Google Cloud Speech-to-Text API (Chirp) + Gemini 2.5 Flash Non-Thinking. Treat it as a searchable index of what was broadcast, not a quotation record.
00:00:00Artificial intelligence is not only related to
00:00:04generative artificial intelligence that we all use today, almost like
00:00:07Chad GPT and Claude. No, there are
00:00:10digital media at the many more advanced things and there are robots
00:00:13on one side, there are things related to hardware, meaning like robots
00:00:17and other devices that are used in factories and so on.
00:00:20But what directly touches humans in the matter of ethics
00:00:24is generative artificial intelligence that
00:00:27we all use today, and I want to
00:00:29me is right or wrong. If I am an expert in mention something important. Most
00:00:32of the information that generative artificial intelligence
00:00:36feeds on is what we give it. Our
00:00:38use of it, we all upload photos
00:00:42Just for the question, 90% of and files and ask it to analyze or write, so it collects our data.
00:00:46tests, they don't go to And it is important, I mean, for listeners and viewers to pay attention to something, that
00:00:50when we log into any system or any program or any
00:00:54application, there are like 10 pages in small print that contain the terms
00:00:58of use.
00:01:03Ukraine, this happened in And the user agrees to share their data with everyone
00:01:07in the world. All these companies today collect data
00:01:10with our consent. So when we talk about the ethics of artificial
00:01:13if you put laws and legislations, no, there is indeed intelligence and the development that is taking place today, it is important that
00:01:17we know that part of providing personal
00:01:21information
00:01:23to generative artificial intelligence applications is through us.
00:01:27So we give it the authority to collect data for us,
00:01:30legislate. Maybe even for but also to use it
00:01:34in a fair, let's call it,
00:01:38transparent and honest way. Today's issue
00:01:41is on the table of all
00:01:43a certain case, or which governments, not just institutions and individuals. Many
00:01:46governments in the world have issued policies for the use
00:01:51And Ashtawl in of artificial intelligence or ethics in artificial intelligence in education,
00:01:55also in health, in many applications. I even
00:01:59saw that in many Arab countries, they worked with organizations
00:02:02like ALECSO and others, and they are working
00:02:06on the issue of a system or policy
00:02:09It was located on for ethics and the use
00:02:13of artificial intelligence in a
00:02:16be a policy in fair, transparent and just way. And the issue is constantly evolving, meaning every
00:02:25also, some major institutions in The issue of publishing on day they are developing it because it is branching out. So controlling the issue is not easy, not easy at all. Of course, you mentioned the issue of legislation
00:02:28that for the second time and laws. Of course, I have a broad question regarding that, especially since we
00:02:31are in the nature of our lives in Palestine and the occupation that
00:02:35surrounds us from everywhere, even in our freedom of expression or even in
00:02:38our use of artificial intelligence
00:02:41and its ethics. Indeed, I was watching
00:02:43a conversation with Bill Gates a while ago, and he said
00:02:47that if the tremendous development of artificial intelligence continues,
00:02:51then we are in big trouble. So we really need international
00:02:55legislation, not just for every country or every
00:02:58company or every institution, or
00:03:00decide what its environment. No, we need international legislation to be able to
00:03:04to upload to artificial intelligence tools. Everything on control what might happen in the future because its uses are expanding in a tremendous
00:03:08way. I mean, this issue, if we are to be honest with
00:03:11ourselves,
00:03:13from my point of view, and I participate in many regional
00:03:17and international conferences and we talk about the same topic, I believe
00:03:21that the issue has gotten out of control somewhat. It really
00:03:24needs government interventions,
00:03:27especially from governments that
00:03:30export
00:03:33matters, because today you open these services to others. I mean, you are talking about Palestine. We in
00:03:37Palestine are recipients of the service, users of the service. We are not
00:03:40working to create an application similar to ChatGPT.
00:03:44We use ChatGPT, we use Claude.
