Google Cloud Speech-to-Text API (Chirp) + Gemini 2.5 Flash Non-Thinking. Treat it as a searchable index of what was broadcast, not a quotation record.
00:00:00November 2nd, International Day to End Impunity for
00:00:04of establishments takes time, Crimes against
00:00:06money, it's complicated, especially when the Journalists.
00:00:08financial state of
00:00:11It's 10 AM here in Paris, hello everyone and welcome to
00:00:14Let's Talk About It, your news broadcast that takes its time. Here are the headlines for
00:00:18this Monday: mutual accusations of cyber-attacks between Kyiv and
00:00:21Moscow. Public warning systems were targeted,
00:00:25Russian and Ukrainian civilians have been receiving erroneous messages since yesterday
00:00:28evening, the time when... the truce ended in Olekhki in southern
00:00:32Ukraine. D-1 before the US
00:00:35midterm elections, a frantic end to the campaign for Donald
00:00:39Trump. Polls are very unfavorable to the Republican
00:00:43the current executive, with the President of camp. The American president showed his muscles again against Iran, we will come back to that in the
00:00:4611 AM news. And then,
00:00:49a back-to-school season under high tension in France after the All Saints' Day holidays.
00:00:53Despite the government's proposals, high school and
00:00:56university student representatives want to continue the blockades and rallies before the... inter-union
00:01:00dream on Thursday that they want to join. There are
00:01:03blocked establishments this morning,
00:01:05the financial situation of
00:01:06Emmanuel put his finger on the images from Paris and Toulouse
00:01:07live.
00:01:10And it is on this social anger that we will stop this morning with my guests. It has been
00:01:146 weeks since the high school movement began, after several days of
00:01:17more general mobilization against the high cost of living. Questions about the
00:01:21future and especially about the possible end of the crisis in the budgetary
00:01:25context that France is experiencing, 6 months before the presidential election. Who
00:01:29or what can bring calm to the country? A big question for
00:01:3245 minutes with Fleur Simon, Jean-Garregue, and Manuel Rivière. Good morning to all three of you, thank
00:01:36you for being here. Let's talk about it, and let's go.
00:01:50Hello Fleur Simon, hello. You are at home here, journalist in the
00:01:54political department of France 24. Next to you is Jean Garrig, hello Jean
00:01:57Garrig, thank you for being here. You are
00:02:00president of the international commission for the history of assemblies, a book to be
00:02:04published in a few weeks on soon on
00:02:07the presidents of the 5th Republic, it is a bit
00:02:11of circumstance, here is France and its presidentialism, we will come back to it.
00:02:16presidential election. What Emmanuel Rivière, hello to you, hello. You are a political scientist, co-author of "The
00:02:18Civil War Will Not Take Place", Robert Laffont 2026.
00:02:22There again a book, it is also a bit of circumstance, a bit of circumstance.
00:02:27social inequalities, Back to school under high tension therefore in authority of the
00:02:29the planet, it's a movement France, 6 weeks after the... of the high school movement which demands among
00:02:32other things better teaching conditions. Student organizations
00:02:36a form of violence or want to maintain pressure on a government whose response
00:02:39to the crisis they deem insufficient at this stage.
00:02:42As I was just telling you, we see live images, I think it's the Hélène Boucher high school on the left
00:02:46of your screen in Paris and images of Toulouse where there is
00:02:50visibly a bit of smoke around this establishment. We will
00:02:53take stock of this week under high tension with Marc Pop and we will talk about it
00:02:57right after.
00:03:01From Toulouse to Lille, passing through Paris, for this back-to-school
00:03:04season, it's high schools once again blocked that many students
00:03:07discover. Trash cans and barricades evacuated unceremoniously by
00:03:11the police in some places like in front of
00:03:14budget discussions, that the Turgo high school in Paris.
