
00:26:224th bloc, and which relies heavily on the mobilization
00:26:25of young people. So I think that could be
00:26:28part of the possible scenarios, that this presidential
00:26:32election corrects a bit, well, it's always the case for presidential
00:26:36elections, elections with high mobilization, always a differential in
00:26:39participation among young people, it could perhaps be attenuated precisely in
00:26:43the wake of this movement. After that, is that enough
00:26:46to allow Jean-Luc Mélenchon to be well positioned? I
00:26:50think he has both, they have been able to capitalize on the fact of being
00:26:53effectively the only political movement that gives the feeling of offering a
00:26:57political outlet to this movement, but from a mathematical
00:27:00point of view, it has its advantages and disadvantages. Yes, and above all, in fact,
00:27:04the events of October 17th also accentuated a form of
00:27:08polarization, reinforcing the opposing camp, rather the
00:27:12camp of Marine Le Pen, that there are disorders that need to be addressed,
00:27:15but what is quite striking is that between
00:27:19these two, no one seemed to grasp what was happening
00:27:23and offer a response. We will come back to the center,
00:27:27indeed, in any case, those who are between France Insoumise and the
00:27:30National Rally, how should we call them? The National
00:27:34Rally. Jean-Garrigues, who for a month now has been
00:27:37doing a kind of balancing act between his voters
00:27:41concerned about security and those who contest their living
00:27:45conditions, who are sometimes the same. The demonstrators of
00:27:49the weekend sometimes being the parents of the high school students. There is a
00:27:52symbiosis to be made in the discourse. Has the crest been
00:27:56found by the party leadership? I
00:27:59well, it's perhaps too early to say, but... Apparently yes, since
00:28:03we don't see a priori a decline
00:28:07in voting intentions in favor of Marine Le Pen, and
00:28:11in fact, the soup remains good, I mean
00:28:14that the quite intelligently,
00:28:18by the way, with a certain political sense, the
00:28:21National Rally plays the card first of all of order,
00:28:25of the failing
00:28:27state to position itself well as an opponent of
00:28:31Macronism. But above all, to position itself well as
00:28:35the opponent of France Insoumise, and ultimately it's
00:28:37that, it's a game, it's a rather perverse game in fact
00:28:41between the two extremes, one embodying the
00:28:45party of order, the other the party of the street, and
00:28:48ultimately the French today are, French public
00:28:51opinion through the media is
00:28:54prisoner of this confrontation, this
00:28:58bipolarity, this brutalization of political
00:29:01relations. And that's why those who
00:29:05are between the two are inaudible because
00:29:08we have gotten used to this form of polarization and that, quite
00:29:12skilfully, both Jean-Luc Mélenchon effectively
00:29:17revolt and the social movement, the National
00:29:21Rally on the side of order, and we see that 80%
00:29:25of French people were in favor of the demonstrations stopping,
00:29:29that they were against obviously all the...
00:29:32manifestations of looting or other
00:29:35violence, and on that, it's Marine Le Pen
00:29:38who capitalizes, and so we are, I repeat, in this perverse
00:29:42game where we don't see how the
00:29:45central bloc, ranging from Raphaël Glucksmann to
00:29:49David Lisnard, can really
00:29:51extricate themselves. It's up to them to be
00:29:55much more present in the fundamental debate, in the truly
00:29:58political debate, but it's also true that to
00:30:02their... disadvantage, how can I put it, the media
00:30:06coverage of what's happening inevitably focuses
00:30:09on events of demonstrations or
00:30:13violence, and we tend to forget the intellectual debate, the
00:30:17political debate on the issues, and that's why
00:30:21we still see quite little, but it's true that it's
00:30:24surprising nonetheless, it's surprisingly inaudible, Flore.
00:30:27Raphaël Glucksmann, Bruno Retailleau, Edouard
00:30:31Philippe, whom we heard yesterday, who talked more about his
00:30:37the possibility of organizing a center-right primary than
00:30:40about the core of the problem. Also inaudible, Bruno Retailleau.
00:30:44But you just said it, exactly, Edouard Philippe and Raphaël Glucksmann, and
00:30:48it's rather, sorry, Philippe and Gabriel Attal, it's rather, well, they're a bit
00:30:52in a race against each other to
00:30:56the
Data courtesy of The GDELT Project (gdeltproject.org), from the Internet Archive TV News Archive. Film strip and transcript are GDELT's, rehosted here under their terms of use, which permit it with this citation.