00:03:47Well, today, these are subject to American
00:03:50laws, for example, or Deep Mind, Chinese laws. Are
00:03:54there laws and legislations in China or America or in Europe to control them? Yes,
00:03:57there are, but what is the extent
00:04:01of the legislations regarding, for example,
00:04:05the bias? How does
00:04:06a lot, by the way, in this artificial intelligence view the question? Let me give an example
00:04:09to clarify the matter. Today, if
00:04:12you ask, you get an email. The simplest thing is you get
00:04:16an email from a specific person. If you put it on
00:04:19Copilot or on ChatGPT and tell it, "I don't
00:04:22like this email, reply to it with a certain reply," it will
00:04:26a secure digital future does tell you, "Yes, this email is not good," and it will reply to it with a bad reply.
00:04:29Hmm, well, if you tell it, "This email is positive and I want you to reply to it
00:04:33positively," it will reply to it in a positive way. So it is what
00:04:36they call prompt engineering.
00:04:39awareness that keeps pace with You are in the engineering of directions that you direct the AI with, and it gives you the result.
00:04:43So it sometimes biases you as a user or gives you
00:04:47the information according to what is available to it. And our Arabic
00:04:50content and Palestinian content is very weak. It does not
00:04:54constitute one in perhaps a million. What, perhaps more, I mean, one in a million
00:04:57of the content available in the world. So we are recipients
00:05:01of the service. Legislation must be through the influential bodies
00:05:04already. 1000 now we have internal legislations. Let me give
00:05:08another example, but it might be difficult to control it. I mean, I find that we might
00:05:12legislate and set laws, but
00:05:15their application might not be easy. I agree with you 100%, and I always like
00:05:19to give examples. If today we are working on legislations,
00:05:23laws, regulations, and policies related to education and higher
00:05:26education, and there was a conference a few days ago discussing the topic. Uh-huh.
00:05:30Well, today we say do not use something
00:05:33that has copyright. Well, when I just go to ChatGPT, it gives me the default, whether
00:05:37it has copyright or not. So what am I supposed to do today? How can I control
00:05:41a teacher? How can he create educational content for his students?
00:05:45Correct. The issues are very complex to the point that we might reach a stage
00:05:48where the policy is at the institutional level, the policy
00:05:52of ethical use might be at the individual
00:05:54level. I mean, it is true that we have a government in every country trying
00:05:58to make legislations and trying to make policies and trying to control
00:06:02some uses, but many things are out of control,
00:06:05and today there are ways people bypass them. They use a VPN to another country.
00:06:09They get information from another source. So,
00:06:18this even serves the occupation, frankly, in this matter. I mean, let them remain lost, let them not know
00:06:22how to act. I mean, this, and even
00:06:26a way to bypass them, as you said, Professor. But I want to
00:06:29delve into a point that might be very important to young men and women.
00:06:32Now, we often see that artificial
00:06:35intelligence, as we said, analyzes huge data through us.
00:06:39We upload photos, we give our data through
00:06:42banks, through more than one institution,
00:06:45and we give it, it might in some way threaten our privacy
00:06:49in it. But how do we make the user
00:06:52actually know when to give the OK
00:06:55to this application to use my data and when
00:06:59not to? And in case I was subjected to a violation
00:07:02of my privacy and artificial intelligence used it against
00:07:06me in violation of ethics and human values, who will guarantee
00:07:09my right? Who is responsible then?
00:07:13In every country, there is a responsible
00:07:17authority that falls under the police. Uh-huh.
00:07:21And we have it in Palestine, fortunately. Any person who is subjected
00:07:24to any blackmail of any kind can go to cybercrimes,
00:07:28they can go to the specialized police departments,
00:07:32and they can complain. This is the positive side of the issue, but there is
00:07:35a negative side, which is
00:07:41in a row, I repeat it, we are the ones who provide it.
00:07:44Let me give an example. Once they said, "If you want to see what you look like when
00:07:48you are old, upload your picture and give it." It is said, according to
00:07:51statistics, that about
00:07:53150 million pictures were uploaded on the first
00:07:57day. Imagine how many might have reached a billion after three or four days. There was
00:08:01another trend, which is to take a picture with a person you lost. I mean, the whole world,
00:08:05frankly, this is one experiment. Look how many
00:08:09people in the world, if we are 8 billion today on Earth, maybe a billion.