00:03:15on the side of the student Despite the All Saints' Day break and the call launched by the government to resume
00:03:19classes, the determination of the youth remains unwavering. And what
00:03:22high school and university students are saying is that the count is not there and that they are waiting for
00:03:26much clearer announcements. Pushing back the end
00:03:29of the program until 2028 when this government will no longer be
00:03:32there, very clearly, the commitment is not serious, it must be from 2027
00:03:36and above all that the government very clearly commits to saying that it is ending
00:03:40all selection at the entrance of university. The government
00:03:43hoped that the announcements made last Monday would be sufficient to appease the anger of high school
00:03:46students. The executive promised the gradual replacement of the
00:03:50Parcoursup platform, a ceiling of 28 students per second
00:03:53grade class, or even 15,000 additional places in higher
00:03:56education. The Minister of Education is once again calling
00:04:00this morning for an end to the blockades. Everyone is free to protest, but no one can
00:04:03prevent a classmate from going to class, I think that's still important to know. I remind you that normally a
00:04:07blockade is illegal and and and and that the necessity
00:04:11finally the absolute priority what a student needs today is to go to
00:04:15class. The week promises to be particularly tense for the
00:04:17government. High school and university student unions are predicting a black day in
00:04:21establishments on Tuesday, November 3rd, and from this Tuesday we will block our universities and
00:04:25high schools at the call of the high school union and the student union and the
00:04:28inter-union and we will block... Thursday also to then go to
00:04:31demonstration on November 5th. The
00:04:34squabbles with Gabriel Attal about high school mobilization thus calls for a convergence of struggles until the end of the
00:04:37week. The yellow vests who are protesting against the high cost of living announce
00:04:40blockades on November 6th and 7th throughout
00:04:42France. You just saw the map of calls
00:04:46to mobilize this week. Emmanuel
00:04:50Rivière, are we settling into a lasting
00:04:53see who will represent crisis? Yes, it will be difficult to get the movement
00:04:56back to normal for a whole host of reasons. First, because high school
00:05:00students themselves seem largely
00:05:03determined, partly supported by public opinion, which is quite hesitant, we see
00:05:07it well divided, not divided, but people are torn
00:05:10between the idea that this illegitimate movement carries
00:05:14deep and long-term aspirations, but at the same time it might be good to resume
00:05:18classes, that there are government proposals that are going in the
00:05:21right direction but that they are not sufficient. The problem is that all this also creates a kind of
00:05:25system with a state of society that is, for
00:05:29once, very angry with the way it is governed, not
00:05:32just for the past 10 years, with the way we
00:05:36allow people, young people to build their
00:05:39future, with purchasing power issues that have taken on a new dimension.
00:05:42Obviously, a very, very eruptive dimension with the rise in fuel
00:05:46prices, so a kind of general fed up that needs to
00:05:49express itself and which has found a focal
00:05:52point with
00:05:55the Republic who is also much questioned in the
00:05:59demonstrations. But what we see clearly when we look at the composition of the
00:06:02demonstrations and the signs that are flourishing in these demonstrations is that it
00:06:06goes in a whole host of directions, all quite legitimate to tell the truth, and that it is very
00:06:10difficult to respond to. We will certainly get to that.
00:06:13It creates a system, says Emmanuel Rivière, do you agree? Yes, I think
00:06:18core of the problem, that is to say that in reality
00:06:22there are a certain number of demands, some of which
00:06:25are legitimate, others, in my opinion, to be
00:06:29teachers and academics, seem
00:06:31a little utopian or unrealistic. Which ones? For example,
00:06:35the fact of eliminating selection at the entrance of
00:06:38universities. So rather than talking about selection, I would prefer to talk
00:06:41about orientation, but I think that we should perhaps even strengthen
00:06:45the orientation capacities of our system.
00:06:49This is the point of view of a university professor who sees 50% of
00:06:53students failing
00:06:56at the end of their first year and who sees
00:07:00well how much of a problem there has been in their orientation. But to
00:07:04return to the essential point, that is to say that you have a
00:07:07crisis not only of regime but almost a crisis
00:07:11of civilization, with this feeling
00:07:14for not only young people but also
00:07:17for almost all categories of
00:07:20society that we have a totally blocked future, a
00:07:23blocked social elevator, future prospects that are
00:07:27bleak, and it had to burst at some point.
