Google Cloud Speech-to-Text API (Chirp) + Gemini 2.5 Flash Non-Thinking. Treat it as a searchable index of what was broadcast, not a quotation record.
00:00:05him that he would not be able
00:00:25We expected to leave
00:00:25or a state of chaos may occur
00:00:27alternative to Netanyahu's government, the camp, no matter what, there were incursions in the camp.
00:00:39and also to stop
00:00:41clear that this From one area to another, from one area to another, you know, this is death, not a normal death that we are experiencing.
00:00:47or those whose recognition has been revoked
00:00:50hand, he believes that with such
00:01:06Iran and thus pressuring
00:01:11on relying on a coalition. There is, of course, a friend
00:01:23then, will they form a government Good times to you, this is a new outlook from today's file. Netanyahu or those who oppose
00:01:27Netanyahu, neither of them was able to obtain the majority
00:01:30that would allow either to comfortably form a government
00:01:34and without talking about more possibilities
00:01:39many alternatives. There and scenarios. The task is not easy, whether
00:01:42for Netanyahu if he wants to form the government, or for Eisenkot and
00:01:45his allies if they want to form the government. But neither
00:01:49of them finds it impossible
00:01:51a government with the support of some to do so. government under his leadership, or It is not enough to get
00:01:55with our people in the interior 61 seats to form
00:01:59deepened this rift, the government, just as and the possibility of his continuation in getting less than that does not mean that you will not succeed in
00:02:03you prefer, forming it anyway. Because the truth is, on Israeli President
00:02:06in such a way that Herzog will meet with representatives of the blocs in
00:02:09the Knesset to begin his consultations
00:02:12and negotiations in an effort to choose who
00:02:17I mean, at will be tasked with forming this new Israeli government. Some say that
00:02:22of Arab votes and votes from Netanyahu may go towards a strike on Iran in order to mix
00:02:26the cards on the political scene
00:02:28your question may be related to and force his opponents to be with him. In a government called
00:02:31a unity government, then it ends with rotation, he
00:02:34has two years and his allies have two
00:02:37other years. There are
00:02:40to elections. I think that accusations against Netanyahu that he is seeking to drag Israel into more
00:02:45was preceded by a coup in the media, in confrontations in order to remain in the Israeli political
00:02:47arena. As for Netanyahu's opponents,
00:02:50there are theories that they may disagree,
00:02:54especially if we look at Lieberman. Lieberman does not want to
00:02:58government, even if it succeeds sit with Arabs and does not want to sit with the religious Jews. Eisenkot himself
00:03:02set four conditions for anyone who wants to be with him in
00:03:06or indirect support from the government. All Israeli leaders say that they do not
00:03:09want Arabs, but rather incited against them and accused them
00:03:12of many accusations. The list
00:03:16is wide enough to accommodate them. We will try with you in this look to
00:03:20the religious parties answer some of the questions and read
00:03:23the scenarios before those who want to form the next
00:03:26Israeli government. The answer will be to
00:03:31plead guilty and receive our questions and yours, accompanied by Professor As'ad Ghanem, Professor
00:03:33of Political Science at the University of Haifa, joining us via Zoom. Professor
00:03:37As'ad, welcome to this episode of today's file.
00:03:41Thank you, thank you for the invitation. What does it mean when the Israeli
00:03:45and therefore Gantz's chances President tells the representatives of the blocs or
00:03:48parties that they must be rational and put aside
00:03:52their personal calculations, and that
00:03:54Israel will not tolerate calling for new
00:03:58elections? What does that mean?