00:08:12Maybe 2 billion people uploaded pictures of themselves
00:08:15and others, and many people upload their picture and enhance it
00:08:18and put it as a profile picture or something else. So we are the ones who provide it.
00:08:22It exists, but what is harder than that
00:08:25today is
00:08:28that it has become difficult to distinguish between reality
00:08:31and forgery. True. And here comes the role of media
00:08:35institutions, and we are proud of Palestine TV. We are here
00:08:38with you today to have awareness programs
00:08:42for citizens about these
00:08:46Facebook or Instagram or any social media
00:08:50application and you see a certain video.
00:08:53You can no longer tell if it is real or if it is artificial intelligence.
00:08:57And the degree of accuracy in it is very
00:08:59high, to the point that it has become convincing you that it is real. So here
00:09:03comes your role first as a user, what
00:09:06you give to artificial intelligence and its tools, what
00:09:09you give to social media, what you put in it. And if you are exposed to something,
00:09:12you have cybercrime departments available. You can resort to them and you can
00:09:16complain, and they will follow up and help matter.
00:09:20But the negative side is that controlling the issue is difficult because
00:09:24we are the ones who contribute to giving it information about us. Correct. And there are
00:09:27many other directions. I mean, it is no longer just pictures and videos, even
00:09:31the use of your voice. It is possible to produce
00:09:35strange and wonderful things, and people will not be able to tell the difference.
00:09:38I want to talk about an experience less than a week old. I saw
00:09:42twice two composite videos of
00:09:45officials with their real voices. I mean, they were talking about something, so I
00:09:49wondered, "Is it possible?" And I was listening,
00:09:52and fortunately, one of them was directly related to me, so I called
00:09:56him and asked him, "What is this video that was released for you?" He said, "What video?" I sent
00:10:00it to him, and he said, "I know nothing about it at all."
00:10:03To the extent that his voice convinced me because I always listen,
00:10:06it convinced me that this is real. Well, here we are in a problem that it is really difficult
00:10:10for citizens to distinguish. Yes.
00:10:25The wrong and the right, and whether this was done within ethics or
00:10:29not. I mean, I will answer you. I will answer you with an answer I gave
00:10:32to my students when I taught
00:10:35Arab American University to master's students in digital
00:10:38media. I asked the same question in the lecture.
00:10:42My answer was: rely on reliable
00:10:45sources. I mean, today when I go to Palestine TV's
00:10:49website on Facebook, I am sure that the news is from Palestine TV,
00:10:52a reliable source. But when it comes to
00:10:55certain pages and certain people, I don't trust anyone. I like
00:10:59to see a reliable source from reliable media outlets
00:11:02for the news. Now, there are things that are not related to news, personal
00:11:06matters, other matters, creative matters, maybe yes, creative
00:11:09matters. Check the source and sometimes look at
00:11:13the comments on it and make sure that this is correct. And I want to give another
00:11:16example, I like examples. In the last
00:11:19war, there were many pictures and videos
00:11:23where you would find someone commenting and saying, "This picture is not real, this happened in
00:11:28such and such a place." But when you see it for the first time,
00:11:31you think the news is true. Correct, but
00:11:35this is all on the general media side, but what
00:11:39about individuals? Today, as you said, we have
00:11:43videos about individuals, voice forgery,
00:11:46image forgery. I think this issue has gotten
00:11:50out of control, but we really cannot, I mean,
00:11:55institutions themselves, or I mean, any
00:11:58officer can prevent you from using something
00:12:02for someone else, or that this file, as long as it doesn't concern you, you don't
00:12:05use it, or there are, for example, complex procedures to prevent
00:12:09it. Look, the direct answer for me is, as long as I
00:12:13use a certain application that is not
00:12:16under the control of the country I am in, then the matter
00:12:19is difficult. I mean, today we use all social
00:12:23media platforms for free. Right, true. We don't pay
00:12:26for them. Well, when I enter them and use them, I don't pay anything,
00:12:30and there are no controls, even if the state set certain controls, unless
00:12:34some countries prevent it. Some countries prevented it. The state said TikTok is forbidden
00:12:37for me. It banned TikTok for a certain reason. Now, can we prevent
00:12:41social media in our countries? Every country has
00:12:44its own privacy.