00:07:31We already saw that during the yellow vest movement. Here,
00:07:34the focal point has been the high school students' revolt, but if you
00:07:38like, the responses to the
00:07:42high school student revolt, we can give them,
00:07:45perhaps we can go even further, certainly, and I think at some
00:07:48point the government will have to let go a little more, but
00:07:52fundamentally the problem, which is a problem of a crisis of
00:07:55our society, is not a problem that will be resolved in a few
00:07:59weeks. So it could very well be that these social
00:08:02movements will spread over months and months because in any case
00:08:06they will not be resolved in the
00:08:10long term. But precisely, there is a first figure there... a sign that the movement, at
00:08:13least on the part of high school students, is decreasing at this stage. 41
00:08:17establishments blocked across the country, that's 1% of high schools in
00:08:20France. The fact remains that the proponents of the
00:08:24strongest position from Simon among high school
00:08:27students and university students want to maintain it today, tomorrow, Thursday for
00:08:30the inter-union mobilization, we will come back to that, and why not
00:08:33Friday and Saturday which will be the 6th and the 7th of November, do a six
00:08:37seven as the young people say, that's part of the project
00:08:41uh on the demands of these high school students
00:08:44and university students. There were indeed, and Marc Poupe reminded us in his report at the beginning of
00:08:48last week, proposals made by the
00:08:51government, a reform of Parcoursup for
00:08:542028, more places in higher education,
00:08:58a maximum of 28 students per class in second year,
00:09:01grants indexed to inflation.
00:09:04Sophie Binet, we just heard her say that it wasn't serious because the calendar
00:09:08went beyond the presidential election. But in reality, what
00:09:11can this government, which will only last
00:09:145 more months, propose, and what else
00:09:18can it do, Pauline, at a time when public finances are in the red?
00:09:21That's still the main problem. So it's true that we saw, well,
00:09:2515,000 additional places, 15,000 professors in higher education,
00:09:29students are asking for 25,000, so it's clear that if we look at the numbers, it's
00:09:33far below. Except that in reality, today, we must still remember that at
00:09:36a time when the budget is being debated in the National Assembly
00:09:40and there... largely criticized by the opposition, there is no more money,
00:09:43and that is the whole problem, because
00:09:47not only are there high school students, but as we said, there are also
00:09:50farmers, fuel prices that are only
00:09:54increasing. So it's true that there is a multiplicity
00:09:57of demands for which it would be necessary to invest
00:10:00and for the government to contribute, except that the problem is that today
00:10:04it is no longer possible, and it is no longer possible also, Pauline, because
00:10:08ultimately these are the lenders, in fact all this money
00:10:11is borrowed, so today the government has more and more difficulty borrowing and at
00:10:15extremely high rates. So it's clear that the main point
00:10:19and the main problem that will be extremely complicated for high school students
00:10:23to get what they want. We even hear some unions talk about 10 billion
00:10:27euros, and it will be very difficult for the government to to to
00:10:30meet their demands in addition to all the other ones around, the high
00:10:34cost of living and fuel and farmers, etc. and the increase in the minimum wage
00:10:38which is currently being studied to be implemented before January 1st
00:10:42as well. Yes, well precisely, if we broaden the scope, we understood
00:10:45that high school students had joined a movement that was
00:10:48announced before this crisis started in establishments, particularly in the Parisian
00:10:52suburbs, at the end of September.
00:10:56And as you recalled earlier, Emmanuel Rivière, today in the
00:10:59demonstrations, called the yellow vests, but also in front of the high schools, we
00:11:03see a whole range, no it was you who said it, Jean-Guarry, of
00:11:06rather disparate demands for social
00:11:09justice, equality, freedom of expression following
00:11:13the restrictions on demonstrations
00:11:16that there have been in recent weeks. We see
00:11:19questions emerging about democracy, uh about access to
00:11:23rights, of course about... purchasing power
00:11:26uh given the situations,
00:11:30France, and given the calendar, can we really imagine
00:11:33uh that a government can concretely
00:11:36respond to all this all this, this mille-feuille of
00:11:40anger? Well, rather difficult, by the way, it's interesting to look at the chronology, because
00:11:44we're back at school, there were indeed a certain number of tensions that were linked both to the rise in fuel
00:11:47prices and to the devastating impact of
00:11:51heatwaves and fires, with a whole host of... professions that
00:11:54had demands in a somewhat scattered order, each one saying to themselves,
00:11:58in a reasoning that is actually quite founded, there's so much less money in the
00:12:01coffers, that it's better for us to try to grab what's left
00:12:05still possible uh than to
00:12:09organize the convergence of struggles. The convergence of struggles has become, thanks to the