00:04:02First of all, the President, in his position as
00:04:05the leader of the state or the head of the state, officially
00:04:08and generally tends to
00:04:12will be formed with external support create a state of political
00:04:14from the religious parties, or at consensus. This, of course, happened historically
00:04:16when there was no possibility of forming
00:04:20a government by one
00:04:22citizens, in order to delegitimize of the parties. This happened in 1988,
00:04:24and it happened on
00:04:28occasions when Israel
00:04:30coup and return was in a state of military confrontation in
00:04:331967. But generally,
00:04:36it is very clear that Israeli society is divided, and very
00:04:39divided. There are fears that the election
00:04:44the Israeli opposition is aligning results will lead to an increase in Israeli division and to an increase in the inability to manage
00:04:47social, political,
00:04:52getting such and administrative affairs within Israeli
00:04:54society. Therefore, from his position as head of state, he
00:04:58directs such a call. Of course,
00:05:02this call is not binding on anyone, and it is
00:05:05only for protocol reasons. It is very clear
00:05:09in order to enter that such a call may be
00:05:13an attempt to save Benjamin Netanyahu, and there are theories
00:05:16that, at least, have begun to be discussed, that there was a tacit agreement
00:05:20that was not known before
00:05:22years ago between President Herzog and
00:05:26the Israeli Prime Minister. Of course, no one knows about this
00:05:30matter, and perhaps no one will ever know
00:05:33about its contents, but there is an accusation that Herzog is trying to save
00:05:37Benjamin Netanyahu. He could have, of course, gone out to the media
00:05:40and said that there are 67
00:05:42members of the Knesset against 53, and there is a possibility to resolve
00:05:46the matter. Of course, the complications, as
00:05:49you mentioned in the introduction, are very great, but it is very
00:05:54president, perhaps his motives
00:05:57are indeed to save Benjamin Netanyahu, but on the other
00:06:03a call, he is trying to direct a call to Israelis
00:06:06that national unity must be preserved and the internal situation in
00:06:10light of a state of political fragmentation
00:06:12to a large extent unprecedented, may not be for ideological reasons
00:06:16or for reasons related to resolving the Palestinian-Israeli
00:06:19conflict, but it is certainly related to internal
00:06:23issues within Israeli society. Well, let's start with Netanyahu. What
00:06:26are the options now before Netanyahu, because we don't know who the Israeli
00:06:30president will task with forming the government. We
00:06:34are waiting after his consultations with the Israeli blocs end on Wednesday.
00:06:37A general reading
00:06:40for Netanyahu. What are Netanyahu's options based on the announced
00:06:43results so far? Of course,
00:06:46based on the election results, we can expect
00:06:51was a belief for three years or even more,
00:06:54since the beginning of the judicial coup in Israel, that
00:06:58Netanyahu had finished his political career,
00:07:01ended his political role, and would
00:07:04be easily overcome.
00:07:08My opinion has always been that Benjamin Netanyahu represents a consensus
00:07:11within Israeli society and that he has profoundly
00:07:14changed Israeli society
00:07:18it is too early to say definitively
00:07:22and conclusively that Benjamin Netanyahu
00:07:25has ended his term. We remember that Benjamin
00:07:29Netanyahu defeated Shimon Peres in
00:07:311996 by a small margin, but it was a margin
00:07:35that led to his ascension to the premiership against,
00:07:38as they say, the "elder statesman" Shimon Peres. Benjamin
00:07:42Netanyahu also defeated Tzipi Livni in 2009 upon
00:07:45his return from political wilderness and began
00:07:49the project of changing Israel. I mean, when
00:07:52we talk about the judicial coup in Israel, this coup
00:07:57universities, in political culture to a large
00:08:01extent in political action.
00:08:05This means that even the religious who in the past were willing
00:08:09to maneuver between the Labor Party and the Likud,
00:08:12now they are all in favor of Benjamin Netanyahu. I mean, the Haredim
00:08:16and the Shas parties and the religious parties,
00:08:20the so-called national Mafdal
00:08:22previously. Therefore, we are facing a radical change. This
00:08:26is something we must think about. I mean, all of us, of course, and thank you for allowing
00:08:29this field, that there is a radical change within
00:08:33Israeli society. The possibility of removing Benjamin Netanyahu may be possible
00:08:37as a person, but Benjamin Netanyahu's project, the project of controlling
00:08:40historical Palestine, a project to change Israel towards a more conservative
00:08:44and more right-wing society, has largely succeeded.
00:08:48The effects that Benjamin Netanyahu leaves behind, Israel
00:08:51may be able to deal with them, but that will require many
00:08:54years in order to return.
00:08:57We will talk about our expectations for what will happen to Israel if
00:09:01Netanyahu leaves, but what are the options
00:09:05for Netanyahu now, in case he is tasked
00:09:09by Herzog to form the government or not tasked with it?