00:12:47social media or forgery, there are laws,
00:12:50and today we have the specialized body in cybercrime
00:12:53that has put in place legislations, and we have legislations, but the possibility
00:12:56of controlling them is difficult, unless you go... The possibility of prosecution might also be
00:13:00difficult. I mean, there are also forgeries on Facebook, many
00:13:04of them, even the numbers used are even outside the country, and you are not
00:13:08in the country. You are in the country and you got any number from abroad,
00:13:11and today with eSIM, I mean, they use fake numbers, and you get
00:13:15fake messages and from fake entities, so controlling it is difficult, and I
00:13:19believe that every person is careful about themselves and must
00:13:22take care of themselves and know what to do and what not to do, what
00:13:26to put on social media and what not to put on social media, or even what material
00:13:30to upload to artificial intelligence tools. Some
00:13:33people upload their secrets, some people upload their whole lives, they upload all
00:13:37their pictures, and he knows when he works
00:13:40on it, it says to him that your information can be shared with
00:13:43other parties. So as long as you accepted to upload it, you have to know that
00:13:46this information reached other parties, and here is the problem. I mean, here
00:13:50the awareness must be with the person. He is the one who will judge.
00:13:53I mean, let's go back to the point
00:14:03where it can take us. So we go back to the basic point
00:14:07that the thing is with us, not with the machine, just as I completely agree with you, but
00:14:11I want to add something to it. Awareness is important, but
00:14:15awareness does not come by itself. It needs awareness.
00:14:17And I call from this platform for there to be
00:14:21national awareness programs for students,
00:14:25for teachers, for university students. I mean, when a student
00:14:28goes to a university or a school, an orientation
00:14:31session should be held for them, and they should be told about how
00:14:35to use, how to use artificial intelligence tools.
00:14:38We should educate teachers, we should educate employees. I mean, awareness
00:14:42is very important. There are countries, and I see experiences where the state has implemented
00:14:46awareness programs for citizens, for students, for teachers,
00:14:50and for others, in order to have general awareness in the state,
00:14:54general community awareness, general awareness among people. It is not enough to
00:14:57say awareness is important. There must
00:15:00be national programs for awareness,
00:15:03especially since we are talking about something important, which is the ethics
00:15:07related to the use of artificial intelligence. A few
00:15:10days ago, I saw that someone committed suicide because
00:15:14he was talking to ChatGPT and they filed a lawsuit against OpenAI
00:15:17that it advised him to commit suicide. I don't know if
00:15:21people might have read about the topic. Some people
00:15:25no longer do anything without asking ChatGPT. They keep
00:15:28ChatGPT open and ask it, "Should I do this today or not? Do this, do that." Their whole
00:15:32life is on it. I even posted an article on my page
00:15:36called "Brain Rot." The brains and minds
00:15:39of people no longer think. They even no longer trust themselves. If they want
00:15:43to write a message or want to write a reply or want to do anything,
00:15:46they started to ask for ChatGPT's opinion and started
00:15:49to believe that ChatGPT's opinion is better than theirs, and they reply to it and go along
00:15:53with it as if it were the first and last decision for them. The last thing I want
00:15:56to mention in this context is that experience
00:15:59is important. I mean, I ask ChatGPT and it gives me a result, but
00:16:03it is also important to know if what it gave
00:16:06the field it gave me, I can judge it. The biggest disaster
00:16:10today is that people in matters they have no experience in, nor are
00:16:14they specialists, they ask the question and take the answer. Let me give an example.