00:12:13high school students, in a certain way, who indeed mobilized
00:12:16before the appointments that had been made, but they imposed the themes in a
00:12:20certain way, and I think that the fact that it is a... movement of
00:12:23high school students, very much driven at the beginning by high school and
00:12:27university students, gives it a theme, in fact, it's a
00:12:30social movement about the future and about the lack of future, as Jean
00:12:34Garrig said, it's a movement that raises fundamental questions about
00:12:37indeed the future of democracy, because we have added a layer
00:12:41of debate about the very treatment of these movements, both the
00:12:45response in terms of maintaining order and the response to organizational
00:12:49constraints, prohibitions, and so on. But it's a movement about the future of
00:12:54of 2027 appears both
00:13:04short and a little discredited too, that's the question that
00:13:07is dizzying, it's normally an election like
00:13:11the presidential election should be the outlet for these
00:13:15questions, these anxieties, what this
00:13:18movement tells us a little and its success uh both in
00:13:21public opinion and in the street even if it is stronger in the street
00:13:25than in public opinion where it is relatively measured as
00:13:28support, it's that we don't really
00:13:31believe that the presidential campaign can
00:13:35organize the debate and provide answers to these fundamental
00:13:38questions which are indeed long-term questions, whereas the
00:13:42tendency is still very much to focus on the short term and these
00:13:46are more the answers that citizens no doubt expect, but on the question of temporality,
00:13:50is it that we spoke of a convergence of anger and struggles?
00:13:53We find in the demonstrations
00:13:55since October 17th, demonstrations that went better the last
00:13:58two weekends than the first, could it have been worse, however,
00:14:02is the temporality of demands the same because
00:14:06the anger against the high cost of
00:14:09living demands a very rapid response, and in that sense, no
00:14:12doubt that alleviating some of the pressure on fuel
00:14:16prices after the release of strategic stocks will perhaps
00:14:20give a little breathing room. But high school students
00:14:22are asking for rapid responses but on long-term
00:14:26things, while the French, the yellow vests, want
00:14:29immediate answers that that, yeah, you are totally right,
00:14:33it's also a problem that arose in a
00:14:37crisis that was the biggest crisis of the 5th
00:14:40Republic, which was that of the revolt of May '68, which started, it must
00:14:44also be remembered, with a revolt of the student world that was a generational
00:14:47revolt against a future that no one
00:14:51wanted anymore. There are similarities
00:14:55with today, but I will also come back to the differences, but we started
00:14:58from there, and a social movement came to be grafted on, which called
00:15:02for short-term solutions that came, moreover, with the Grenelle agreements
00:15:06in May '68. And here there is a phenomenon that is a bit of the same
00:15:09kind, that is to say, we have a generational
00:15:13challenge that arises for young people who were born between the
00:15:1690s and 2010s and who call
00:15:19for solutions that are in reality long- term
00:15:23uh including.
00:15:25This is where I disagree with Sophie Binet,
00:15:29reforming a system similar to that of
00:15:32Parcoursup, in any case a new orientation system, takes
00:15:36time, it's complicated. Restoring a certain number
00:15:45France is deplorable. So there's
00:15:49that, excuse me for interrupting you, Parcoursup, at the time it was conceived, was supposed
00:15:53to erase social inequalities that are unique to French
00:15:56schools in Europe and creates inequalities, which it actually
00:16:00does, because Parcoursup is the least bad of the
00:16:03systems we've known for 30 years. But if you
00:16:07like, the big problem is that this transfer
00:16:11towards social questions about purchasing power, which we've
00:16:14always known throughout almost the entire 5th
00:16:18Republic, it also calls for solutions that
00:16:21are in a different temporality than those posed
00:16:25by young people who are facing a bleak future because
00:16:28of pandemics, because of climate crises, because
00:16:32of AI which is coming and which will undoubtedly disrupt at least 50%
00:16:36of jobs. So these are fundamental answers, it's
00:16:39really a challenge for almost
00:16:43civilization, and then you also have immediate
00:16:46questions about purchasing power for 10 million
00:16:50French people who are below the minimum wage and who cannot make
00:16:53ends meet, and this makes things much
00:16:57more complicated than in May '68, because in May '68 there was 5%
00:17:00growth, there was fat to chew on to answer
00:17:04the questions of young people
00:17:07and the social movement, and including for
00:17:11young people, there was a generation that was coming and that was going to be able to
00:17:14express itself and take power, that is to say this generation which is today challenged
00:17:18by young people. So there are these very different temporalities,
00:17:22plus the fact that, as Flor pointed out, from the governmental
00:17:25side, there aren't many solutions, especially since we are at the end
00:17:28of a reign, and there is a president who is rejected by the French.