00:09:13What is the available space for Netanyahu now? On election
00:09:16day, Benjamin Netanyahu began a wide incitement campaign. Of course, it has
00:09:20been building up over all Netanyahu's years, but this time it took
00:09:24a large turn, so it is said that he
00:09:27published about, let's say, 200 tweets during election day,
00:09:31half of them against Arab
00:09:34Arab citizens. When the election results
00:09:38were published, it was clear that Benjamin Netanyahu would seek to
00:09:41undermine the legitimacy of Arab citizens and undermine their political
00:09:45power so that they would not be partners, and this is the only way Benjamin Netanyahu
00:09:49can prevent an opposition government.
00:09:53But of course, and unfortunately,
00:09:56with this position in the vast majority. I mean, there is a difference, but the vast
00:09:59majority of Benjamin Netanyahu's allies now,
00:10:02if he is tasked by the president, I believe that he will
00:10:06first seek to strengthen
00:10:08the bases of the current or supporting
00:10:12currents for him. There are voices in their limits now in the last
00:10:15two days saying that they are willing to consider alternatives to Netanyahu. I do not
00:10:19believe that this is true because, in the end, the religious
00:10:22parties also respond to the voice of the street
00:10:25that supports them, and the religious Israeli street
00:10:29is the most right-wing and most racist. Therefore,
00:10:32Benjamin Netanyahu is the fundamental solution for
00:10:35them. Therefore, when Benjamin Netanyahu says, or if
00:10:39he is given the opportunity to form a government,
00:10:42he will strengthen his supporting bases. He will seek to
00:10:46split some Knesset members from the parties
00:10:49that are now called the opposition. We do not
00:10:52know who the Knesset members are, for example, from the
00:10:56party. I mean,
00:10:59Benjamin Netanyahu may be able to split a part of it, not
00:11:03necessarily split them as a bloc, because there is a condition that one-third
00:11:06of the bloc must be willing to split, but he
00:11:10can convince some to vote alongside him or abstain on
00:11:14voting day on the pretext that a government cannot
00:11:17be formed with Arab support. So this is the first
00:11:21or at least the second possibility. The third possibility is to go to a national
00:11:24unity government. You mentioned in the introduction the issue
00:11:28of instigating a major war with
00:11:31the Israeli opposition to enter
00:11:35in the United States who is tweeting
00:11:38for the formation of a national unity government in Israel. There is
00:11:41a president in Israel who says that, and there is, of course, popular
00:11:45support for the idea of unity. I mean, there is always a tendency for such
00:11:48sayings, and therefore this is also a possibility for
00:11:52Benjamin Netanyahu. It is an issue, I mean, or the end
00:11:55of his political life, or the continuation of his political life. Therefore,
00:11:59the continued promotion of the idea of the illegitimacy of Arab
00:12:02citizens in order to prevent the formation of any alternative
00:12:06government is the main path for Benjamin Netanyahu
00:12:09to enter or to be able to form a minority
00:12:16opposition members, or to go to a national unity
00:12:19government. All of these, in my personal opinion, will represent
00:12:23a victory for Benjamin Netanyahu.
00:12:26paper, the possibility is slim, but
00:12:29unfortunately, opposition parties, and some of them at least, Lieberman
00:12:33and some members of Eisenkot's party, may
00:12:36be opponents, or they may continue on the path
00:12:40that denies the possibility of forming a government with Arab support,
00:12:44and therefore they may facilitate Benjamin Netanyahu's
00:12:47task to remain in power.
00:12:50Of course, we hope that something else will happen,
00:12:54but we will see what will happen. Well, we will talk about Eisenkot and
00:12:58his allies and his four conditions, but now the other option or the other
00:13:02possibility, if Netanyahu
00:13:04does not have the ability to form
00:13:07the government, what are his options?
00:13:10He will remain acting prime minister until the next government is formed,
00:13:14but after that, there are many questions. Can we speed
00:13:18that up from his trials? What
00:13:21options does he have?