00:16:19people today go to a laboratory, do medical
00:16:24the doctor. They put it on ChatGPT and see what medicines and start treating
00:16:27themselves. What you are doing is wrong. The doctor knows exactly what
00:16:31you need. Not everything it gives you, I mean, you upload this picture that the lab
00:16:35gave you, unless you are coming, by God, and he goes
00:16:38and prescribes medicine for himself. There is also a specialization. ChatGPT might give you certain
00:16:42instructions, but it is not your
00:16:46agree with you and add our voice to yours as well. Well, Professor,
00:16:49I mean, at the end of our discussion, if we want to set
00:16:52a set of basic rules that we must
00:16:56follow in our use of artificial
00:16:59intelligence, so that we can actually remain within ethics
00:17:02and protect ourselves and be able to confine ourselves
00:17:06to talk about not just protection, but also using it
00:17:10correctly. I mean, a set of rules,
00:17:12a set of behaviors that we can
00:17:15use, or to whom can we turn in
00:17:21pages can we follow in case we really find ourselves deeply
00:17:25immersed in AI, for example? I put it in three
00:17:28main points. The first main point is at the state level, the government
00:17:32level. There must be regulating
00:17:35legislations for the use of artificial intelligence in various
00:17:39sectors. Fortunately, we are working on it. Uh-huh. It must
00:17:42be applied, it must be implemented to protect the citizen.
00:17:45Number one. The other dimension and the other main point
00:17:49is the institutional main point. There must
00:17:54institutions for the use of artificial intelligence, the way
00:17:58artificial intelligence tools are used. And fortunately,
00:18:03the country today have started to adopt these policies. For example, it is forbidden
00:18:07to use certain materials or certain files
00:18:11or sensitive files or sensitive topics on artificial
00:18:14intelligence tools, and how to use them and how not to use them and when
00:18:18to use them. These directions are correct. And the third topic and the third main point
00:18:22is the citizen himself, the human being himself.
00:18:25You must be aware of what
00:18:29you use and what you don't use. You must watch awareness
00:18:33programs. Plus, you have to
00:18:38to put on social media, what
00:18:41social media, by the way, goes to artificial intelligence tools. You
00:18:45make sure that you know that any
00:18:48information you upload to these tools and platforms means
00:18:51it went to everyone. So you must be careful
00:18:55yourself not to upload any information you don't want people
00:18:58to know, because everything you upload, everyone
00:19:01will know. Correct. We thank you, Professor, today,
00:19:04you have enlightened us with insights. Thank you for
00:19:07our topic. And we are very happy to
00:19:10have you with us today. Thank you. Thank you. Thank
00:19:14you.
00:19:22The ethics of artificial intelligence are not just a theoretical discussion or
00:19:26a set of rules that are set within companies
00:19:29and institutions, but rather an issue related to human
00:19:32rights, privacy, and dignity, and also to his ability
00:19:36to make conscious decisions in a constantly
00:19:40changing digital world. Artificial intelligence may help us develop
00:19:43education, improve health services, facilitate
00:19:47work, and access information more
00:19:49quickly. But it may also open the door to
00:19:53privacy violations, bias, misinformation,
00:19:56and the use of data in ways that its owners do not realize.
00:20:00Therefore, building
00:20:04not only depend on developing smarter systems,
00:20:07but also requires clear laws,
00:20:10transparency in the operation of systems, accountability of responsible
00:20:13parties, and community
00:20:17this development. Artificial intelligence may be capable
00:20:21of simulating human thinking in many tasks,
00:20:24but the most important question remains: How
00:20:28do we ensure that its use is consistent with
00:20:31our human values? Here we come
00:20:34to the end of this week's episode of Beyond Digital. We will meet you in
00:20:38a new episode. Goodbye.
00:20:39اللقاء.
00:24:29The third news bulletin from Palestine TV begins
00:24:32with the main headlines:
00:24:35five martyrs and wounded in the occupation's
00:24:38shelling of several areas in the Gaza
00:24:41Strip.
00:24:44The occupation demolishes a house south of Bethlehem
00:24:48and withdraws from after
00:24:50an aggression that lasted 11
00:24:53days.