00:17:32So that means we are in a situation that is
00:17:35quite worrying, to say the
00:17:37least. And then an economy at a standstill, indeed, you were talking about
00:17:405% growth in '68, we are at -0.1 for this 3rd quarter,
00:17:44a French economy at a standstill, these are the words of the Minister
00:17:47of Economy. There are still 6 months left
00:17:50for this government until the
00:17:53can it put on the table, where are we
00:17:55going? That's the question this program is asking this morning. Until a mobilization
00:17:59until? And maybe even after because as
00:18:03Emmanuel Petit said, I think Rivière
00:18:06Rivière, pardon
00:18:10Rivière Emmanuel, you are to politics what Emmanuel was to football. Emmanuel
00:18:14Rivière, no, but it can even last after because it's not because there
00:18:17will be a new president of the Republic, there will
00:18:20priori in May 2027 that all these
00:18:24demands and especially this fundamental problem which is that of the economy
00:18:27will change. So it's true that today the government, in
00:18:30addition to having its finances in the red, does not have,
00:18:34I remind you, an absolute majority in the National Assembly,
00:18:38so that's also extremely complicated. Moreover, we already see
00:18:41it on the budget for next year.
00:18:45We see that the benches of the hemicycle are deserted
00:18:48even though we are in the middle of
00:18:51the government's proposal has already been largely swept aside
00:18:55by the opposition. So that's a real problem, it's
00:18:59not only these finances but also this
00:19:02lack of a majority in the assembly with a
00:19:05president of the Republic who is the target of all the
00:19:09ills, all the problems, in any case that's what we
00:19:12can also see and hear from the opposition,
00:19:16of course, but also in these demonstrations. So it's true that
00:19:19there's the impression that the government is at a dead end, but once again,
00:19:23the next president of the Republic or the next female president of the
00:19:27Republic uh what
00:19:30more can she do? Because public
00:19:34finances won't just improve overnight, unless we erase the debt, but that's
00:19:38another subject uh the
00:19:41position of Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Jean-Luc Mélenchon's position, absolutely.
00:19:45Uh, well, it's true that we can tell ourselves that it can last, and then
00:19:49moreover, to come back to the high school students, we see that today the movement is still
00:19:52quite politicized, very structured, very organized, and they have
00:19:56a capacity for mobilization in the long term because, well, quite
00:19:59simply, they don't lose days of salary when they
00:20:03mobilize or strike. So that can, unlike
00:20:06employees. Uh, you wanted to react, Emmanuel? Yes, on the
00:20:10continuation of the movement, we can still make several hypotheses,
00:20:14and uh well, the mobilization this morning is still less strong than it was before
00:20:17the holidays, that is to say there is a reality that has not disappeared
00:20:20on Parcoursup. The point of view
00:20:24we can have when we work on the perception
00:20:27of young people is a little different from the point of view of university
00:20:31efficiency. We conducted a survey
00:20:33recently for the agricultural grid, well, a survey
00:20:37that was conducted both by the Cluster 17 institute and the Grand
00:20:41Public agency on young people, there were 300 young people interviewed. The first adjective that
00:20:44young people used to describe themselves was stressed, before
00:20:48supportive, committed, stressed.
00:20:54Young people aged 15 to 17 said they were stressed. There is a
00:20:58small subject on this regarding Parcoursup and the way in which
00:21:02school results from the first year give the feeling that one's future is being
00:21:05decided. But the consequence of that is that, well, high school students
00:21:09today are also asking themselves a little about what their absence
00:21:13of grades is becoming, what is happening in the blocked establishments compared to
00:21:16establishments that continue to function with grades, knowing well
00:21:27but that Saturdays remain days of mobilization precisely because
00:21:30Saturdays do not cause a loss of class days, do not cause a loss of salary, a
00:21:34little like the yellow vests and which had gradually
00:21:37faded away as time passed.