00:13:24There is always a possibility in the Israeli
00:13:27government of not forming a government and going to early
00:13:31elections. All opinions agree that any early
00:13:34elections will lead to a big victory for Benjamin Netanyahu because the opposition
00:13:38and the Palestinian masses inside put all their weight
00:13:42in the last election battle and got 67
00:13:45seats. There are ideas that Benjamin Netanyahu
00:13:49may prepare himself better, and we are talking about a previous
00:13:52experience, even in 2021,
00:13:56elections were held every six months for three times, and in the end, the process
00:14:00elected Benjamin Netanyahu. Therefore, this is also a possibility,
00:14:03and it is a possibility that may allow him to remain
00:14:06in power for several months and go
00:14:09to elections as prime minister in
00:14:13Israel. Now, if a minority government is formed, as Eisenkot
00:14:17is now promising, he is declaring today that he will go to
00:14:21a minority government, perhaps with the abstention of one of the religious
00:14:24parties, the abstention of the candidates or
00:14:28Arab members of the Knesset, perhaps with limited support from the United
00:14:31Arab List, that he will go for such an option. In
00:14:35such an option, there are two clear possibilities for
00:14:38Benjamin Netanyahu, or that the formed government
00:14:42will indeed thwart all Benjamin Netanyahu's plans
00:14:46and form an investigation committee into the so-called October 7th
00:14:4923rd failure and invalidate all laws that
00:14:52relate to the judicial
00:14:55to, I mean, at least, a dialogue
00:14:59with Arab citizens in a better way or different from the previous
00:15:02government, Benjamin Netanyahu's current government. This may send
00:15:06Netanyahu to opposition and thus perhaps exclude
00:15:09him from political life, and of course, with the hope that
00:15:13the opposition parties will seek to enact a law that prevents anyone who is accused
00:15:17of bribery or corruption or is under investigation
00:15:20from running for prime minister. This is
00:15:24a possibility. The other possibility is that Benjamin Netanyahu
00:15:27builds his calculations on the fact that any government supported
00:15:30by Arabs will not be a stable government, and be assured that
00:15:34he will begin, the day after the formation or the thought of forming
00:15:37any government with the support of Arab
00:15:40parties, an incitement campaign, I mean, much greater
00:15:44than the current situation, and the current situation is very dangerous.
00:15:48The elections showed that Benjamin Netanyahu
00:15:52raised the level of incitement against Arab citizens in an unprecedented
00:15:55way, and there is even a state of fear among Arab citizens
00:15:59that there may be a state of chaos
00:16:03at the popular level and at the level of the security establishment,
00:16:06especially the police which, of course, Ben Gvir
00:16:10heads. So he builds on the possibility of weakening, of
00:16:14seeking to weaken any government that is formed by continuing
00:16:18his incitement against Arab citizens and their representatives in the Knesset
00:16:21and perhaps forcing the government to quickly disband
00:16:24and quickly go
00:16:27to early elections
00:16:31in Israel. So I at least
00:16:34believe that the saying that there is
00:16:38a definitive and clear opportunity to end Benjamin
00:16:42Netanyahu and his legacy and his rule is
00:16:45premature. We must wait, and I hope, of course, that this
00:16:48is what will happen, but so far, as
00:16:52we know, strong opposition voices, very
00:16:55strong, still say that we cannot rely on Arab votes. How,
00:17:00without relying on those votes? But Professor, many, many
00:17:04Israeli leaders or party leaders say one thing before
00:17:07the elections and another thing after the elections. I will give
00:17:10you an example. Netanyahu in past years described
00:17:13our people in the interior as partners and as successful
00:17:17and praised
00:17:20them. He allied
00:17:23with this or that one of them, but now he attacks
00:17:26them and hurls all accusations at them.
00:17:29Whoever says that he will not sit
00:17:32before the elections may sit with them
00:17:35after the election results are announced. Well, do
00:17:41at least, I am sure that the Arab
00:17:44parties will not gamble on the possibility
00:17:47of negotiating with Benjamin Netanyahu or giving him a safety
00:17:51net in any way due to his role in the massacres that happened
00:17:55during the last years and from the escalation, including
00:17:58the escalation against Arab citizens.