00:21:41So I think the most probable scenario is still that
00:21:45after the holidays there won't be much left of these Saturday
00:21:48mobilizations, but that's not to say that nothing will remain at all, quite the
00:21:51contrary to all the anxieties that are being expressed. Yes, yes, Jean
00:21:55Guerri, yes, what in reality, what
00:21:58interests me if we zoom out a little bit, so I Parcoursup there also
00:22:01I understand the perception that exists today, but
00:22:05the previous systems were much more stressful in reality, and
00:22:09for years, high school and student organizations had been
00:22:12specifically asking for a system like Parcoursup. So it was
00:22:16badly handled, badly
00:22:19handled, etc., and that's what generates stress, we
00:22:23agree, but to get back to the essential,
00:22:26what's sad, I mean, is that what high school
00:22:30students and students are raising today
00:22:33is this concern about the future. It
00:22:36should precisely give the opportunity, since there's a
00:22:39presidential election, for a big debate, particularly on
00:22:43our education system that doesn't work,
00:22:46on this social elevator that's blocked, etc.
00:22:50And what we see, the very structure of these
00:22:54demonstrations, the polarization on issues of
00:22:57law enforcement, violence, and
00:23:00the essentialization of opponents, the polarization of
00:23:03debates, etcetera, etcetera, means that
00:23:06we are missing out on a major debate. So what you're saying
00:23:09is that this high school movement could have imposed the theme of the
00:23:13presidential election,
00:23:17access to education. And in
00:23:20reality, having slipped in some places into
00:23:26chaos, as some even say,
00:23:28what it could have generated as a public debate
00:23:32is not happening. Yes, and not only that, but
00:23:36also the fact of trying to
00:23:39reduce the movement to a few
00:23:42demands that are legitimate,
00:23:45by the way, I think that it would deserve much more. In any
00:23:48case, it would deserve to be taken up by the presidential
00:23:52candidates, and the fact is that for
00:23:55now, only France Insoumise is really
00:23:58present in the discussions about this
00:24:02problem. But does France Insoumise really have something, and here I
00:24:05turn to you, Flore, does it emerge as
00:24:09a winner from this sequence in terms of voting
00:24:13intentions? In any case, if we look at the polls,
00:24:16it's the first political party/movement that
00:24:20attracts 18-24 year olds, around 40%. High school students don't have the right to vote,
00:24:23should we remind them? Yes, but well, 18-24 year olds, after all, there are also students,
00:24:27etc., so for young people, yes. But then again, these young people also have to turn out, because these
00:24:31are voting intentions, but it's not a segment of the population that
00:24:35votes a lot. Jean-Luc Mélenchon
00:24:39and France Insoumise in general, it's true that we saw them from the start
00:24:42on the blockades, then we see them in all the
00:24:45demonstrations, they are indeed, they want to be
00:24:49uh, not only the embodiment of this high school
00:24:52movement, but also the political outcome. So, once again,
00:24:56with the fact that some don't vote yet, and
00:24:59that it's not a segment of the population that turns out much, but nevertheless, they want to bring
00:25:03young people with them. Uh, just a quick word, what
00:25:07we also see in these mobilizations is that there's
00:25:10also, I think,
00:25:12a reality, which is that the National Rally is currently
00:25:16leading in voting intentions in the first round, and...
00:25:20Marine Le Pen is winning in all voting intentions for the second
00:25:23round, and we see that these are young people mobilizing, but
00:25:27not only them, and we also see on the placards and in the
00:25:31demands a kind of awareness that they don't want
00:25:34these people who are demonstrating to refuse the National
00:25:37Rally at the Élysée. So on that too, France
00:25:41Insoumise, which is with the National Rally, also
00:25:44has its card to play, if you will, in this
00:25:48mobilization where we see that the National Rally could
00:25:52access the Élysée. Does Jean-Luc Mélenchon see
00:25:55in this social anger
00:25:58a way to inflate the votes, let's say?