00:18:00The issue relates, I mean,
00:18:06the Israeli opposition. This is something possible, and I believe
00:18:10that we rely on
00:18:13that as Palestinians inside, that the way of
00:18:17dealing from the opposition will change, especially since the opposition has understood
00:18:20now that the Arab vote is almost one-third.
00:18:24Why do I say a little less than one-third of the opposition's
00:18:27votes in Israel or the alternative to Benjamin Netanyahu? It is not possible
00:18:31to form a government, I mean, at least a stable
00:18:36in the opposition in forming it,
00:18:40without, I mean, direct
00:18:43the Arab parties. The Arab parties, especially
00:18:46the Joint List, of course, have conditions,
00:18:50but they fully realize that we are facing a test
00:18:53to remove Benjamin Netanyahu. This
00:18:55is what is required, and that is why people came out to the streets. Well, before
00:18:59I elaborate more on the options of others, Professor,
00:19:03what about the possibility that Netanyahu will
00:19:08a pardon and leave political life? Is
00:19:12this a viable option in your opinion?
00:19:15Definitely, I mean, I think some analysts
00:19:19indicate the possibility that the President of the State, and perhaps
00:19:23with the participation of Trump, the American President, may propose such
00:19:26a scenario, whereby Benjamin Netanyahu is tasked with forming a national
00:19:29unity government for two years, and after that, I mean,
00:19:33the issue of reaching a deal with the Israeli
00:19:36prosecution. This is certainly possible, and this
00:19:39is being proposed, and the Israeli opposition believes
00:19:43that this is one of the ways to get rid of Benjamin
00:19:45Netanyahu, and perhaps this will facilitate the formation
00:19:49of a government in partnership between the Likud, Eisenkot, and the Jewish
00:19:53parties, as it is now. Even
00:19:56now, the opposition still adheres to canceling the so-called
00:20:00judicial coup or Benjamin Netanyahu's project. There is no disagreement about
00:20:04the Palestinian issue at all, nor about the genocide, nor about
00:20:08dealing with the Arab region. All of these were issues that were
00:20:11largely agreed upon.
00:20:14On the other hand, we must
00:20:17realize that, I mean, Benjamin Netanyahu also put
00:20:21in options, I mean, that may force him, to some
00:20:25extent, to reconsider the possibility of actually
00:20:29a pardon that you mentioned in the question
00:20:33and thus ending his political career and going to a symbolic
00:20:36position. Some talk about the possibility of him being nominated for the presidency
00:20:40of the state or something similar. So far, it does not seem
00:20:44that Benjamin Netanyahu can bet on this, but if the space narrows
00:20:47and it was clear that he would not be able to form
00:20:51a government, and it was clear to
00:20:55to continue in power for reasons related to the election
00:20:59results, but also reasons related
00:21:02to, I mean, the support or position
00:21:05of the deep state, I mean, the deep state institutions in
00:21:08Israel, the courts, the army, and academic
00:21:11institutions, there may be a proposal
00:21:14that Benjamin Netanyahu leaves the scene by obtaining
00:21:18a pardon or an arrangement
00:21:20that prevents him from going to prison, but to
00:21:23rid Israelis of this, of Benjamin
00:21:27Netanyahu's leadership. Well, this is regarding
00:21:30Benjamin Netanyahu. Now let's go to Netanyahu's
00:21:33opponents, who are all agreed
00:21:36on the necessity of getting rid of Netanyahu. What are the options
00:21:40before them? There is Lieberman's ambition, Lapid's
00:21:43ambition, Naftali Bennett's, and also
00:21:47Eisenkot set four conditions. He
00:21:50wants to disarm, or what is called disarming, Gaza, the issue of
00:21:54the judicial coup, the issue of mandatory military
00:21:56service, and he puts a big veto
00:22:01Arab parties, meaning
00:22:04the Joint List and the United List. What
00:22:07is Eisenkot's room for maneuver according to the announced
00:22:10numbers? I mean, at least
00:22:13there is an expectation or thinking that Eisenkot will not
00:22:17repeat the mistakes of Gantz or Tzipi Livni. I mean, in
00:22:212009, there was a possibility of forming a government
00:22:24led by Tzipi Livni, but she
00:22:27refused to cooperate with the Arab parties. In
00:22:302015, Gantz was qualified to form a government with the support of the Arab
00:22:33parties, the Joint List at that time, but he refused.