00:26:03To increase voting intentions in his favor for a potential
00:26:07second round in the presidential election? Very clearly, I think France Insoumise must
00:26:10see the confirmation of part of its winning
00:26:14scenario. In their minds, there is an electorate to conquer, which is an
00:26:18abstentionist electorate that they have called the
00:26:224th bloc, and which relies heavily on the mobilization
00:26:25of young people. So I think that could be
00:26:28part of the possible scenarios, that this presidential
00:26:32election corrects a bit, well, it's always the case for presidential
00:26:36elections, elections with high mobilization, always a differential in
00:26:39participation among young people, it could perhaps be attenuated precisely in
00:26:43the wake of this movement. After that, is that enough
00:26:46to allow Jean-Luc Mélenchon to be well positioned? I
00:26:50think he has both, they have been able to capitalize on the fact of being
00:26:53effectively the only political movement that gives the feeling of offering a
00:26:57political outlet to this movement, but from a mathematical
00:27:00point of view, it has its advantages and disadvantages. Yes, and above all, in fact,
00:27:04the events of October 17th also accentuated a form of
00:27:08polarization, reinforcing the opposing camp, rather the
00:27:12camp of Marine Le Pen, that there are disorders that need to be addressed,
00:27:15but what is quite striking is that between
00:27:19these two, no one seemed to grasp what was happening
00:27:23and offer a response. We will come back to the center,
00:27:27indeed, in any case, those who are between France Insoumise and the
00:27:30National Rally, how should we call them? The National
00:27:34Rally. Jean-Garrigues, who for a month now has been
00:27:37doing a kind of balancing act between his voters
00:27:41concerned about security and those who contest their living
00:27:45conditions, who are sometimes the same. The demonstrators of
00:27:49the weekend sometimes being the parents of the high school students. There is a
00:27:52symbiosis to be made in the discourse. Has the crest been
00:27:56found by the party leadership? I
00:27:59well, it's perhaps too early to say, but... Apparently yes, since
00:28:03we don't see a priori a decline
00:28:07in voting intentions in favor of Marine Le Pen, and
00:28:11in fact, the soup remains good, I mean
00:28:14that the quite intelligently,
00:28:18by the way, with a certain political sense, the
00:28:21National Rally plays the card first of all of order,
00:28:25of the failing
00:28:27state to position itself well as an opponent of
00:28:31Macronism. But above all, to position itself well as
00:28:35the opponent of France Insoumise, and ultimately it's
00:28:37that, it's a game, it's a rather perverse game in fact
00:28:41between the two extremes, one embodying the
00:28:45party of order, the other the party of the street, and
00:28:48ultimately the French today are, French public
00:28:51opinion through the media is
00:28:54prisoner of this confrontation, this
00:28:58bipolarity, this brutalization of political
00:29:01relations. And that's why those who
00:29:05are between the two are inaudible because
00:29:08we have gotten used to this form of polarization and that, quite
00:29:12skilfully, both Jean-Luc Mélenchon effectively
00:29:17revolt and the social movement, the National
00:29:21Rally on the side of order, and we see that 80%
00:29:25of French people were in favor of the demonstrations stopping,
00:29:29that they were against obviously all the...
00:29:32manifestations of looting or other
00:29:35violence, and on that, it's Marine Le Pen
00:29:38who capitalizes, and so we are, I repeat, in this perverse
00:29:42game where we don't see how the
00:29:45central bloc, ranging from Raphaël Glucksmann to
00:29:49David Lisnard, can really
00:29:51extricate themselves. It's up to them to be
00:29:55much more present in the fundamental debate, in the truly
00:29:58political debate, but it's also true that to
00:30:02their... disadvantage, how can I put it, the media
00:30:06coverage of what's happening inevitably focuses
00:30:09on events of demonstrations or
00:30:13violence, and we tend to forget the intellectual debate, the
00:30:17political debate on the issues, and that's why
00:30:21we still see quite little, but it's true that it's
00:30:24surprising nonetheless, it's surprisingly inaudible, Flore.
00:30:27Raphaël Glucksmann, Bruno Retailleau, Edouard
00:30:31Philippe, whom we heard yesterday, who talked more about his
00:30:37the possibility of organizing a center-right primary than
00:30:40about the core of the problem. Also inaudible, Bruno Retailleau.
00:30:44But you just said it, exactly, Edouard Philippe and Raphaël Glucksmann, and
00:30:48it's rather, sorry, Philippe and Gabriel Attal, it's rather, well, they're a bit
00:30:52in a race against each other to
00:30:56the