00:22:37This time, I think that the internal dilemma within Israeli
00:22:41society, I mean, the discussion about Benjamin Netanyahu and his personality
00:22:45power, perhaps
00:22:49and this rift, which relates to Benjamin Netanyahu's personality and the continuation
00:22:52of his rule, may lead to different
00:22:55thinking among Eisenkot. At least, there is a bet on such a matter.
00:22:59If this happens and Eisenkot has the level
00:23:02of courage that qualifies him to form
00:23:05a government, least
00:23:09a minority government with the support
00:23:12the Haredim, this is a possibility I think that attention
00:23:16is now turning to, and there is great pressure on Eisenkot to go
00:23:20for such a thing. Always, of course, there are other alternatives. There
00:23:23is an alternative, as we mentioned, just as Benjamin
00:23:27Netanyahu has the alternative of going
00:23:30Eisenkot will not risk such an alternative. There is a possibility
00:23:34of going to a national unity government. So far, Eisenkot has announced that he will not
00:23:37sit with Netanyahu in the same government.
00:23:40I hope that this is true. Are there partners
00:23:43with Eisenkot who could facilitate
00:23:47things for Benjamin Netanyahu? I think that is possible, and that may
00:23:50put Eisenkot in a difficult position. Well,
00:23:54Professor As'ad, some say that Eisenkot will try to convince
00:23:57Shas and United Torah Judaism to join
00:24:00him, despite Lieberman's opposition, and
00:24:03observers also say that he will seek to convince Lieberman
00:24:07to accept
00:24:10in the government, but he will not be able to convince
00:24:14him to share power with our people in the interior,
00:24:16and we are talking here about the Joint List and the United List.
00:24:28This puts, I mean, the possibilities, or of course, and he will not sit with
00:24:32the religious,
00:24:35in this situation are slim. There is a possibility of bypassing
00:24:38Lieberman. Definitely, there is a possibility if Shas
00:24:42and United Torah Judaism support a minority government
00:24:46or a government led by Eisenkot, he may be able to bypass
00:24:49Lieberman to go to a government supported
00:24:51by Arab votes, and thus pave the way
00:24:55for Lieberman to enter at a later stage.
00:24:57And there is, of course, a scenario that a minority government
00:25:04least from the United Torah Judaism party,
00:25:07and with the support of the Arab parties, in the hope that United
00:25:11Torah Judaism will receive assurances that there will be no
00:25:14major change in the issue of conscription and instead of insisting
00:25:18on conscripting the religious, to give more, I mean,
00:25:21benefits to conscripts
00:25:24by giving them job opportunities or financial support
00:25:28or other possibilities.
00:25:31Therefore, this possibility seems plausible
00:25:34now, especially since at the end, I mean, a few
00:25:37months ago, there was great criticism
00:25:41among important rabbis in United Torah Judaism against Benjamin
00:25:44Netanyahu due to his so-called lack of commitment on the issue
00:25:47of conscripting the religious.
00:25:50Therefore, this matter is possible and likely,
00:25:54and I believe that it may be an exit for Eisenkot, at least
00:25:59the Knesset presidency and make some changes.
00:26:03Some changes within the Knesset, and thus go to
00:26:06a minority government and pass some laws that invalidate what
00:26:10was changed through the judicial coup. This matter
00:26:14is possible. I believe that the Arab parties could support this.
00:26:17There are, of course, historically, contacts. This is what
00:26:20the Joint List clearly and explicitly announced,
00:26:23that it will not enter any coalition, but it said that
00:26:27it might support any government
00:26:30and the support would come from outside
00:26:33in exchange for, of course, demands,
00:26:36the most prominent of which is to eliminate racism in dealing
00:26:39with and combating crime,
00:26:42demolition operations in the Negev and the Judaization of the Galilee,
00:26:45and also to recognize the unrecognized villages
00:26:49in the Negev. This leads us to ask you now,
00:26:53before we move away from Netanyahu, of course, is there
00:26:57any possibility for Netanyahu to succeed in convincing?